3 ms·
Defecting on vaccination is perfectly rational if you expect everyone else to cooperate and never meet another defector. You get all the benefits of herd immun
by saalweachter 12y ago
Defecting on vaccination is perfectly rational if you expect everyone else to cooperate and never meet another defector. You get all the benefits of herd immunity while taking on none of whatever slight risk of complications there may be.
It's pretty straight-forward game theory, which must be met with equally straight-forward strategies: defectors must be punished.
- mcguire 12y agoOne of the few good things about the article is that it demonstrates that the simplistic game theory approach doesn't work: defection isn't uncorrelated. The year's larger outbreaks of measles are in groups that have all defected together. Herd immunity doesn't apply because the defectors have a closely related sub-herd through which the disease spreads quickly. (On the other hand, it does apply when the disease tries to pass out of the community and cannot. Hm.)
- Ygg2 12y agoHopefully, the measles spread and the defector groups get wiped out - either through acquired immunity, higher vaccination rates or death.
- saalweachter 12y agoYou could probably treat each defector-cluster as an individual. As long as they remain isolated and never shake hands with another defector (eg, an unvaccinated missionary visiting a country with a disease reservoir) they're fine.