3 ms·
Aren't these students effectively claiming it's too much to expect them to know basic calculus as they're about to graduate with a degree in economics? That doe
by taylodl 12y ago
Aren't these students effectively claiming it's too much to expect them to know basic calculus as they're about to graduate with a degree in economics? That doesn't seem like a wholly unreasonable expectation to me and if they're unable to do so then what kinds of problems are they expecting to encounter when they get jobs?
Maybe student expectations could have been managed better but I wouldn't think you'd have to explain to economics students preparing to graduate that they should expect to utilize basic calculus during an exam.
- mathieuh 12y agoI've been educated in and am studying in the UK at the moment, and for us exams are meant to examine how well you know the content of the course (or so we're told). If the students are correct in saying that the exam contained questions regarding things they'd never seen or had experience of before, then in my opinion the exam was unreasonable. Throughout my entire academic career exams have worked this way, so regardless of whether they ought to know it for The Real World, if they haven't been taught it then it shouldn't have been on the exam.
- deong 12y agoMy first impression looking at the questions was that they were intended to take the knowledge they had gained during the course and apply it to what may have been an unfamiliar circumstance. Done correctly, that's a completely fair exam. I'm sort of inclined to think that if there's this much smoke, something's probably on fire though. I know my own students will complain about silly things, but if they all complain about something, invariably I end up agreeing with them.
- basseq 12y agoThat's an apt comparison: if no (or painfully few) students were able to give at least a reasonable answer, the problem lays in the teaching curriculum or methodology. (This may not be the course itself, it may be a broader question about hand-holding an academia or similar, but the question remains.) I remember a particular instance in Geometry in high school. Everyone did poorly, so the teacher allowed us to work together to answer the questions again. My group was stuck on a particular question, so I asked the teacher to clarify. She refused, saying we were taught it. I retorted that since everyone was struggling, clearly the problem was on the other side of the desk. (It went over about as well as you might expect.)
- arethuza 12y agoWell my experience getting a degree in the UK in the 1980s was that exams would often contain questions in a different form from what you had seen before - you did know how to answer them but it definitely wasn't trivial to identify what techniques to apply to solve each question. I get the feeling that people now expect questions to be of the form "apply technique X to data A,B,C" which is what I used to expect of secondary school level exams.
- aquadrop 12y agoDidn't they experience exponents? Maybe multiplication should also be out of questions? Its their final year, I don't think phrases like "third question could be as well in chinese" is suited here.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoFrom TFA: As well as students taking a BSc in economics, the paper was sat by students taking a joint BA honours with other subjects, such as politics. The head of the economics department, Prof Andy Dickerson, said not all the questions were mathematically based. "Those that had mathematical content were set at a level consistent with the maths taught to all economics students, including those on dual degrees."
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoI like the irony of an econ course asking students to model economic consequences in an exam, but failing to model the economic consequences of pissing off its students so much it makes the national news.
- mikecb 12y agoIn addition, lots of topics in undergraduate econ might require require partial differentiation to derive, but not to understand, explain, or compute them.