3 ms·
I'm not sure it is that important. If the tractor has some failsafe to just stay in the field, then somebody standing in the field is going to have a bad day.
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
I'm not sure it is that important. If the tractor has some failsafe to just stay in the field, then somebody standing in the field is going to have a bad day. They're in the way of some industrial operation, and its their fault.
I know, children and kittens etc. But plenty of other industrial processes are dangerous and don't deal with it; why should farming?
- furyg3 12y agoDangerous industrial places like ports, for example, have big fences and security cameras and security officers watching those cameras and driving around. It could be that hiring a tractor babysitter is cheaper than all of that.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoEver been in a corn field? No need for fences and cameras. They are way out in the middle of nowhere. Distance makes them safe. I spent large portions of my childhood in corn field/hay fields etc, and nobody ever, ever went out there but me and people like me who had business there.
- mikeash 12y agoAnd if you do wander into a random corn field in the middle of nowhere, the presence of a human farmer doesn't suddenly make it safe. You can get run over by a manned tractor just as well as an unmanned one. And an unmanned one won't shoot you with a shotgun if it feels threatened.
- HCIdivision17 12y agoMost dangerous industrial processes like that I've seen go two ways: if a person makes it in the system emergency stops, and if it can't there's signage clearly stating brainless machines are at work (and always guards and such protecting actively moving parts). So in this case, the parent is likely right. The machine shouldn't be able to assume the field is empty. And since it's neither brainless nor can it have guards over the cutting implements, the next best thing is an area-of-denial zone around/in front of the tractor; pierce the zone and the tractor halts as fast as possible. And that pretty much leaves you with a vision system to watch for that zone violation. (It's easy to thoughtlessly make a minor mistake or forget something for just a second that otherwise appears to be a Darwin Award nomination. Constant vigilance is hard and impossible comprehensively, and while necessary, safety in layers is always a good idea. For example, I know at least some Kuka robotic arms with a cage denying access, yet robot will also notice a torque error and dump it's motors to a braking resistor, just in case the extra resistance was a squishy person - bypassing all interlocks is stupid and you'd have it coming, but death is non-OSHA-compliant.)