4 ms·
My Dad used to own one and it was fun to shoot, but I could not imagine dragging it and a few hundred rounds of .45ACP ammo around. Very heavy. He also had a "m
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
My Dad used to own one and it was fun to shoot, but I could not imagine dragging it and a few hundred rounds of .45ACP ammo around. Very heavy. He also had a "mini" one that someone had made that shot .22 caliber ammunition. Much less expensive to shoot and much lighter.
That said, it is more the legacy of the 'machine pistol' (which the Thompson is, given its pistol ammunition) which found service in special forces and security services around the globe, that is interesting to me. Looking at different defense manuals it is amazing just out deadly a modern warfighter is, against a wide variety of opponents, compared to the folks who carried one of these into battle. Like the gap between a cutlass and musket.
- aidenn0 12y agoYou are wrong on the terminology; the line is a bit blurry, a submachine gun is a carbine designed to fire handgun ammunition, wheras a machine pistol is a pistol that is either select-fire or fully-automatic. The Thompson, with a fixed-stock and foregrip is clearly an SMG by that definition. [edit] Here's a machine pistol[1] (though you can get longer barrels and either a foldable or fixed stock, at which point it gets confusing) 1: http://www.thespecialistsltd.com/replica-mac-10 http://www.thespecialistsltd.com/replica-mac-10
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThanks! I've updated my vocabulary appropriately. And after grazing a bit on wikipedia updated my notion of the difference between a sub-machine gun and a machine gun.
- aidenn0 12y agoThe terms confusing enough that I've heard a lot of people completely stop using SMG in favor of "pistol-caliber <rifle/carbine/whatever>"
- hga 12y agoThere are a lot of "pistol-caliber carbines" (which are also by definition rifles) that aren't sub-machine guns. For example civilian versions that are semi-auto only ... and very useful in home defense, since they're more easily aimed thanks to the stock anchoring them on your shoulder (see e.g. dccoolgai's comments, some of his fellows on the firing line were using handguns). Or the WWII M1 Carbine, which not coincidentally was the first weapon system we fielded with exclusively non-corrosive primers. Then there's the new Personal Defense Weapon category, with my favorite (in theory) being the P90. Not intended as a classical SMG, but more for people who's main weapon is not a small arm but say a tank. Short and compact to allow easy bailing out of a burning tank, with ballistics intended to give the bearer the best chance once out in the open.
- davidw 12y ago> warfighter Just out of curiosity, when did this word crop up? To me it seems like some kind of odd DoD invention to supplant more traditional words like "soldier", but I don't know anything about the etymology.
- hga 12y agoMarines are not soldiers, but both are "warfighters" (at least if they're at the sharp end of the stick); ditto SEALs. Perhaps the word is used to avoid getting Marines angry at you ^_^.
- davidw 12y agoOk, fair enough, but it seems recent - I don't think I've ever seen it in connection with anything about, say, WWII. But I'm not exactly knowledgeable about the armed forces beyond listening to the Vicenza base's radio station every now and then :-)
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI saw it come into the lexicon of DARPA RFPs and proposals in the early 90's. It provided a generic term to encompass anyone engaged in the prosecution of the war. So these days it includes pilots sitting in trailers in Nellis AFB driving drones over Afghanistan.