3 ms·
Playing devils advocate is all very well, but your questions have pretty easy answers. Unfortunately they involve math, and so people tend to tune out. But how
by nl 12y ago
Playing devils advocate is all very well, but your questions have pretty easy answers. Unfortunately they involve math, and so people tend to tune out.
But how do you quantify it? How much harm is caused to herd immunity by 1 more child not getting vaccinated?
Herd immunity is a threshold. For measles (which is highly contagious) it is generally accepted to be between 82% and 94%[1].
What is the expected value of that -- the probability that the disease for which the vaccine is available actually occurs in such a way that the voluntarily-nonvaccinated person contracts it and then passes it on to someone who is involuntarily nonvaccinated?
In a non-vaccinated population, a single case of measles can be expected to infect 12 to 18 people[2].
In the recent Disneyland incident, 3 people were vaccinated and caught it (because the vaccine is only 97% effective - less if you have only received the first dose). 2 children who were infected were too young to receive the vaccine[3][4].
32 people were infected in total.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number
[3] http://www.wired.com/2015/01/vaccinated-people-get-measles-disneyland-blame-unvaccinated/ http://www.wired.com/2015/01/vaccinated-people-get-measles-d...
[4] http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/disneyland-measles-outbreak-hits-children-too-young-be-vaccinated http://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/disneyland-mea...
- chrismcb 12y agoMaybe I'm doing the math wrong, but if herd immunity threshold is 82 to 94% then isn't it ok that 7% of the children aren't immunized?
- soneil 12y agoIt's borderline. If 7% have 'personal belief exemptions', then the 'herd' is at 93%. And we have at least one example (the child in the article) of further members who aren't vaccinated outside of this 7%. So the actual number is likely to be a little lower than 93%. Personally, I don't believe a model as simple as a % is likely to be workable in a school. If one of those 7% happens to sit beside him in every single class, the odds are going to defy the 'threshold' very quickly.
- nl 12y agoThe vaccine doesn't work for 3% of people, so that's down to 4% we are ok with. Then there is a set of people who can't get the vaccine for various reasons. The most obvious of these are very young infants, but it also includes elderly people who didn't get it when they were young as well as suffers of various diseases. Then there are people with depleted immune systems (chemo patients etc) who are vulnerable to diseases even if they are immunised. It seems likely this set of people adds up to between 1% and 2%. That drops it to 2-3%.