3 ms·
> We haven't thus far. And we've had the capability for a while. Care to present some evidence or a rational argument that we will? Signs point to the contrary.
by danso 12y ago
> We haven't thus far. And we've had the capability for a while. Care to present some evidence or a rational argument that we will? Signs point to the contrary.
I'm going to assume your argument is not merely, "Well, we haven't yet destroyed ourselves, so therefore, we aren't capable of doing that"...because then my response will just be, "Well, we haven't yet developed AI, so therefore, we aren't capable of doing that"...and so your counter-argument is based on a different interpretation of history than mine: I think the decades of Cold War and the near-misses we had with all-out nuclear war are examples of situations in which we have the potential to quickly wipe ourselves out without the help of AI. Others would point out the trend of mass surveillance -- again, implemented and controlled by humans and human institutions -- of a harbinger of doom.
Keep in mind that I'm not saying that technology has reached its peak. I am very open to the idea that we could reach a point of semi-autonomous systems, and yet still have human institutions as faulty as they are now, and the combination of both will result in a threat greater than what we've faced so far.
- maratd 12y ago> I'm going to assume your argument is not merely, "Well, we haven't yet destroyed ourselves, so therefore, we aren't capable of doing that" What? Read what I wrote again. "We haven't thus far. And we've had the capability for a while." We've had the capability for a while. That means we're clearly capable. That's what capability means. The fact that we haven't is supporting evidence that we won't. Because we've had the capability but have not used it. Which is historical evidence against our using it. Which is not a guarantee that it won't happen, just an indication that it won't.