4 ms·
I suspect those links are biased because the people writing them want to believe eating vegetables and not harming animals is not only ethically right, but also
by the_af 12y ago
I suspect those links are biased because the people writing them want to believe eating vegetables and not harming animals is not only ethically right, but also biologically right. However, I think mainstream science currently holds that humans evolved as natural omnivores, eating both vegetables and meat.
- Retric 12y agoThe problem with that assessment is omnivores don't just eat the meat. They also eat, cartilage, ligaments, organs, skin, etc. People might love 'Steak and Potatoes' and look down on a hotdog as mystery meat. But chances are the hotdog is closer to what our ancestors were eating. Edit: Ignoring the preservatives etc. PS: Consider, we acutally need to maintian ligaments etc so not eating such things seems somewhat risky.
- kbart 12y agoThey still do, at least in Europe and Asia. I can hardly think of something uneatable except skin and bones. For example, an old national Lithuanian dish is made of pig's intestine stuffed with blood and pearl-barley. And I won't even start what kind of things I've eaten in China..
- Filligree 12y agoOh, no, the skin is quite edible. Fry it until it's suitably hard and crispy, and you have a delicious snack.
- gleenn 12y agoUhhh, if you've had fried chicken you're probably eating the skin. And as you noted about the Chinese eating many things, I believe its pretty common that they eat the bones. I think bone marrow is common in some European dishes. I'd say the big difference between a hotdog and what we ate a long time ago is probably all the hotdog's nitrates.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoI've seen enough information that I believe it's worth noting glycine and lysine and tryptophan intake for this reason. The problem with muscle meat, ignoring the claims of the article under discussion, is far too much tryptophan and not enough glycine. This is well demonstrated to be inflammatory. Any historically normal consumption of muscle meat would have been accompanied by large amounts of collagen and organs, which appropriately balances the amino acid ratios. So I make a point of eating more gelatin and shellfish in preference to isolated servings of muscle meat.
- the_af 12y agoAh, yes, sorry. I didn't mean meat as in steak and potatoes. What I actually meant was "animals". (BTW, I love chicken skin, bone and bone marrow. My wife watches in silent horror as I chew that stuff).
- dandelion_lover 12y agoDr. T. Colin Campbell wrote in his book "Whole" (2013) that he was not based on ethics, but on science only. So you assumption is wrong. Btw, he is from the mainstream science.
- wcummings 12y agoForget that, lets do paleo right and go back to eating bugs! The whole "biotruth" "evolution-as-intelligent-design" argument isn't very interesting. Who cares how ancient humans ate? Their lifestyle was completely different. They didn't have access to the resources (both in terms of food and education) we do now, why would their diet necessarily be the best?
- the_af 12y agoI somewhat agree with you, but I think that's going a bit too far. We should care what ancient humans ate because it can give us insights into what is healthy for us now. The beef (no pun intended) I have with this sort of articles is that I think the authors start from their ethical point of view ("eating animals is wrong") and then they try to find a biological justification, which happens to be a bit flimsy and not what mainstream science currently holds. If they were more honest, they would admit: "I don't care what ancient humans ate, or what we are more biologically suited for. I still think eating animals is wrong, and that today we have the means to adapt to a diet that doesn't involve harming them." (Not that I agree with this position, but it would seem more honest to me).