10 ms·
The Starlight Lines Employee Forum RPG
- DiabloD3 12y agoSo its not really secret anymore is it?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- diyorgasms 12y agoI remember playing this game when I was younger, and being impressed by the interactivity of the AI. Though honestly, I mostly just swore at them creatively. I have to wonder, though, if the game did actually have especially good AI, or if I just wasn't familiar with text-based adventure games enough to recognize Starship Titanic as essentially being one.
- visakanv 12y agoI relate to the dilemma. When I was playing Half Life as a kid, I remember being blown away by the "smart enemy AI." These days I find it odd when enemy AI does NOT react in a dynamic, networked way. Interesting how my expectation has changed over the years. I wonder if the same applies for video game graphics, too?
- coldtea 12y ago>Interesting how my expectation has changed over the years. I wonder if the same applies for video game graphics, too? How can you wonder? Isn't it obvious? Graphics that would leave us impressed in 1985 or 1995 or 2000 are considered nothing to write home about a few years later...
- visakanv 12y agoOh, sorry I wasn't precise- yes, absolutely! I'm particularly curious about the nature of that 'expectation evolution', and how exactly that works- and how, for example, people not exposed to the earlier work might interact with it. I'm reminded of an interesting story of a father walking his son through all of video game history: https://medium.com/message/playing-with-my-son-e5226ff0a7c3 https://medium.com/message/playing-with-my-son-e5226ff0a7c3
- bojan 12y agoI remember my father saying FIFA 1996 graphics "looks like live TV".
- diyorgasms 12y agoWhile this is true, I find the distinction between graphical fidelity and art style to be important in these matters. While the graphics of Super Metroid might not be anything spectacular, the pixel art is phenomenal, and replaying it recently I gained a whole new appreciation for how future-proof the art direction in that game is. I think there are many more examples of this out there, too. For instance, people often bemoan early 3d games (Nintendo 64 games especially) for aging horribly. On the whole, that is true. But there are certainly exceptions, such as Majora's Mask, where (again) the art direction saved the game's graphics from the awkward low-polygon limitations of the system.
- JonnieCache 12y agoThe sub-pixel movement engine in super metroid is fantastic too. It's what makes the art in that game really sing IMO. Also they got a bit of help from kubrick ;)
- danielweber 12y agoEach mode has a time when it gets "good enough," and everything on top of that is gravy. IMHO, for 2D, that was achieved with the NES generation. And for 3D, with the GameCube generation. (My son fired up Metroid Prime yesterday on the Wii, and it took me a while to realize it was a GC game, not a Wii game.) But, yeah, Super Metroid is amazing. I only played it recently (~6 years ago), never the original, and I still enjoyed it thoroughly.
- kibwen 12y agoIn this particular case note that the Wii hardware is, to a large degree, a straight repackaging of the GCN hardware with a bit more RAM and a higher clock speed. That the Wii is not an extreme graphical advance over its predecessor is to be expected. :) I do agree with you in general, though. Which isn't to say that graphical advances aren't still perceptible (compare SNES-era sprites to any of the positively gorgeous sprites from Odin Sphere or Rayman Legends), but at some point you cross a threshold where graphics cease being cringe-worthy and start being merely dated. FFVII is a cringe-worthy example, whereas The Elder Scrolls: Oblivion remains breathtaking to behold (as long as you don't look anyone in the face, that is).
- omegaham 12y agoDepends on the graphics. Sprite-based games are still perfectly playable; Super Mario World is still gorgeous 25 years after its release. Meanwhile, polygon-based games show their age really, really obviously. You can see the difference between Madden 2005[1] and Madden 2015[2]. I wonder what Madden 2025 is going to look like. Hilariously, people note that Madden 2005 is probably one of the best in terms of gameplay. I don't think it was until 2013 that they actually tried innovating, and the innovations weren't very good. [1]http://www.vgu.tv/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Madden-05.jpg http://www.vgu.tv/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Madden-05.jpg [2]http://oyster.ignimgs.com/mediawiki/apis.ign.com/madden-15/9/9a/Madden-NFL-15-announcement.jpg http://oyster.ignimgs.com/mediawiki/apis.ign.com/madden-15/9...
