4 ms·
And what about the Alien Fundamentalists? There is this assumption that Aliens would be atheist, but that's actually pretty unlikely considering religion is on
by ars 12y ago
And what about the Alien Fundamentalists?
There is this assumption that Aliens would be atheist, but that's actually pretty unlikely considering religion is one of the human universals.
- krapp 12y agoThere's no reason to believe it likely that religion is a constant elsewhere, though, since humanity is the only data point we have. Both assumptions are just projections of human bias, without any basis in fact.
- ars 12y agoDon't some theorize that Neanderthals had religion? Humanity is also the only data point we have that intelligent life is possible. If you are going to theorize that it exists elsewhere you have to include everything else that is universal for humans or you are being intellectually dishonest. You can't just pick and choose which universal things you think would exist elsewhere and which wouldn't.
- belorn 12y agoThere is a theory that explains this, which says it is a by-product from a survivalist psychology in children. "children who believe their elders when they say things like "don't go swimming in the river; there are alligators there who will eat you" are more likely to survive than children who insist on finding out for themselves. Such unquestioning belief has drawbacks, like occasionally believing something that isn't true, but these drawbacks are minor compared to the advantage of not dying young." - The God Delusion
- krapp 12y ago>If you are going to theorize that it exists elsewhere you have to include everything else that is universal for humans or you are being intellectually dishonest. No I don't, because I don't assume that, if life exists elsewhere, it necessarily evolved to resemble humanity in any particular way. Just because two genetically related hominid species from the same planet might have had religion doesn't mean a sentient starfish from Proxima Centauri probably does as well. I'm not picking and choosing universal traits, i'm arguing that nothing we know about life, or humans, can be assumed to be universal. We don't know how normal or abnormal we are.
- tbrownaw 12y agoThere's no reason to believe it likely that religion is a constant elsewhere, though Religion is a natural side-effect of our various cognitive biases (make inferences on too little data; assume the familiar; don't constantly try to invalidate what you already know). These are all shortcuts that allow us to save either time or expensive brainpower. So you can only not get religion if those resources aren't constrained (to the point that wasting them has no impact on evolutionary fitness). since humanity is the only data point we have. Both assumptions are just projections of human bias, without any basis in fact. Inductive reasoning is fallacious. Always. But in practice, it often still works well enough. At least if you put enough thought into designing your model.