4 ms·
One of the odd personality changes that I've noticed in myself after 25-ish years on the Internet is that I now have essentially zero tolerance for whinges[1] o
by mcguire 12y ago
One of the odd personality changes that I've noticed in myself after 25-ish years on the Internet is that I now have essentially zero tolerance for whinges[1] of the form: "This one thing he said is completely and utterly wrong, therefore he is a pillock and should be shanked with a shiv.[2] (Well yes, the rest of what he said is perfectly true. But still.)"
Elizabeth Bear's primary complaint seems to be "Andersen is shooting so fast that he doesn't have time for a full draw." This is true. It is the first thing you notice about Andersen's video, after the fact that he's jumping around like a loon. (The fact that he's hitting targets while doing so is a little impressive, isn't it?) She has other complaints about his technique, and about the "viral" video, most of which are also true.
But what makes this rant a spectacular example of what sets off my own particular crab-osity is:
"His tactics, though--speed shooting and so forth--are suited to a shorter recurve [...], which is designed to be shot in motion and from horseback."
...like (although not identical to) the one he's using in the video. So...did she just admit that somewhere between a third and a half of her words are irrelevant to her topic?
Anyway, my bottom line is that I'd rather read a "...Considered Harmful" paper.
[1] A lovely term that I picked up long ago, from the Internet. Oddly, I can remember a significantly isomorphic rant about its use from long ago.
[2] Or shivved with a shank. I don't actually care.
P.S.
GRRR!! Argh! Razzlefrasin'...[3]
I just read Stross's comment,
"Dirk. YELLOW CARD.
"Do not derail, annoy, or otherwise mess with the honourable guest bloggers, or I will be forced to take time out from this very important business trip to kick your ass.
"In particular, do not derail a comment thread with idiotic quibbles before it even gets started. (Broken links, mis-spellings, okay: quibbles, not so much.)
"Am I understood?
"Signed:
"The Mgmt."
Derailing is specifically the point of the article. Idiotic quibbles are the whole raison debris of ye damned thing.
Signed:
Miffed.
[3] Cf. Yosemite Sam.
- nkurz 12y agoYou missed the part where she argued that his approach is wrong because it's impossible to be accurate when using it: "Also having a reliable anatomical point at which to anchor your draw, and a reliable stance, means that you have a reliable point of aim. Incredibly minor alterations in biomechanics--something as invisible as tensing your neck, or not fully broadening your back--can send an arrow wildly off course over distances as short as ten or twenty yards. Something as major as moving your draw point an inch? No freaking telling where that arrow is going." Regardless of how impractical and historically inaccurate his approach might be, do she really believe he has no idea where his arrow is going?
- jdmichal 12y ago> Do she really believe he has no idea where his arrow is going? Has no idea? Of course not. But there's a magnitude of difference between knowing roughly where your arrow is going within 10 to 20 feet, and within 30 to 40 yards. Olympic archers are accurate at 70 yards. Not to mention that longer distances also increasingly force an archer to take into account that arrow trajectory is not going to be a straight line, but an arch both vertically and horizontally.
- mcguire 12y agoPffft. 70 yards? Pikers. Lame-o. Ye olde longbowmen shot at 200-400 yards.[1][2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_longbow#Range https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_longbow#Range [2] http://www.archerylibrary.com/books/badminton/docs/chapter24/chapter24_1.html http://www.archerylibrary.com/books/badminton/docs/chapter24...
- isleyaardvark 12y ago>Elizabeth Bear's primary complaint seems to be "Andersen is shooting so fast that he doesn't have time for a full draw." I didn't take that as her primary complaint. I thought it was quite clear what her main complaint was right at the top: >But he's not actually doing anything we didn't already know about, he's not shooting in a manner that would be at all effective in combat or for the historically more common purpose of feeding his family, and his quiver-handling skills are worthy of the "before" segment of an infomercial. and >Here's the thing. He's basically misrepresenting a bunch of well-known techniques in non-Western-European archery as his own invention or "rediscovery" (bonus cultural appropriation!), and into the bargain, he's not actually putting any strength into that bow of his. To say that his tactics are suited to a shorter recurve supports one of her points, that he isn't showing anything archers didn't know about.
- mcguire 12y ago> "not actually doing anything we didn't already know about" Yeah, that's another one of my pet peeves. "We already knew that" is a wonderful way of shutting down any kind of discussion and it's rather frequently followed by a significant lack of evidence that "we already knew it." Yes, the idiot's techniques, like most "trick shot" things, are completely ineffective at anything useful. But still, which are they, ineffective or "well-known techniques in non-Western-European archery"? Or is non-Western-European archery assumed to be ineffective? And if short-bows and non-Western-European archery are the topic of the day, then what's with the long digression into The Queen Of All Archery, the English longbow? Fortunately, it's Monday and I'm allowed to hate everything.