5 ms·
" allowing the middle class to own property, start businesses, etc," Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank
by raverbashing 12y ago
" allowing the middle class to own property, start businesses, etc,"
Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive
I wonder what would happen to property prices if lending was severely restricted, maybe then the value would actually be affordable and not a lifelong debt that becomes unserviceable in the first hiccup
- jljljl 12y agoThe benefits of saving vs. borrowing really depends on the situation, and it's possible that borrowing is actually more beneficial. Let's say I want to save money to buy a house, and I want to pay in cash (i.e., no mortgage). I estimate it will take me about 20 years to afford the house, so I start putting away money from my pay check. However, since I don't have a mortgage and thus no house to live in, I also have to pay rent somewhere. This means I am paying 1/20 the cost of a house + the cost of rent in my city. Additionally, since I won't be buying a house for 20 years, there's a risk that the value of housing could change drastically in that time period, meaning the amount I've saved might not amount to enough to cover the price of housing when I'm finally ready to buy. Obviously the risk of this happening varies by how I invest my savings, and the particularities of the housing market I live in. So the benefit to saving vs. borrowing comes down to something like: (Cost of Housing in 20Years) + (Cost of Rent for 20 Years) - (Gains from Investments) vs. (Cost of Housing Today) + (Interest on Mortgage for 20 years) Obviously there's a lot of other things to take into account, but it's not as simple as Savings Good Debt Bad.
- anon4 12y agoWell to be fair, borrowing with interest works really well only in the presence of endless growth.
- gizmo686 12y agoNot necessarily. Borrowing with interest also works in the presence of endless inflation; it does not necessarily need real growth.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoBut does it work with near-zero inflation or deflation?
- raverbashing 12y agoI agree with your calculation, of course you don't need to save for 20yrs, just save for a good down payment Too bad a lot of people go buy a house on the wrong side of that equation However, owning vs. renting has an interesting hidden cost: you can move "anytime you want" with rent. Renting usually tracks the market affordability/cost more closely, while your mortgage doesn't change while the price go up or down, BUT if the price goes down this might be a problem.
- Sandman 12y agoWell, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive Yeah. Unfortunately this only works if you have enough money after you pay the bills etc. to put aside.
- falcolas 12y agoPlus, saving up the 10-50 thousand dollars (say, to start a restaurant in the US) required to start a business would take a significant chunk of someone's working lifetime. To use a more concrete example, you can't make money weaving cloth when you can't afford a loom.
- wtbob 12y agoI think your numbers are off by an order of magnitude, which makes it even harder to do for someone with few resources.
- rch 12y agoNot really - I know someone in the town where I went to school who opened a coffee shop using a combination of cash and credit cards at that level. She now owns the building the shop is in and a home in Hawaii. Not VC riches or anything, but not bad either.
- rhino369 12y agoA coffee shop isn't a restaurant.
- zo1 12y agoWell, a restaurant isn't the only business venture an individual can get into. Just the other day I saw meme-photo (can't vouch for the validity/truthfulness) about a woman that made money at the beach by attaching balloons filled with margharita mix over her breasts. And charging party-goers (probably mostly male) for the chance to drink out of them. Ridiculous and asinine example, but I bet she started off with no more than a hundred dollars in capital. Which means that entrepreneurship, and ingenuity are what's most important. Capital will follow.
- kryptiskt 12y agoDoing five years of work to get the money you need to capitalize on an opportunity is often not an option.
- paulojreis 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive I think the point here is opportunity. You might be able to afford it in X years and pay no interest, which of course is better, but you may also have to act "now". This is where credit is adequate and needed.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoAlso: time. Imagine a fellow (me, as a student) who hasn't got a washing machine and does his laundry every other week at the coin launderette, which takes several hours, including the time spent on public transport. They could save up the several hundred bucks for a washing machine and buy one in a year (student, limited budget, or just simply poor), or buy one on credit now. As soon as the thing is installed you have two more afternoons each month to get more productive work done. What would you choose?
- skylan_q 12y agosaving money because we're all keynesians now, saving is now evil.
- a3n 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive. Capital idea. I think we should outlaw all lending, to individuals and to corporations. If poor people are expected to save, then it should be even easier for those of much better circumstance and financial ability. Imagine. No more mortgages.
- SixSigma 12y agoIf you didn't borrow from a bank then banks would charge for you to store your money, making your purchases more expensive
- jdmichal 12y ago> Well, there's this crazy concept called "saving money" where you don't borrow from a bank but rather put some money aside every month to be able to afford something expensive That's great, except that everyone is born short housing. You're not trying to afford something expensive, you are trying to cover your short position. And you're either going to do it by buying or renting. And since renting is just throwing the money at someone else, it can make a lot of sense to get into a mortgage instead. (This is why rent vs buy calculators exist.) > I wonder what would happen to property prices if lending was severely restricted, maybe then the value would actually be affordable and not a lifelong debt that becomes unserviceable in the first hiccup Agree on this point. It's a lot like universities and student loans. They have the numbers; they know the average student can afford $x / semester. They also know the average student can take out $y / semester in loans. So what are they going to charge? $(x + y)! Increasing the accessibility of student loans just gives the universities a reason to increase the prices. They don't care how much debt students walk out with; they already got theirs.