6 ms·
I feel like a fraud and that’s a good thing
- rudolf0 12y agoIt's a lot easier to handle feeling like a fraud when you receive no negative feedback with overwhelming positive feedback, and are very confident regarding a certain domain. If someone feels like a fraud even in their "core competency", that can create a lot of unneeded stress and anxiety in their life. But I agree that intellectual humility is very important to self-growth.
- Zikes 12y agoI think the author might have conveyed their point more accurately using the word impostor, rather than fraud. It would also better fit the documented phenomena: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impostor_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impostor_syndrome I've seen third-hand quite a few instances where people are publicly challenged, even harassed, for their not performing their core competency to someone else's (or even everyone's) standards. Recently one public figure announced they were now seeing a therapist, presumably due in part to that overwhelming negative feedback.
- JimboOmega 12y agoHonestly - this is part of why looking for jobs is so very hard, which is what the author mentions right at the beginning. There are lists of requirements you know you don't meet, and often times you apply, and for reasons that may have nothing to do with how skilled you are, you don't get the job. Maybe you have a few rounds of interviews that seem to go great, but there's no offer. You start to wonder if your language/skillset is over the hill, if you really aren't so good at code, heck, maybe YOU are too old in SV years. Something about the job search process really amplifies this feeling. You never know why they think it isn't a fit - but it's only in searching for a job that you are actually getting some external feedback. And it's tough. Even if your skillset is in demand and recruiters are crawling all over each other to make you offers, if the companies you really love aren't among them, it makes you wonder. It's tough. And it's easier to play the games and engage the behavior the author talks about to get "likes", hacker news upvotes, reddit upvotes, whatever, to let you know your views, your languages, your skills are valid. It's tough out there.
- emsy 12y agoI've recently tried to get some projects. The required skills are almost always ridiculously specific. It's not unusual that the projects descriptions want you to be an expert in the whole software stack and the project domain. This is a grave problem because people who feel like impostors lose projects to intentional impostors. There are some ways to tackle this problem, but I think it hurts companies and honest developers more than it needs to.
- johansch 12y agoAnother self promoting "evangelist". Please save us from their spam. The way to get your stuff noticed (and hence the approval of your manager) should be posting stuff with actual valuable content. Not tabloid meta teasers like this one.
- delluminatus 12y agoI thought this was going to be a humblebrag -- and boy, it sure started out that way -- but I was pleasantly surprised by the end. It made me think about how some tools, libraries, or frameworks seem to prefer to use buzzwords or neologisms to make simple things seem complicated. As though by obfusticating the problem domain, they can make their solution seem that much more magnificent. As though the docs should make you feel stupid. And the reason they do this is because in our industry, it works. Things often seem impressive to the degree that they seem complicated. People are "advertising" their stuff by making it seem like a special snowflake instead of a simple thing. Far be it from me to blame people for doing something that works. But there is a bit of an echo chamber, especially in this forum, where developers -- developers, not marketers, not "suits" -- prefer to use buzzwords over plain language, and they would rather you think they did something complicated than something simple or something solid.
- analyst74 12y agoThat is a natural problem in our industry. It requires far more skills to write simple code to solve complicated problems than to write complicated code to solve such problems. What makes it worse is once your head is fully immersed in the problem space, the line between simple and complicated becomes blurry, and what seems like simple solution at the time may seem overly complicated to someone who has not gone through the same thought process.
- leesalminen 12y agoI agree with your point about the obfuscation of simplicity and complexity. I've been thinking about that a lot lately.
