6 ms·
> I'm sure he sees absolutely nothing weird in that. If this were a discussion of Japanese conviction rates based primarily on (coerced) confessions or somethi
by gwern 12y ago
> I'm sure he sees absolutely nothing weird in that.
If this were a discussion of Japanese conviction rates based primarily on (coerced) confessions or something like that, then yes, a 99.6% conviction rate would be suspicious. But you have to remember two things here:
(1) 99.6% is not that much higher than the usual federal prosecution rates (I think they get a net of ~96% when I looked it up a few months for a different discussion),
(2) and when Baranoff says “We don’t build our cases on one piece of evidence. Our cases are built on evidence that is curated over many years. We take our time to build these cases to make sure we have them right.” (the part you didn't quote), he's not kidding. That's exactly what they do with cyber-crime cases. They spend years investigating an organization or figure, flipping people, running markets or forums, extracting records from ISPs and Amazon and Google, and so on and so forth. Look at the whole tangle of carding cases in the 2000s with cardingplanet/shadowcrew/etc. For that matter, look at the Ulbricht Silk Road case right now - the agencies involved spent years busting random vendors, looting people's emails (eg Ashley Barr's Gmail was searched on only the vaguest possible suspicion), flipping multiple employees... Read the trial transcripts if you have a few days to spare.
If anything, I'd say that a rate of 99.6% says bad things about them, but for an entirely different reason than you: because it implies that they're inefficiently overdoing their cases, goldplating them & gilding the lily.
- jacquesm 12y agoIs there any substantial difference between coerced confessions and plea bargaining as practiced in the US?
- happyscrappy 12y agoI think you are letting your hatred of the US cloud your judgement. Plea bargaining is mostly a cost saving measure, going to trial is very expensive.
- kghose 12y agoPlease don't feed the trolls.
- ObviousScience 12y agoExcept that I know people who have accepted plea bargains for things that they probably would have prevailed at trial on, because the risk of losing at trial outweighs accepting the plea bargain (or they didn't have the money for a proper defense to refute police misconduct, etc). A particular instance I'm privy to the details of was a friend accepting a bargain on a resisting arrest charge (it probably got reduced to a more minor charge in the bargain) that only led to community service (and probation), when the reality is that the police officer had assaulted the defendant and they were covering it up. It simply wasn't worth the risk of going to jail and the certainty of financial trouble for him and his kids to fight the city on it. But the city got a conviction against a troublesome black, or whatever euphemism they're using these days, and didn't have to admit wrongdoing on the part of a police officer, so all good, right? I'm not saying all plea bargains are bad, I'm just saying that the US makes suspicious use of them and some of them have been noted to be abusive (eg, that they charge ridiculous things for the trial and agree to plea down to what the charges should've been in the first place). I view this as semi-rampant prosecutor misconduct, rather than a fundamental problem with plea bargains, though plea bargains make this kind of misconduct easier, if not otherwise policed.
- jacquesm 12y agoJustice should not be about cost.
- happyscrappy 12y agoIt also costs time. This Russian cracker will plead out.
- malandrew 12y agoYou're assuming guilt. Unless you have some special knowledge of this particular individual, the general ideal we originally strived for in the US Justice system is a belief that individuals are considered innocent until proven guilty. It's fine if you want to believe that yourself, but it's contradictory to how the US justice system is supposed to work. I'm of the opinion that trials should be system where both sides should be allowed to put as much money as they want into a trial, but that they need to put that money into a pot that is divided equally between the defense and prosecution. You cannot have justice when there is financial asymmetry. This would allow trials to be as cheap or as expensive as necessary to determine the truth. It provides a great disincentive for either side to pour money into the process if they know they are in the wrong going into a trial.
- tptacek 12y agoStipulate that some significant portion of the accused are, in fact, guilty. We don't know which ones, but we know in the abstract that they exist. We also know that the overwhelming majority --- not all, but most --- of the guilty accused know they're guilty. In your proposed system, what's the incentive that prevents the guilty accused from allocating infinite resources to their case? Why not do that? These are people who've drawn off-suit seven deuce in the poker game of justice. What would they have to lose?
- jacquesm 12y ago> What would they have to lose? Absolutely nothing, and that's just fine. Let them have their day, even 10 days in court. If they're guilty it will still stick. If not they should walk, no matter how long it takes to get to that point. The way to deal with the overload is a many pronged problem, for one you could decide not to have so many crimes on the books, second you could decide which crimes are to be dealt with using fines and which are to be dealt with using prison time, and prison time could be seen as a measure of correction rather than one of punishment or revenge. That would mean that there would be a lot less prisoners and that in turn would upset a whole pile of applecarts but on the whole that's not a bad system to have. At least you won't have 1% of the population (and 2% of the adult population) behind bars which is generally considered to be a good thing because it takes people out of circulation causing a domino effect into the next generation. Kids of convicts are more likely to become convicts themselves. http://www.tdcj.state.tx.us/gokids/gokids_articles_children_impacted.html http://www.tdcj.state.tx.us/gokids/gokids_articles_children_... Compromising the right to a fair trial on cost basis because you're scared the 'guilty accused' will hog the system has a much higher cost in the longer term.