- the_af 12y agoI'll go even farther and argue that the beauty and timelessness of good graphics depends on something else, different from whether they are bitmap-based or 3D or whatever. Like you say, there are really beautiful sprite-based games; but also the polygon-based graphics of Another World are pretty timeless, and I wouldn't trade them for anything else. On the other hand, I agree the graphics of games such as the original Alone in the Dark haven't aged well at all. I can't explain exactly why I feel different about those two games, but I do. Maybe because the graphics from Another World are highly evocative, and its backgrounds sometimes remind me of something out of a Moebius illustration, while Alone in the Dark's are more tied to technological limitations of its time rather than to artistic decisions.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI feel like the polygon graphics in Another World (or Out Of This World) haven't aged nearly as well, much like Star Fox and Super Mario 64 haven't aged nearly as well as Super Mario World and Chrono Trigger. With Star Fox, Super Mario 64, and Another World, you have to look at them through a lens of "well, for the time..."; they were astonishing at the time, but now they look dated. On the other hand, new sprite-based games are still being made and sold today, as well as romhacks for console-based games. I don't think this is my nostalgia filter talking; there really was a certain peak at the height of the sprite-based era. (That said, Out of this World is also amazing for being the work of one person.)
- acomjean 12y agoI remember reading somewhere, they tried to make the "AI" but in the end just relied on having a ton of canned responses to questions. According to wikipedia: The engine incorporates over 10,000 different phrases, pre-recorded by a group of professional voice actors. The recorded phrases would take over 14 hours to play back-to-back. I have the hint book. One of few games that made it way to the mac in the 90s. Now sadly unplayable.
- Technomad 12y agoNot so. The AI was always there. We originally intended to use Text-to-Speech for output but rapidly found that TTS couldn't deliver the vocal nuances and timing required for the experience we wanted to deliver - this after all was a game where humour and quality of writing were crucial - hence the move to pre-recorded chunks. One of the heroic and oft-unsung latter-day development efforts on the game was the design of the pre-recorded chunks for assembly on the fly at play time and the mechanism by which they were assembled and delivered.
- acomjean 12y agoInteresting! Thanks.
- yoz 12y agoHere's how the AI worked (second-hand, because although I was semi-involved with the game, I wasn't on the dev team). The original natural language parser was Velocitext, an engine we licensed from Virtus. I say "original" because our devs - mainly the super-smart Jason Williams - put a ton of tweaks and other new code into it, and Douglas ended up naming the new system "Spookitalk" (because it was spookily good). Here's how to make spookily good AI: 1. When ST came out (late 90s), everyone had basement-low expectations of natural language parsers. These days things are somewhat better with Siri and Wolfram and the like, but back then the best you had - especially in games - were the Infocom and Magnetic Scrolls adventure systems. It turns out that all you need to blow people away is something that's slightly better than that; people expect computers to be useless at this stuff, so when they can occasionally come out with something smart, the impression is huge. 2. Jason and our test lead (Francine) put HUGE amounts of time in putting people in front of the game, recording text entered and the responses, then tweaking, iterating, etc. The AI's job was to parse text, add a little context and then return one of the several thousand pre-recorded responses. By the time the game came out, Jason had it handling the vast majority of things that people were actually likely to type. But again, the secret: AI doesn't have to be amazing. It just has to be better than you expect at doing the single thing it's meant to do. (See also: Valve's relatively simple soldier AI in the original Half-Life, which was amazing at the time)
- Technomad 12y agoNearly: We worked with one particular coder from Virtus, who was a (very good) NL person, who worked with us to implement the original engine that we and she designed (I've still got my original design docs - at least the ones that weren't written on Groucho Club table cloths…). What made Spookitalk (itself about the fourth title it had) so effective was that we combined the outlook of engineers (who always try to disambiguate) and writers (who play with the ambiguity and 'noise' of natural language) to create an engine that was explicitly focussed on delivering the illusion of intelligence by whatever means - a large proportion of the later work was focussed on just that - handling and interpreting the contextual and colloquial 'noise' around a conversation and using it to deliver appropriately smartarse responses. In that regard, Spookitalk was the spiritual successor to ELIZA.
