2 ms·
He seems to be arguing against himself, probably hoping that the reader only notices one half of each argument. First he argues that the nuclear bombs weren't
by mcphage 12y ago
He seems to be arguing against himself, probably hoping that the reader only notices one half of each argument.
First he argues that the nuclear bombs weren't that important, or different from our other bombs. Okay, fine. Then he argues that we persist the myth that the bombings ended the war because it helps us feel better about having dropped them. But if they weren't that different from our other bombings, why would we even need the lie to feel better about them?
Similarly with his timing. August 6th -> 9th was (he feels) both too long a wait to deal with the crisis, but also too quick, since the preliminary report about the bombings didn't arrive until the 10th.
And invasions: they didn't surrender at the threat of a possible US invasion, but a possible soviet invasion caused an immediate surrender?
As an argument that the Japanese surrender was more complicated than "we dropped a bomb, they surrendered"—well, obviously that's true. History is never that simple outside of textbooks for children. But in his arguments that it was irrelevant, he spends too much time contradicting himself.