4 ms·
The fact that companies do not operate internal markets is well known in economics. The theory is that there is a balance point between the scale at which activ
by simonh 12y ago
The fact that companies do not operate internal markets is well known in economics. The theory is that there is a balance point between the scale at which activities are most efficient operating on a command model and the scale at which activities are most efficicently managed by market mechanisms. The position of the balance point is different from industry to industry, and also varies over time with economic conditions. Idealy you want efficient markets, but also a dynamically responding corporate world that can freely consolidate, diversify, merge, etc to adapt it's structure to whatever is most efficient as technology, supply, demand, etc shift in the economy.
This is why command economies tend to be less efficient, because any given market and corporate structure is only most efficient for very specific economic conditions. Heavy regulation of companies, markets and things like employment law tends to freeze their structure in place, so they are unable to adapt as conditions change.
So markets are only one aspect of an efficient economy. A flexible corporate, finance and employment environment is the other. Hence the economic flexibility and strength of the USA. Something as a Brit I'm perfectly willing to admit to. I'm not saying economic strength is the be-all and end-all of civil society. I firmly believe regulation plays an important part in ensuring markets are fair and laws are equitable, but all these things are not mutualy exclusive.
- bobcostas55 12y agoCoase won the Economics Nobel for his analysis of why and how firms organize. The Nature of the Firm[0] is still worth reading. The answer basically boils down to "transaction costs" and how they affect economic activity at different scales. [0] http://www3.nccu.edu.tw/~jsfeng/CPEC11.pdf http://www3.nccu.edu.tw/~jsfeng/CPEC11.pdf
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoIf by 'efficient' you mean 'most consistently profitable', then no, neither markets nor a 'flexible corporate environment' promote actual efficiency. In that kind of environment - which is not too dissimilar to the one we're in - corporations simply hoard money to no great end, and markets crash unless they're propped up by public subsidies and hand-outs. This distorts the wider economy and makes real efficiency less likely. Of course if by 'efficient' you mean 'providing the greatest possible benefit to the greatest number of people' that would be a very unusual aim in orthodox economics.
- Pinatubo 12y agoOn the contrary, 'providing the greatest possible benefit to the greatest number of people' is a central focus in economics. Start with Pareto efficiency and go from there if you want to see various ways in which economists actually define and study efficiency.
- ConfuciusSay 12y agoEconomists might focus on that, but the point is that in actuality companies do not focus on 'providing the greatest possible benefit to the greatest number of people'. Partially it's because that goal is far more difficult and complex than the simple aspirations of Greater Taylorism: to increase shareholder value. It's much easier to increase a stock price than it is to actually provide value for a large number of people, which leads to cases like IBM who spends billions buying back their stock while the actual value of their products declines to near zero.
- Pinatubo 12y agoI assumed by "orthodox economics" OP meant the study of economics. If s/he actually meant corporate behavior then that's of course different. Unfortunately people often conflate the study of economics with business, which leads to a lot of confusion.
- coldtea 12y agoPaying lip service to something is not the same as applied economics.
- calibraxis 12y agoCompletely ahistorical. Capitalism clearly dominates because capitalist nation-states dominate and war, imposing that economic system. Such economic priesthood stories conveniently omit world hegemons which send vast armies of uniformed killers across the world against anyone trying out their own systems. (Like overthrowing Iran's secular parliamentary democracy for daring to be vaguely "socialist", installing the Shah.) Or their police who literally strangle people in broad daylight, and violently attack people like the Occupy movement who imaginatively discuss alternatives to the economic order.