3 ms·
But don't insider trading rules apply even to people with no real agency power? A secretary who overhears that a drug trial failed is not in a position to affec
by snowwrestler 12y ago
But don't insider trading rules apply even to people with no real agency power? A secretary who overhears that a drug trial failed is not in a position to affect how the company reacts to that information, and probably does not have enough capital to move the stock. But she would still be violating insider trading laws if she sold all her stock before the press release was issued.
I can see why professional traders and speculators might not want to level the playing field, but I don't see why long-term investors would feel that way. When I invest in stocks, I intend to hold for a long time. I'm betting on the business success of that company or group of companies, not on inequalities in the availability of information about them.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's not in the interests of long-term investors to keep advantaged traders out of the market. The alternative to the participation of informed investors is mispricing. Fundamentals investors want prices to reflect actual value, too.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI feel like this begs the question of information inequality, though. If all traders were equally informed, then mispricing would be avoided as well. And without the complexity of trying to infer information from the trades of others. Isn't this what insider trading laws try to do? The law obviously can't keep insiders from learning information first, so the law prohibits insiders from acting as investors until the info is public. At worst this creates a lag between information and price, but that wouldn't matter much to long-term investors. Not that insider trading laws can create total information awareness for every investor. But at least it gives every investor a more equal opportunity to find and use information. minor edit for clarity
- tptacek 12y agoThe laws keep insiders from doing that, but it does not prevent other people from amassing non-public data through research, investigation, or financial modeling. Instead, the law protects the products of those activities as trade secrets, thus enshrining into law the idea that some traders do in fact get to be advantaged with non-public information.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI'm having a hard time thinking of non-public data that would be legal to trade on. The examples in the article and this thread all seem like public information. Anyone can observe a sales floor, or a parking lot, or a store entrance. Anyone can observe the IR radiation coming off oil tanks. Anyone can observe tweets. Anyone with the time and means to do so, anyway. Anyone could do these things; but most don't. For the people who do, what is protected is their investment in gathering and analyzing the data. The law does not grant Person A access to the data set of Person B--true--but the question is whether Person B could do their own work to gather the same data set. Whereas information that is only available, in any form, to Person A would be considered non-public, and not legal to trade on.
- mwerd 12y agoI've always heard this called mosaic theory, not trade secrets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_theory_%28investments%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_theory_%28investments%2...
- lmm 12y ago> I feel like this begs the question of information inequality, though. If all traders were equally informed, then mispricing would be avoided as well. And without the complexity of trying to infer information from the trades of others. If all traders were equally informed (perhaps by a law that any information you wanted to trade on had to be public), there would be no way for people to profit by digging up new information. We (society) like it that analysts have a financial incentive to figure out the truth about how well a company is doing - whether that be by coming up with a better model of how one industry affects another (which will ultimately lead to better allocation of resources), or doing the legwork to realise that a particular company is a massive fraud (which leads in a more direct/obvious way to better allocation of resources). But we don't want them to just bribe insiders - that causes agent-principal problems, gives certain market participants unfair advantages, and all the rest of it. Hence the law, where figuring out these things through research is encouraged, but getting them from insiders is illegal.