5 ms·
His biggest mistake was not ending up in US. Russia has never (at least that we publicly know) assassinated anyone in US, or US in Russia for that matter. From
by rdtsc 12y ago
His biggest mistake was not ending up in US. Russia has never (at least that we publicly know) assassinated anyone in US, or US in Russia for that matter.
From an evil dictator point view killing defectors in horrible ways does make sense. It is also imperative that everyone knows who did it but hopefully without there being a clear way of factually proving it.
This wasn't just simple revenge this was a message to other agents who might have thoughts about defecting.
- osipov 12y ago#BlamePutin is a knee jerk reaction that will get you upvotes amongst the fans of Western media. Of course for you Putin is an evil dictator despite the fact that no proof exists that he ordered an assassination of anyone, while Obama, the Nobel Peace Prize winning leader of the "Free World" police states, legally kills people with drone strikes. Warped values in my opinion.
- vinceguidry 12y agoYou think Lugovoy just up and decided to kill him on his own volition?
- osipov 12y agoDo you seriously want to know or are you just trolling?
- vinceguidry 12y agoI was looking for a short paragraph laying out a sane rationale for why Lugovoy might have killed Litvenenko. He either did it himself or was directed to do so. If it was the former, why? If the latter, who, and again, why? That you failed to even come up with that and instead are wondering whether I'm trolling or not indicates that either you are trolling yourself or that the situation is so complicated that you need way more space to articulate a rationale and you're just testing to see if I'm worthy of that kind of effort. Which, when you think about it, is silly, because your audience isn't just me, it's everyone seeing this thread. Putin is the obvious choice because shortly before Litvenenko died, he'd written several anti-Putin screeds for the British press. Putin might not have green-lit the murder himself, it could well have been someone in his intimate circle. Doesn't matter which, Putin's still the one to blame. Litvenenko was also anti-organized crime, it's possible one of his many enemies in that sphere could have influenced Lugovoy to do this. I don't rate that as particularly likely though. Lugovoy himself has taken the outlandish position that British intelligence did it, hah.
- ajuc 12y agoPlease. 1. dictator Putin is de facto ruler of Russia since 2000. He changed consitution to allow him to still be in power. He shut down free press, introduced laws persecuting minorities (homosexuals for example), was involved in election falsification. 2. evil Putin annexed part of Ukraine (Crimea), his army is occupying other parts of it (Lughansk and Donetsk) and invading further west. Russian army is also in parts of Moldova and Georgia against their will. The fact that Americans aren't always the good guys change nothing. I can show you many bad guys, this doesn't mean we should stop naming them. The fact that he has huge support in Russia also change nothing - Hitler had huge support too (especially after sucessfull campaigns). Putin is evil dictator and should be stopped.
- osipov 12y agoKeep mindlessly repeating the propaganda you are getting from your Polish media! It is almost as bad as the crap they are feeding Ukrainians.
- vixen99 12y agoHe at least provides a few facts. Where are yours?
- osipov 12y agoIt will be pointless for me to even try to argue facts for the following reasons. The subject we are debating is something that neither you or I know about first hand. Our entire basis for the discussion is based on reports of the subject through the media lens. Not sure about you but I'm monitoring media from both the Western and the Russian civilizations and there is no away that we can agree on the necessary facts if you are getting your opinions from just one source. The facts that we can agree on are probably trivial or have a conflicting interpretations. What do you think?
- osipov 12y agoHere some facts from a source that you'll deem Russian propaganda: http://uk.sputniknews.com/opinion/20150128/1013394849.html http://uk.sputniknews.com/opinion/20150128/1013394849.html
- ajuc 12y ago> Russia has never (at least that we publicly know) assassinated anyone in US, or US in Russia for that matter. Polish communist colonel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryszard_Kukli%C5%84ski http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryszard_Kukli%C5%84ski that defected to USA (together with his family) during cold war and gave NATO USSR's invasion on western Europe plans. > In subsequent years, both of his sons died. The older, Waldemar, was run over by a truck without a licence plate in August 1994 on the grounds of an American university. His younger son, Bogdan Kukliński drowned half a year earlier, on January 1, 1994, when his yacht capsized on a silent sea. Ryszard Kukliński did not insist that they were assassinated by the KGB, but he never rejected such possibility either.
- hga 12y agoCovert ugliness certainly happened; during the Cold War I had a friend at a research lab where they got some sort of NSA blessed network land-line terminating communications device, it had to be in its own special room that was beefed up so that breaking into it would be detectable. As one of the two in the group with access to that room to maintain etc. it, he was required to get a special clearance, and one of the requirements was that he never ever visit certain parts of NYC (where he was from) and Long Island, where we know the UN KGB types spend a lot time (including on the beaches :-). That's because too many of our people just up and disappeared while visiting those areas.... Very different from a completely overt hit like this, or shooting someone with a rictin pellet (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgi_Markov http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgi_Markov), but, still, it happened sub rosa.
- rdtsc 12y ago> just up and disappeared while visiting those areas.... Disappeared as in "assassinated"? That sounds a little too made up. If I was the security officer of that employee I would also probably try to make up some scary stories to make sure he never even feels temped to go there by telling him "some" agents had been captured, tortured and dissolved in acid by secret and evil commie rat agents.
- hga 12y agoNope, the key thing here is that they had were through to have valuable information, so they were thought to have been kidnapped in an area where it's really easy to exfiltrate people. I have reasons to believe this was something way beyond a security officer making up wild stories, e.g. he was working for one of the nation's top nuclear scientists, a protege of Edward Teller ... the other person cleared for that room. Who also lived under the restrictions, although things like overt, official conferences in Moscow were OK. The scientist was a real character, at one of those (maybe the only one), he sent back a post card saying "They've met my price! Please send my library." The security officer, while recognizing it was a joke, found it in very poor taste. And why bother with all this unless there were concrete reasons to make them no-go zones? If not a threat of kidnapping with a very Bad End, why were these areas off-limits???