- nogridbag 12y agoI agree but I'd also like to add that most of the time the complexity for me using some frameworks, libraries, or tools has nothing to do with code but instead in the prerequisites for using them. The authors of some tools make certain assumptions about your knowledge of the whole ecosystem around the tool or supporting tools. Here's a few examples that have caused me pain: Some time ago, an upgrade to Foundation framework required NodeJS and Ruby 1.9+, a version not preinstalled on my Mac. OK, at the time I knew nothing about NodeJS and have never used Ruby, how hard could it be? 5-10 minutes max? - NodeJS installed fine, but I had to use "sudo" to install modules or I'd see errors - Googled... many people used "nvm". I installed nvm, had some issues, but in the end all worked fine - Next, Ruby. "rvm" is popular, I'll try that. - rvm installation failed with a cryptic error message, Googled message... - I need to install "command line tools" which come with Xcode - I don't have Xcode and apparently it's several GB, after an hour or more I finished downloading it. - I had to open Xcode, find some random preferences panel and click some button to install "command line tools" - rvm installation still did not work, Googled.... many people use Homebrew - installed Homebrew, ruby 2.x installed (with strange warnings) but showed 2.x in the console - Foundation tools did not work - Googled how to uninstall Homebrew, found some random "gist" script some guy made which does scary things on my system - Tried installing rvm again, and for a reason unknown to me, it was successful! - Foundation tools still did not work - Didn't notice, last two line of rvm installation required me to copy/paste two lines into the shell. Great, now I can use Foundation in my Grails project that has nothing to do with Ruby or NodeJS. This whole process took ~6 hours, half of the time I spent just googling error messages. More recently, I couldn't figure out how to properly package/bundle my React app into a single minified JS file with browserify. The docs linked to a nice simple template: https://github.com/petehunt/react-browserify-template https://github.com/petehunt/react-browserify-template The package.json has a few useful commands in the "scripts" section: "scripts": { "start": ... "build": ... } "npm start" works fine, so why isn't "npm build" working!?!? I posted on stackoverflow and got no answers. Ten days later I figured it out. Knowing very little about npm I had no idea "npm start" was a shortcut for "npm run-script start" and thus I needed to do "npm run-script build".
- Mz 12y agoFWIW to the author of this piece: I don't know who you are and googling did not turn up a Wikipedia page. So that makes me think you aren't really FAMOUS, no matter how many people online or in tech might know of you. The song "Thank you" by Alanis Morissette comes to mind. She hit it big at a young age. She wisely did not want to suffer the fate that stars like Meatloaf suffered when he hit it big young and then crashed and burned. Overwhelmed by her fame and success, she took a sabbatical and stopped singing. She found her voice again while visiting India, where she was surrounded by throngs of people, none of whom knew here. It was a good antidote to the ills of fame. It's a big wide world.
- davidcgl 12y agoI think you're missing the point. He's not writing about undeserved fame or status.
- Mz 12y agoNo, I don't think so. I am talking about human psychology and having perspective. This seems to be a common theme on HN: People here have tunnel vision. There is a lot more to the world than Hacker News and folks in tech and so on. I participate here regularly and I spend a lot of time online. Yet, I did not know this person's name. I am not inner circle enough for his name to have caught my attention before. Also, Alanis Morissette's fame was not undeserved. Neither was Meatloaf's. But thank you for commenting.
- sprkyco 12y agoWithout googling around I found this link at the end of the story that validates, in my opinion, your misplaced concerns. http://icant.co.uk/ http://icant.co.uk/ http://developer-evangelism.com/ http://developer-evangelism.com/
- Mz 12y agovalidates, in my opinion, your misplaced concerns I apologize, but I cannot parse that. Are you saying that the links validate my point of view? Or validates your opinion that I am in error? I just can't make heads nor tails of what that phrasing is supposed to convey. thx
- Bahamut 12y agoI am fortunate to have already experienced the "Do I belong here?" feeling from graduate school. The thing to remember is this - there are always people who are going to be ahead of you just by virtue of having more experience. How you carry yourself is the most important thing though. In this context, if you see someone who is better than you at the moment, do some work trying to improve yourself and your abilities. The best don't become the best instantaneously - they do it through hard work & maybe a little talent. My own experience probably has helped me take on the correct perspective in my own career as a developer - I do things purely because I want to do it or improve myself. I don't care about being the most popular/well-known developer or anything like that - it is a job that I happen to like is all. Stars/likes/etc. on GitHub, those don't matter. I create stuff for fun, and if it becomes popular, so be it - I work on open source stuff in the hopes it helps people and to improve my own abilities.
- jarcane 12y agoIronically, one of the projects I created with what would seem like the least amount of practical use also got the most positive feedback. Sometimes when you just do what you want for fun and self-edification, it results in a project that shows more passion and finesse than something banged out for more cynical purposes. It's one of the things I struggle most with, besides the relentless self-consciousness that comes from being a 33-yo trying to retrain in a technical profession, is feeling like all that stuff I love has rather minimal crossover with the stuff that might pay the bills ...
- delluminatus 12y agoI remember that feeling in my upper-division math classes in college -- PDEs, abstract algebra, etc. It seemed to me like I was struggling (which was a new experience for me in math class) and to make it worse, I sat next to this guy who always seemed to know it cold. I would score in the 80s on almost everything, and I would look over there and this guy would have perfect scores all the time. It definitely bothered me. About halfway through the semester I ended up spending more time with this guy and I realized that he really lived and breathed mathematics. I mean, he did all the exercises in every chapter. (Who does that?) He would study for hours and hours before tests. Anyway, it kind of taught me a lesson. If you want to belong, you have to work for it. Nobody's just going to move over to make a space for you. You have to carve a space for yourself.
