6 ms·
OK. Maybe I don't get this, but doesn't framing this as a "war" make the situation even worse? Isn't viewing the opposite gender as "enemy combatants" a really
by falcolas 12y ago
OK. Maybe I don't get this, but doesn't framing this as a "war" make the situation even worse? Isn't viewing the opposite gender as "enemy combatants" a really terrible thing to do?
I would think that women face enough challenges in their workplace without being viewed by their coworkers as being hostile and out for their livelihoods.
Maybe I have this all wrong, but this seems that "news" pieces like this do not help anybody but the media (though perhaps it makes those on either side of the gender divide who already view the others as enemy combatants feel validated).
- saraid216 12y ago> Isn't viewing the opposite gender as "enemy combatants" a really terrible thing to do? Except that's not what's happening. The war is between the ideology that genders are equal and the ideology that genders are not equal. Framing it the way you have is a standard tactic employed by people who are entirely aware they are at war and have set up feminists as enemy combatants already.
- nl 12y agoThe war is between the ideology that genders are equal and the ideology that genders are not equal. I think a better summary would be this: The war is between the ideology that genders should have equal opportunities and the ideology that genders should not.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoI don't think anyone outside certain religions[1] asserts that genders should not have equal opportunities. Could you link to such a person? A better statement: The war is between the ideology that individual humans should have equal opportunities, and the ideology that certain groups should be statistically equally represented in all fields. (Or sometimes it's all fields that result in "power", a poorly defined term.) [1] Interestingly, those religions usually have more women than computing. I've never been to a church where women didn't outnumber men.
- saraid216 12y agoSince you're obfuscating, I want to clarify that your "better statement" is not a restatement of what I said. It's a disagreement.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoYes, I'm disagreeing. I guess my phrasing was unclear, my apologies. Again, if you can link to people of any significance who openly state opposition to equal opportunity for individuals, it would be fairly convincing.
- geofft 12y agoWhat does "equal opportunity" mean? https://inclusiveactioneverydaylives.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/40824_176008489215668_1643818166_n1-e1367896308468.jpg https://inclusiveactioneverydaylives.files.wordpress.com/201... Is it equal opportunity to see the baseball game, or equal opportunity to pick up a crate? There are certainly people who state opposition to each of these forms, although they each tend to say they support "equal opportunity," meaning the other.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoTo translate my statement to the language used in your cartoon, "equality of individual opportunity" is "SAMENESS" and statistical equality is "EQUITY". One major obfuscation made by various activists in this discussion is that lack of EQUITY can only be caused by a lack of SAMENESS. As illustrated nicely by the cartoon, some folks are short. If shortness is distributed unevenly, then SAMENESS will result in some groups being underrepresented.
- geofft 12y agoYes, but (to stretch this analogy quite thin) the goal here isn't shortness or tallness. The goal is being able to watch the baseball game. It just so happens that there's a big wooden fence there, which may or may not have some reason to exist, but its purpose is definitely not to block short people from watching the game. If it has a purpose, it's something else. Blocking short people is a side effect. So, if shortness is distributed unequally, and there's a big wooden fence in front of the game, you could respond by saying that tall people are naturally more suited for game-watching, and argue based on tall people having historically been more successful at it. But that claim isn't likely to stand up to a deep examination of causality and reality. There are two significantly more defensible responses: give short people enough crates to see over the fence, or tear down the fence (preferably by figuring out what purpose it serves, and building something else to serve its purpose without the side effects, like a Plexiglas fence). Then your ability to watch the game will be determined only by your natural talent at game-watching, not by your natural talent at being tall.
- saraid216 12y agoEh. I prefer mine. We're really just changing where we put the origin point for our coordinate systems, but I like mine better. :P I would also swap out "opportunities" for "autonomies", but that's being pedantic and obscure.
- MrDom 12y agoDefine equal. Then tell me what legal rights women have that men don't have. Because I can name about five legal rights that women have that men don't.
- geofft 12y agoLegal rights are irrelevant if they cannot be exercised. In 1860, a runaway slave in the North had the right to life, liberty, and property; why did the Underground Railroad reach to Canada?
- MrDom 12y agoYou didn't answer my question. What legal right don't they have? Or, as you say, what legal right can't they exercise?
- dang 12y agoYour repetition of ideological talking points is both inflaming this thread and making it altogether predictable. We don't need yet another flamewar. Please stop.
- joshAg 12y agoYou misunderstand the enemy. The enemy isn't the other sex. The enemy is the culture itself that reinforces and perpetuates traditionalist gender roles. In short, the enemy is the patriarchy, and if you think for a minute that that only negatively affects girls and women, well, then you've never been a shy nerd asking out that cute girl from your math class who's also a cheerleader. Spoiler alert, P(that goes well) < 0.01.
- MrDom 12y agoThe enemy isn't the patriarchy, it's feminism. They create straw men to attack because they want power. There is no global gender war. It's being fabricated in real time to justify the ridiculous laws that arbitrarily make criminals out of men. And if you don't believe me, ask Byron Banks. you've never been a shy nerd asking out that cute girl from your math class who's also a cheerleader. Feminism is designed to make sure it's illegal for the shy nerd to ask out the prom queen. Spoiler alert: feminists are not the friends you may think they are.
- joshAg 12y agoDo you possibly mean Brian Banks, the Long Beach high football player? False accusations of any crime are horrible, but they are in no way common: The United States Justice Department agrees [with the rough percentage of false rape claims], saying false accusations "are estimated to occur at the low rate of two percent -- similar to the rate of false accusations for other violent crimes." Coincidentally, 2% is the number of rape accusations that ever result in a conviction: https://rainn.org/get-information/statistics/reporting-rates https://rainn.org/get-information/statistics/reporting-rates (this sources back to the DoJ as well. RAINN just has a nifty infographic.
- theorique 12y agoHow is it the fault of the "patriarchy" that shy nerds asking out cheerleaders tends not to go well? This makes it sound like a conspiracy.
- vinceguidry 12y ago