- josefresco 12y agoSome day, I'll come back to Hacker News with that same longing...
- dsuth 12y agoYou are in a maze of twisty little passages, all alike.
- roneesh 12y agoWill we though? HN is for commenting on articles, which in several years will have their links broken. We don't develop characters, carry on stories or create a memes. Is a community based around commenting on things as durable as one that has to create their own content?
- dang 12y ago> We don't develop characters Look again. :)
- DanBC 12y ago> create a memes "Did you win the Putnam?"
- josefresco 12y agoA different community certainly, but I've shared many emotions on Hacker News, participated in excellent exchanges of ideas, arguments and discovery. A different flavor, but one with it's own sense of belonging.
- cstross 12y agoOh, cool. (The only time I ever met Douglas Adams, I was in London and dropped in on TDV, where a friend of mine was working as a sysadmin -- this was around summer 1997 -- and I got the tour, which included the man himself, who just happened to be in.) IIRC the novelization was going to be written by Robert Sheckley (who was also there, one of the great SF satirists of the 1950s to 1970s, up there with Harry Harrison in his early period): http://sf-encyclopedia.com/entry/sheckley_robert http://sf-encyclopedia.com/entry/sheckley_robert TDV had enormous energy back in mid-1997, but as I understand it everything fell apart very rapidly after Douglas died; he was the main driver behind the whole project, so rather than being an independent games house -- which it had the potential to become -- it died with its founder. (There's a lesson in here for startups, I think: try not to depend exclusively on a single creative vision?)
- hoers 12y ago>try not to depend exclusively on a single creative vision? I guess if you have an unmatched creative genius like Douglas Adams in your team, that might be the only real option. Especially since a lot of creative geniuses seem to have problems cooperating with other creative geniuses (at least in my experience). But I generally agree. Just look at Apple.
- ohitsdom 12y agoIt must be scary having a company so dependent on one creative mind. But how would Apple look today if they tried not to depend on Jobs so much? My guess- much smaller, much less significant.
- jessaustin 12y agoApple seem to be doing just fine without Jobs: http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2015/01/27Apple-Reports-Record-First-Quarter-Results.html http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2015/01/27Apple-Reports-Reco...
- maskedinvader 12y ago
- 72deluxe 12y agoI am not sure why this game was labelled a secret. I remember it coming out! I also remember it being praised for the AI but don't recall any of the reviews saying why it was so good. I suspect we'll soon have an article about the secret Lucasarts game called Grim Fandango.... Douglas Adams wrote some interesting books (I fondly remember the 5 book series of Hitchhiker's Guide and listened to the radio show from my dad's cassettes) and thought Dirk Gently's first book was funny but lost interest in the second. I was surprised that this game was labelled as Douglas Adam's creation though - did he write any code? :-)
- peterkelly 12y agoThe actual game the article talks about is so secret that even when presented with a detailed explanation of how it works, you managed to miss it.
- 72deluxe 12y agoHaha valid point I did skim read the article thanks to the abundantly rubbish Internet connection I am stuck with where half of the images never load. I deserve the stick I'll get for making that comment. I'll reread the article; thanks.
- madaxe_again 12y agoThe original wasn't, this is/was. The original was brilliant - remember I got it as part of a jewel set that came with Spaceship Warlock, Ultima V and VI, and... I can't remember what else.
- wcummings 12y agoThis was way before my time, but I was still aware of it as an Adams' fan
- sixothree 12y agoAs a side note, Grim Fandango was just re-released as a 'remastered' version.
- DennisP 12y agoThe book may be out of print but it's available for Kindle: http://www.amazon.com/Douglas-Adamss-Starship-Titanic-Terry-ebook/dp/B0012D1DLO http://www.amazon.com/Douglas-Adamss-Starship-Titanic-Terry-...