- jbrooksuk 12y agoI missed Christians post about moving to Microsoft, so this was a nice read, especially seeing how worried he seems about it. I did a talk back in November which included a section on "Imposter Syndrome". The video can be found here; https://james-brooks.uk/staffs-web-meetup-video/ https://james-brooks.uk/staffs-web-meetup-video/
- gjcourt 12y agoThis guy literally "wrote the book" that taught me javascript. One of the best resources that I've ever used to this day. Kudos on the new job.
- nogridbag 12y agoThis article really resonates with me. Most of my coworkers seem perfectly happy to simply show up, do their work and go home and have no desire to seek to improve their craft. Sometimes I wish I could be like them. I have this thirst for knowledge and to improve my skills, which is why I'm here reading HN. But it is really overwhelming at times trying to keep up with everything here and at times I can't help but feel inferior to others at times. I spent several years using GWT and now I'm getting compensated very nicely to work on an multiple ExtJS products. To keep from getting left behind I've toyed with Angular, React, Mithril, mercury, Redis, etc. and my queue of things to learn keeps getting larger and larger (Docker, Vagrant, Sandstorm, most of AWS stack, ...). At this point I probably have at least 200 bookmarks tagged with a generic "Programming" label. When I'm responsible for the architecture for real systems, I sometimes feel like a fraud. Domain driven design, TDD, CQRS, anemic vs rich domain models, functional vs OO, agile... do I really know what I'm doing? Does anyone know what they're doing? I recently looked back at some code from some senior level architects I worked with when I was still relatively junior - guys I really respected. Some of those projects had truly awful architecture and I must admit I felt a bit better about myself after seeing that code.
- jhildings 12y agoNot much to add, but I feel quite the same. There is a list of neverending things that one is supposed to learn ;P
- marktangotango 12y agoThe secret is to learn what you need to know when you need to know it. I recently had to use some new js framework hotness; spend a couple days reading blogs, tutorials, and the docs, learn what you need to be productive and move on. Then dump it all, and jack in the next big thing for the next project. Rinse repeat. No one knows it all, no one expects you too. You are expected to learn, get up to speed, semi independently and with little direction. It gets easier after you've done it a few times, then it get really old.
- getdavidhiggins 12y agoI've been following Chris' work for years, and I think he articulates this 'trying too hard' nonsense you see everywhere on Github. Like we can make a 3D cube in HTML and make it spin, but people can't buy a ticket to fly to another country without what feels like a case study in dark patterns, usability issues, and horrific a11y issues. All code is energy, and if it's squandered in the wrong places, you get an imbalance. The net effect of engineers getting carried away in a lab is ― you get kids learning how to make their first website thinking that code is some dark art, and some black magic. It's not. <b>Look ma, no GruntJS</b> It's rather simple stuff. That said, any time I read the words "Impostor Syndrome", I think of agony aunt sections in newspapers, and open teen diaries, not learning how to style a bullet point with CSS, or improving my craft.
- heywire 12y ago> What you do is compare your secret blooper reel with the post-production highlight reel of other people. You know more about yourself than anyone else. What a great quote.
- Terr_ 12y agoVariations on "bloopers vs highlights" have been around for a while, I'm not sure who (if anybody) was the original source.
- tricolon 12y agoHere's something in the same vein that I use to cheer myself up every now and then: http://www.viruscomix.com/page528.html http://www.viruscomix.com/page528.html
- FLUX-YOU 12y ago>Feeling like a fraud keeps you humble, it keeps you sane, it keeps you on your toes. Or it just erodes your self confidence until you're committing fixes that miss obvious details which then goes to production and breaks things. Now I'm just stuck in a positive feedback loop and frankly I don't think I'll be able to justify my pay in 6 months.
- nitrogen 12y agoSounds like you need a vacation. Pick one of the next three weekends, reserve a hotel, pack a bag (and family, if appropriate) and just drive off. When you get back, start writing integration tests for your project's "happy path" to catch those kinds of mistakes.
- FLUX-YOU 12y agoHonestly, if I need a vacation after 6 months, I don't think I'm cut out for this work/this company.
- Bahamut 12y agoIt depends. I got caught in crunch time at my current company and needed a vacation bad after 3 months. It ended up coming a little later, but I got copious vacation in order to get back to normal (~3 weeks).
- tinco 12y agoIs six months a short time? Maybe it's because I'm European but six months sounds like a really long time to go without even a short vacation.
