3 ms·
I can remember quite a few university exams where my initial reaction was "What the ^-&%! is this?" - but you had to stay calm [1], work through it and try and
by arethuza 12y ago
I can remember quite a few university exams where my initial reaction was "What the ^-&%! is this?" - but you had to stay calm [1], work through it and try and actually apply the logical thinking you were supposed to be learning.
That question they have a picture of looks like something I could attempt an answer to - and I've never studied economics.
1. The actual advice I remember from my dear old mum was "keep the heid".
- tokai 12y ago>That question they have a picture of looks like something I could attempt an answer to - and I've never studied economics. My thought as well. If we assume that they have been introduced to 'coordination cost', it should be easy to answer. Non of the three sub-questions are even about calculating, they are about discussing the concepts of a very simple model.
- gmarx 12y agoEven if you haven't maybe it is. I might be overly cocky here but it seems obvious what kinds of costs these are and why the simple model is the way it is. Why is the exponent on N greater than 1? Because otherwise coordination costs would decrease as you add more people, right? Are their complaints basically that the exact answer to this question should have been available in the notes and that they shouldn't have to apply past knowledge and techniques to an unfamiliar problem?
- mturmon 12y ago"Because otherwise coordination costs would decrease as you add more people, right?" Not so fast, or you might lose 10 points. ;-) Note that the coordination cost is given per-capita, and it is proportional to N^2. If the per-capita cost was O(N^a) for a < 1, the total cost would still be N*N^a = N^(1+a) which increases with N. If the (per-capita) coordination cost were proportional to N, that would indicate that (e.g.) to do something, you have to contend with "N" other people (everyone else in the population), which makes sense. The total coordination cost would be: (N people) X (per-capita cost of N) = N^2, which is familiar from various kind of networks, e.g., distributed computations in which total communication costs can rise like N^2 (where N is the number of processors). But if the per-capita cost is proportional to N^a for some a > 1, that's even stronger. I'm not sure how you justify that. I'm sure you can, I'm just not sure how the course did it. Maybe you say that you have to coordinate with all N other people, as well as all pairs of the N other people. The number of pairs of other people is proportional to N^2, giving you a per-capita coordination cost proportional to N^2.
- titanomachy 12y agoWithout knowing what coordination cost is, that would be my guess. I'd probably phrase it vaguely like "the cost of coordinating N people is proportional to the number of connections between those people, i.e. proportional to N^2". But that might be less obvious to an econ student who's never studied complexity theory.
- mturmon 12y agoBut I fear, from what you wrote, that you fell into the same trap as @gmarx above. The claim in the exam is that the total coordination cost is above quadratic, i.e. proportional to N^b for some "b" strictly larger than 2. (Because per-capita cost is proportional to N^a for some "a" strictly larger than 1.) This is not what is typically assumed in complexity theory.
- ashark 12y agoI'm terrible at and quite out of practice with math an have nearly no education in economics and it doesn't look that bad. I've got what I judge to be a decent guess at (a) based primarily on knowing what the word "coordination" usually means, my only hang-up with (b) is that I don't know how you get per-capita consumption from the information provided (presumably students in economics do?) and (c) looks a bit tedious but far from impossible. This question does seem more mathy than economicsy, though, in that it looks like a math major could probably do very nearly as well at it as an econ major, if not better.
- Abraln 12y agoAgreed, reminds me of a test I took in a stress analysis class (mechanical engineering at Arizona State University in the US). We had covered thermal expansion of unconstrained objects, as well as those held in certain dimensions by fixed walls. On the exam the professor wanted to cover both so he had the walls placed a small distance away. Most students flipped out because they had not seen an example of that exact situation, but a moment of thinking shows that the problem should be broken into pre-contact an post-contact parts. This professor had the highest drop rate I have seen (around 30%), but his insistence on comprehension over memorization made me learn more than any other class I took. Mobile submission, so please excuse grammar.
- maaarghk 12y agoI agree with yer maw :P. I done a degree in Physics and we would get asked questions like this all the time - unseen, but with the definitions you need included mid sentence. We had our fair share of complaints about professors to make but this seems a little entitled/lazy. shrug
- jules 12y agoI'm certain that when I was in secondary school most of my classmates would be able to answer (b) and (c) of that question since it's a standard 'set derivative equal to zero' question. Part (a) is indeed vague, and they want you to prove something that's incorrect, but it's not hard to see what they want to hear. Ugh, that brings back memories of answering vague questions in such a way that you know will make the teacher happy, but is actually incorrect. I remember one instance where a question on a physics exam asked us to solve a problem that did not have an unique answer (it boiled down to 3 variables and only 2 equations). So I wrote as my answer an explanation why the question could not be solved, which the teacher gave 0 points for. Later in the exam review in class I asked him what the correct answer was, and he gave incorrect reasoning. After I politely pointed out that his answer was incorrect I got 15 minutes of "public shaming" in class about how stupid I was and how dare I disagree with him. Afterwards I sent that question to a physics professor in a university, who also said that the question could not be solved. I sent that to my teacher which only made him more angry. Luckily those days are over.