4 ms·
Anything you say today, however innocent, is potential "evidence" against you by a later government. "Your Honor, the accursed is on record, and admits, that he
by a3n 12y ago
Anything you say today, however innocent, is potential "evidence" against you by a later government. "Your Honor, the accursed is on record, and admits, that he regularly voted for the Repugnicratic party. Why, he even admits to giving them money!"
Any personal fact collected and stored, however politically or criminally innocuous, is potentially retrievable by criminals breaching the storage system.
It doesn't matter how pure of heart today's collectors may be; if it's not observed or collected today then it can't be abused tomorrow.
- explorigin 12y agoCase in point: Brenden Eich
- SaltyMaia 12y agoIf there isn't anything inherently wrong with collecting, and future abuse is the only thing you are worried about, then you should probably worry about protecting against abuses, not collecting. Especially if you have no other point to be had for privacy, when the opposition claims unobjected that giving it up can and does save lives. That said, I think the criminal breach argument is a valid one but the one that really nails it is one already mentioned above: "privacy isn't something you can just give up. It's a right given to society by our framers, not individuals. A smoothly functioning democracy depends on dissent, which requires privacy to allow alternate points of view to gain traction. So privacy is a social good, not a personal right, and if we reduce privacy, we are reducing our democracy. The Soviets didn't have privacy. Free countries must." Sans the soviet part, in my opinion... Seems useless and even fallaciously counter-productive to mention it, I don't get why it's even there edit: What I mean by the first paragraph, in case it's not clear, is that most technologies can and probably will be abused, which doesn't go a long way to say that they should be forbidden right at the start, if there is good to be had in them. You just have to be careful not to allow abuses (which by your post I figured you don't think are happening at this moment)
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> What I mean by the first paragraph, in case it's not clear, is that most technologies can and probably will be abused, which doesn't go a long way to say that they should be forbidden right at the start, if there is good to be had in them. You just have to be careful not to allow abuses (which by your post I figured you don't think are happening at this moment) Collecting data isn't a technology, it's a use of a technology. And preventing mass data collection is how you disallow abuse. The vast majority of the productive use of e.g. location tracking data is possible when you have the data on yourself and nobody has mass data on everyone. The things that are only possible with bulk data collection are almost universally bad.
- LordKano 12y agoI remind everyone of Brendan Eich. He donated money to a popular political cause and a few years later, after the political winds have shifted, a leak about this lead to him being forced out of his job. A lot of people are alright with this because the find Eich's position to be repugnant. Maybe it was but that's not the point. They need to remember that sometimes, they're not going to agree with the herd and it well could be them on the chopping block. Ubiquitous surveillance will make future McCarthy-style witch hunts possible and arguably it even makes them likely.