5 ms·
"We don’t know where we are going to get our energy from in the second half of this century, and if we don’t get fusion working we are going to be really stuck.
by TheSpiceIsLife 12y ago
"We don’t know where we are going to get our energy from in the second half of this century, and if we don’t get fusion working we are going to be really stuck."
We have nuclear, solar, and wind. Even if Iter is successful it will take -guessing here- decades to bring it to production and the better part of half a century to roll it out in any significant way.
I think the next technological leap will be in manipulating huge amounts of energy, maybe we can warp space and go to the starts. So something like fusion power is probably necessary for that.
In the mean time, I think we can keep the lights on.
"The promise of fusion, if scientists can get it to work, is huge – unlimited power without any carbon emissions and very little radioactive waste."
I'm interested in how much CO2 is emitted to produce 400,000 tonnes of steel and concrete. I wonder what the life time emissions are for a fusion power plant, given that nothing lasts forever it will have to be maintained and have major rebuilds. This is an experimental design, so it will probably never pay back construction related CO2 emissions, so we should look at the numbers for a theoretical production unit, and how those numbers compare to other power generation technologies.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoA typical coal plant burns a box-car of pure carbon every 15 minutes. Compared to that, the amount of CO2 generated producing 400,000 tonnes of steel and concrete is negligible. Fission is currently our only scalable, safe, cost-effective replacement for baseload coal. Fusion would be an alternative-alternative. Wind/solar plus batteries is a backup plan. At this point, given what we know about climate change--and more to the point what we don't know yet, but will find out empirically if we keep down the no-nukes road--it is very difficult to be opposed to fission power. We are only "stuck" with out fusion because anti-technology crusaders have made it effectively impossible to build more of the solution we have in hand.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoYes, in the pursuit of perfect we appear to be overlooking good. With what we know about Gen III+ and what we're told about Gen IV nuclear fission, we should probably be doing a war-like roll-out of existing and new nuclear technology. I grew up in South Australia which is host to the worlds largest known single deposit of uranium in the world.[1] Maralinga in the Woomera Prohibited Area is the site of seven British nuclear tests.[2] Australia is also host to the OECD's dirtiest coal fired power station, Hazelwood Power Station in Victoria[3]. There's definitely some irony going there. I suppose if it weren't for Greenpeace and Friends Of the Earth Australia might have had nuclear power by now, or at least process and value-add our uranium ore. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympic_Dam,_South_Australia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympic_Dam,_South_Australia 2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_nuclear_tests_at_Maralinga http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_nuclear_tests_at_Marali... 3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazelwood_Power_Station http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazelwood_Power_Station Edit: fixed a word
- Shivetya 12y agoYou do realize that maintaining windmills is a constant affair, their install costs and such are not insignificant. I won't even touch the damage they can do to birds and bats. Solar might be worse depending on which tech you implement. Besides simply all the site improvements required you have entire factories elsewhere making the bulk of the parts and many of those processes are not that clean. Then top it all off with getting the power to where it is needed. Wind power pretty much has locations where its more ideal to build. Solar's foot print does similar. A fusion plant, probably could simply replace any large coal facility which would get you two birds with one stone
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoYes, I'm well aware of the input and maintenance requirements for wind turbines. One company I have worked for manufactured a bunch of turbine masts. Lots of steel, lots of welding. Though I reckon, with nuclear fission + solar + wind, when and where it makes sense to use each technology, we can keep the lights on, buying us time to develop even cleaner more efficient forms of electricity production. The small modular reactor designs we've been hearing more about recently sound like a really good idea for drop-in replacements for existing coal fired power stations. Though retro-fitting new technology to existing plant is often a better idea on paper. But at least the existing sites can be reused.
- onion2k 12y agoI wonder what the life time emissions are for a fusion power plant, given that nothing lasts forever it will have to be maintained and have major rebuilds. For the first fusion plant it'll be a huge loss environmentally speaking. But they'll improve as we learn and iterate the design and building process until eventually they're better than anything we can imagine today. That can't happen unless we build the first one. In the long term they're definitely the best possible energy source for the environment.
- simonh 12y ago> I'm interested in how much CO2 is emitted to produce 400,000 tonnes of steel and concrete. If the steel and concrete plants are powered by electricity generated using coal, a lot. If they're powered by electricity generated using Fusion, much, much less. It's not just those plants either, if the ships transporting the materials have fusion power plants. If the trains and trucks run on fusion generated electricity. All of a sudden the carbon footprint of the entire economy collapses.
- DanBC 12y agoWe've learnt a lot from Sellafield - an early nuclear plant in Britain (which was mostly used to provide material for military use). That site is a disaster and will take very many years and a lot of money to clean.
- DennisP 12y ago"ITER has been designed to produce 500 MW of output power for 50 MW of input power" and its construction "will require 16,000 tons of rebar, 150,000 m³ of concrete and 7,500 tons of steel for the building structures." [0] By comparison, "a MW of installed capacity for wind requires 460 metric tons of steel and 870 m3 of concrete compared to the 98 metric tons of steel and 160 m3 of concrete for coal, and the even lower 40 metric tons of steel and 90 m3 of concrete for nuclear" [1] So to match ITER's 450MW net with wind power, your turbines would require 270,000 metric tons of steel and 391,500 m^3 of concrete, several times more than ITER will need. This neglects thermal inefficiency for ITER, but on the other hand ITER is an experimental reactor and the followup DEMO plant is supposed to get 2 to 4 gigawatts with a size only 15% larger. [2] Also, the wind figures are for capacity, not actual output, so the numbers are pretty comparable anyway...it'd be reasonable to assume 30% thermal efficiency and 30% wind capacity factor. But you're right that ITER/DEMO has a pretty long timeline, which is why I favor smaller-scale alternate approaches (as well as advanced fission). [0] http://www.iter.org/factsfigures http://www.iter.org/factsfigures [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/07/01/is-the-answer-my-friend-blowing-in-the-wind/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/07/01/is-the-ans... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoThank you.
- jobposter1234 12y ago900 kg of CO2 per ton of cement. According to Wikipedia, it generates up to 5% of worldwide manmade CO2 emissions. 1.8 metric tons of CO2 per ton of steel. 200k metric tons of cement = 180k metric tons of CO2 200k metric tons of steel = 360k metric tons of CO2.