- larrymcp 12y agoHaven't taken a vacation in about three years. It hasn't occurred to me to do so! Love my job so much.
- mytochar 12y ago
- vijayboyapati 12y agoThis article felt very validating for me. I've always done well at school (4.0 in college), on various tests and at work, but it never registered and I've always felt like a bit of an impostor. When I was an engineer at Google I particularly had this feeling because I couldn't really build anything. Well, strictly speaking that wasn't true; what I mean was that my job was so pigeon holed that I only knew how to do specific things really well. I couldn't, for example, setup a basic web business with a database backend (horror!). After I joined YC I had to go through the process of learning about all the tools that were available that would help me piece together a product without having Google's giant infrastructure behind me, and without the help of internal technical mailing lists where any question could be quickly and expertly answered. This was quite daunting, but also enormously gratifying. I finally learned that I can build entire products on my own and have a sense for a full development stack and how to e.g., inter-operate a crawler and an indexer and a frontend, and how to host the whole thing. But even after doing this, I still feel like an impostor! I think this feeling will probably never leave me, but as the author says it can be beneficial. But I think I (and others who suffer from this) need to be mindful of the downsides of this syndrome: the reluctance to ask questions for fear of seeming incompetent. The difficulty in approaching new problems for fear the new knowledge involved might be insurmountable. And of course the general sense of self doubt that afflicts those with impostor syndrome.
- Animats 12y agoI finally learned that I can build entire products on my own and have a sense for a full development stack and how to e.g., inter-operate a crawler and an indexer and a frontend, and how to host the whole thing. I've done that. Now all the technologies I'm using are obsolete. I have Python 2.7 code using FCGI and a MySQL database running on dedicated servers, pushed to the server with Dreamweaver. Works fine. Needs very little attention. But it's totally obsolete. I need to learn a bunch of new technologies to do the same thing. And they're boring.
- task_queue 12y agoCongratulations, you have a low maintenance system built on solid technology. New isn't better, especially when it's rehashing the same problem that was solved decades ago.
- drawkbox 12y agoVery good article on some of the more plastic or marketed aspects of tech, over what really building good systems and products is about.
- mproud 12y agoI’m in the exact opposite spot. For me it’s becoming a bad thing. • Lack of confidence • Lack of self-esteem • Lack of aggressiveness • Lack of fearlessness I’m much too humble and too honest. Although these are great personal qualities, and can help when working in groups, in the end they do not get you very far, nor quickly, in business.
- placebo 12y agoThe article touches some of the core things I ponder when trying to keep on top of the latest and greatest in the tech world and deciding how to distribute my finite time and energy, and many issues resonated with my feelings on some of the high tech trends. I disagree however that feeling like a fraud is a good thing (unless you are one) and strongly believe there are much better motivators for studying and being great at something than the fear of others being better than you. I think it is exactly this fear which is at the heart of what enables the emperor's new clothes syndrome to flourish. Of course, in addition to the hype and buzz there are also a growing amount of authentic great new technologies, but you can't hope to learn them all. The best you can do is know about them so that you'll be able to retrieve them and dive deeper if and when they become relevant to something you need to implement.
- ryan-allen 12y agoI'm not entirely sure that programmers should be advising us on psychological issues based on personal anecdotes.
- Animats 12y agoThat's the human side of "meet the new technology, same as the old technology". There are a vast number of levels of cruft to master to do anything now. They're constantly changing. This used to be the issue with GUI toolkits, most of which do roughly the same thing. Now it's more server-side. Lately, it seems that the complexity is not in the code that actually does the work, but in the packaging systems. The amount of packaging seems to increase over time. Here's a presentation comparing four build systems for Javascript: http://jbavari.github.io/JavascriptBuildSystemShowdown http://jbavari.github.io/JavascriptBuildSystemShowdown This is for a language that is deployed as source code. What's wrong with this picture? There's lots of new, exciting stuff that actually does something, like machine learning or vision processing. That's worth learning. Having to learn another build and deployment system, or worse, being expected to know it to get a job, is just wearing.
- fndrplayer13 12y agoI think the sphere of technology where he's focused (frontend) is particularly fast moving right now. It is extremely humbling to read about somebody like this feeling this way. I know many developers, myself included, experience these pangs of inadequacy on a frequent basis. It would be hard not to, things move fast and everyone around us is talented and smart. But, just like anyone else, I think this article reminds us that we're all human, no matter how talented, and open to feeling inadequate. There's always more to know, more to achieve. But its good to pause and focus on the skills we have sometimes to be grateful for what we've done.