3 ms·
The money insiders make would otherwise go to other parties/counterparties when the news became public. Insiders charge a rent on everyone else. So do non-ins
by cma 12y ago
The money insiders make would otherwise go to other parties/counterparties when the news became public. Insiders charge a rent on everyone else. So do non-insiders doing above-board sales research, but they are subject to competition, keeping the rent/tax down.
In addition to the rent, there is also a benefit provided in accurately pricing securities, but there is no law of economics saying this benefit will exactly cancel out the rent or anything of the sort.
There are fundamental things (like limited number of sufficiently high-level insiders) restricting competition in conventional insider trading to minimize the rent charged from insider "research".
- savanaly 12y agoIs it a transfer of income, or a genuine loss of resources? It seems like the losses to everyone else are offset one to one by the gains to the insider traders.
- notahacker 12y agoIt's not a zero-sum game if the effects are a disincentive to invest on the part of parties without strong connections to insiders.
- cma 12y agoYes, a transfer. What I meant by other parties/counterparties is that a sale that went to an insider might instead go to the next highest bidder, and the gains once the good earnings news was released would go to him or her. Or the absence of the insider might mean the bid never goes high enough and the seller stays with the shares, to later make the gain. Zero sum, but basically all the normal market participants are avoiding a "presence of an insider" tax when insider trading can be curtailed.
- notahacker 12y agoNon-insiders doing above-board research also don't have perverse incentives; they can't profit from selling intelligence on their own screwups (accidental or otherwise)