3 ms·
> I wonder if that manga increases or decreases the number of actual child abuses. Doing a quick Google search, it seems UK and US are in the top 5 countries wi
by ekianjo 12y ago
> I wonder if that manga increases or decreases the number of actual child abuses. Doing a quick Google search, it seems UK and US are in the top 5 countries with highest child abuse rates:
As I said in another comment it's not even the point. Is it moral to actually have kids access such depictions in the first place, whether it's actual pictures or drawings, is what I am talking about. Of course everyone will have a different opinion about that, I guess.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoReligion is for morality. Your point is fair, but we are talking about prohibition. That is (ideally) not done on the basis of morality alone. A good reason for a law to exist is to protect people from each other. Hence laws against real murder, and real child abuse. Photos of child abuse are clearly illegal because they mean actual child abuse has taken place. Not because they are immoral, per se. They may be, but that's not as clear an argument. For the same reason, the discussion about the legality of drawings / enactments of illegal acts centers not around morality, but around whether or not it will lead to more of those acts actually happening. You're getting downvoted because you stick to making the morality argument, implying that is reason enough for prohibition. HN is a crowd where many people feel it's not. In the spirit of "Live and let live", I tend to feel the same way.
- ekianjo 12y agoI'm not asking to prohibit anything. I'm just questioning the logic behind prohibiting one thing and actively encouraging one thing very close to what is being forbidden at the same time.
- Sir_Substance 12y ago>Is it moral to actually have kids access such depictions in the first place Is it moral for you to force your morals on someone who holds other morals?