- yoz 12y agoHey, folks. I'm Yoz Grahame, the chap in the article who coded and (very badly) ran the forum. Many thanks to Lewis for writing such a great piece, and to dnetesn for posting it here! If you're interested in learning more about Starship Titanic and the Employee Forum, I recommend this MetaFilter post: http://www.metafilter.com/98848/The-Post-That-Cannot-Possibly-Go-Wrong http://www.metafilter.com/98848/The-Post-That-Cannot-Possibl... Rhaomi put together an amazing collection of links, including a guide to getting and running the game today. I also have a big mess of a comment halfway down the thread with some extra info and stories. My one main addendum to Lewis's piece: I was far from the only person behind the ST sites. The content was written by Michael Bywater, Neil Richards, and Alison Humphrey. Design & development by Alison Humphrey, Cynthia Miall, Claudio Calvelli and (whenever I got in before lunchtime) me.
- shimfish 12y agoTDV seemed to be a magnet for oddball online communities. One day, irritated with all the abject nonsense, requests for him to do their English homework, and speculation about the number 42, that was posted to his main forum, Douglas requested to add a "Half Witted Crap" forum. I promptly set that up and, rather than being offended by it, the community took to it with relish. I believe it also developed its own rich subculture but not being as brave as Yoz, I never dared look long enough at it to work out what was going on there. [edit: found link to original request for new forum: http://www.douglasadams.com/cgi-bin/mboard/info/thread.cgi?426,0 http://www.douglasadams.com/cgi-bin/mboard/info/thread.cgi?4... ]
- nemothorx 12y ago> "it worked fantastically – so fantastically that some people really did send the emails back, reassuring us that they hadn't looked at the site." I was one of those people! In fact, my email archive still has my response, where I attached the message to the reply, assuring that I'd not read it. I thought I was being so smart! Sadly, the original emails from "Ford" were lost from my archives somewhere along the lines. I suspect I got >< close to the forums too. The site is all very familiar to the memory, but I either didn't dig quite deep enough, or found it but didn't realise it was postable rather than a read-only forum with more play marketing. Still, it's truly fantastic that it's been kept alive so long, and I'm sure should a day ever come that you don't wish to (or unable to) continue hosting it, that there are a legion of fans who would happily take over!
- dang 12y agoWe attempted to tone down the baity title just a little, but if anyone has a better suggestion, we'll change it again.
- hullo 12y agothe new title is actually incorrect, the "secret" RPG is not the released-to-the-public game but actually "[The] Starlight Lines employee forum" if one is going to be literal about it. I'd personally just keep the article's title.
- dang 12y agoThanks for the correction. I've made that the title, but if anyone has a better suggestion we can change it again. (The reason for not using the original is that we don't want clickbait tropes like "The Secret Celebrity Foo That Bars Have Been Bazzing For A Bazillion Years". A good HN title is accurate and neutral.)
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI administer a small vBulletin forum that I inherited from a friend who inherited it from... well, whatever, this thing's been around for over a decade now. A few years ago we discovered that we had parasites! Apparently, that version of vBulletin had some sort of secondary built-in way for users to register - totally bypassing the moderation tools I used - and a whole secondary forum which these vermin could use! It didn't show up on the main boards, and was only discovered by accident. Apparently they'd hitched a ride on our forum to start discussing some pokemon-like game. We ended up flushing them all out. In hindsight, I really regret this. It wasn't anything as neat as the Starlight Lines forum, but it had only been going for about a year. On the one hand, I probably should have let them continue. On the other hand, I would have to be the benevolent admin of a bunch of people that weren't a part of my community, who were using a server I was personally paying for, and posting god-knows-what. Considering I'd already had to ban several regular users for posting awful things, I didn't want to double my workload. edit: did a little research; the feature they used was "Social Groups", and they still had to sign up normally, via the moderation tools. I guess they had just signed up far enough in the past that I either had moderation disabled, or I had forgotten about them.
- weeksie 12y agoHilarious! I have a forum that's been around for a similar amount of time and at the beginning it was on vBulletin. At least in the old days it was possible to have hidden forums that didn't show up on the main index, but would show if you went to a specific URL/forum id. Those became little secret forums that the users went to talk shit about other users. It was hilarious and I'd forgotten about that. Nowadays there might be twenty or thirty of us left. It's pretty slow but it's a nice little community.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI was about to ask whether you and I were on the same forum, but then I realized that there's maybe five people who even bother signing into mine once a week these days :)