3 ms·
My understanding from the linked paper in another thread, is not to do it the way Spivak does. That is, the article says Lamport "walked us through a proof of
by taeric 12y ago
My understanding from the linked paper in another thread, is not to do it the way Spivak does. That is, the article says Lamport "walked us through a proof of a corollary to the mean value theorem from that textbook, pointing out statements that he felt were not precise or rigorous enough and rewriting the proof using his technique."
My reading of that is that Lamport found faults in Spivak's approach. Did I missread that?
I will say that this really looks like a way to write proofs for computers to read, moreso than a way to write them for other people. Probably has great value, but not too surprising that it isn't widespread.
- TylerJay 12y agoNo, you didn't misread it. You can see the example for yourself in the paper. It's Section 2 here: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/lamport/pubs/proof.pdf http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/lamport/pubs/p...
- j2kun 12y agoI also read through Lamport's critique and I'm not convinced by it. The 'errors' he points out are trivial, and the cultural assumption is that an active reader will fill in the omitted details.