- crististm 12y agoI think they should just put him in jail. Look at his picture - it's his 'guilty' posture!!!
- Karunamon 12y agoApples and oranges. A "coerced confession" places you under duress, a plea bargain does no such thing.
- inclemnet 12y ago> A "coerced confession" places you under duress, a plea bargain does no such thing. My understanding was that plea bargains are criticised in the context of being offered as an alternative to fighting the case against a very significantly tougher sentence, so that you might win but you're much worse off if you lose. The criticism is then that there is certainly duress - not literally forcing your hand, but forcing a choice that is unreasonable given the nature of the crimes and (so is the claim) encourages confessions by people that are innocent or even just an overall sentencing distribution that ends up being a bad fit for the crimes. I could have understood wrong previous discussion of this though, or perhaps the problematic cases are not widespread.
- Karunamon 12y agoThat's true of any criminal court case though. Imagine for a moment that the bargain wasn't a thing. It's you vs whatever the possible maximum sentence is for what you might be accused of. That hasn't changed. Adding an alternative is not coercion.
- jacquesm 12y agoYou are missing the point here. People that are quite possibly innocent when intimidated with 'plead guilty and you get 5 years or try for innocence and we'll hit you with 50' will choose the 5 years guilty plea because they do not have the power of the state at their disposal to fight. This means that instead of justice being about truth finding it ends up being about conviction rates, which is gamifying the justice system in a way that is very detrimental to society. Couple it with such things as three strikes laws, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison%E2%80%93industrial_complex http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison%E2%80%93industrial_compl... and a system that is punitive rather than corrective and you have a major problem. Plea bargaining could be put to good use but in practice it is used as a means of intimidation and to short-circuit the justice system.
- tptacek 12y agoThe person we're talking about in this thread is accused of a spectacular crime: playing an instrumental role in the theft of millions of identities from several of the largest companies in the world, for profit. What's the role "plea bargaining" plays here? He could legitimately be facing a double-digit custodial sentence no matter how cooperative he is.
- jacquesm 12y agoSince when is being accused equivalent to being guilty because the crime is spectacular? How spectacular a crime is should have very little to do with the judicial proceedings. > He could legitimately be facing a double-digit custodial sentence no matter how cooperative he is. That's roughly the problem right there. For all I know he's as guilty as they come. But on the off chance that he's not guilty there is an extremely large chance that that will never be taken into serious consideration because of the plea bargaining system. It basically makes the justice system a casino where the house wins when you refuse to play and will likely win bigger when you do. Do you truly believe that a Russian 'hacker' on American soil in the current political climate will be given a fair trial?
- tptacek 12y agoI put a really simple question to you, and you responded with a smokescreen of random questions. I won't answer them. I will, however, repeat the question I asked, rephrased an expanded: A 20 year old street level cannabis dealer caught with a couple eighths could be faced with a plea structure requiring them to choose between a felony guilty plea with a 6 month custodial sentence, or a trafficking conspiracy indictment with double-digit years attached to it. That is an unjust predicament to put the accused in†. This person isn't a 20 year old street level cannabis dealer. If this person is guilty, they are guilty of a spectacular offense. What role does plea bargaining have in this case? † The problem isn't the plea bargain, though: it's the outrageous sentence attached to the more severe charge.
- jacquesm 12y agoI started out from the premise that given the prosecutor was boasting the conviction ratio that a fair trial was likely not in the cards. See GGP comment, my questions were in line with that. As for whether or not this person is guilty, my point is that even if he is not he will likely accept a plea bargain because the alternative will be one that is unacceptable. That means his guilt won't enter into the equation at all, it's not as if he's going to win even if not guilty in an all-out confrontation with the DOJ, which is likely exactly what will happen if he does not accept, aka being made an example out of. Whether or not he's a 20 year old street level canabis dealer or someone guilty (partially guilty?) of a spectacular computer crime (which we all know carry penalties roughly in line with similar non-violent white collar crimes) shouldn't make any difference in principle.
- ObviousScience 12y ago> (1) 99.6% is not that much higher than the usual federal prosecution rates (I think they get a net of ~96% when I looked it up a few months for a different discussion), It's an order of magnitude better, which is mildly startling. Instead of losing 40 out of 1000 cases, they're only losing 4 out of 1000 cases. That... would be suspicious change in most statistics.