4 ms·
To me this is an excellent argument for the disbandment of the CIA and related agencies. This is obviously a thoughtful, knowledgeable, conscientious person. He
by jessaustin 12y ago
To me this is an excellent argument for the disbandment of the CIA and related agencies. This is obviously a thoughtful, knowledgeable, conscientious person. He probably has colleagues who are the same. Yet, when organized as they currently are, they can't think their way out of a paper bag. There must be a better way to do this work.
- briandear 12y agoWhat would be the replacement? Despite abuses and missteps, CIA does serve a valuable role. It would similar to the argument to disband police departments because of abuses. There could be a better way to stop criminals, but while that's being figured out, you get your car stolen and your sister raped.
- j2kun 12y agoUnfortunately the CIA does not devote resources to your stolen car.
- mercurial 12y agoIt may be more of a problem with the "service mentality" the document is talking about. Bad things happen when what your customer actually wants is "Find me a pretext to invade the Middle East and reshape it in a more US-friendly form, because Western intervention in the area has always turned out fine."
- arca_vorago 12y agoBingo. The problem is that in the intel community they used to have that salty old graybeard that would tell general X and politician Y the cold hard truth to power that they need to hear, instead of what they want to hear. Post 9/11, there is evidence that it was mostly vp Cheney who physically intervened in this process, personally pulling in analysts and grilling them... The problem to me is that the same chilling effects we have seen develop in the journalistic community have also grown in the intel community, and when you have analysts who spend more time kissing ass than calling people out bullshit like they should, we are only going to end up in worse geopolitical situations. NSA right now holds cards over CIA, keep that in mind as well.
- flurpitude 12y agoNSA right now holds cards over CIA, keep that in mind as well. Can you elaborate a bit or suggest some reading on that point?
- arca_vorago 12y agoWell it's more of an insight gained mostly from reading former-spooks books and similar. The fact is that the resources, both monetary and physical, are much larger than the company (CIA). It employs many more people as well, and a lot of people don't realize that the agency (NSA) has paramilitary divisions as well. The main reason I say though is because NSA has the upstream under their thumb. Pretty much anything the company does is going to be visible to the agency but not the other way around, which creates an information power disparity that is inevitable with the current organizational structures.
- btilly 12y agoOn this topic it is worth highlighting the following line from that document: Newcomers to the IC may not realize that the CIA presence in the Oval Office during the George W. Bush administration was the exception, not the rule.
- rst 12y agoWhich is reportedly the case, without exaggeration. According to one CIA agent's memoir, the group in charge of monitoring Iraqi WMD activity was literally told, by their boss, "Let's face it. The President wants us to go to war, and our job is to give him a reason to do it." (Source: "Blowing my cover", the memoir of ex-CIA agent Lindsay Moran, who says that hearing about this was the reason she quit.)
- billsimpson 12y ago> they can't think their way out of a paper bag Can you elaborate on this? Is this based on first-hand experience, media coverage, or some other source?
- jessaustin 12y agoTFA alludes to some of this. The CIA grossly overestimated the strength of USSR, for decades. They are routinely surprised by the actions of rivals, allies, and others. A decade ago, when the FBI and military already had perfectly sufficient interrogation capabilities, the CIA hired a couple of dumbasses to develop a horrific kidnapping-and-torture regime that betrayed not only our values but also our security. Although they have emphasized the "threat" posed by radical Arabs for at least two decades now, the CIA has yet to develop human assets native to the Middle East in anything like the numbers that they had devoted to the Soviet Bloc. Some would balance this shoddy record against the assumption that "well we have to have some top-secret intelligence-sabotage-and-kidnapping service." That simply isn't true. Through most of USA history we didn't have anything like that at anything like the CIA's scale. National leaders do need to know about other nations, but that work could be done better by normal non-classified and accountable researchers, who at least in the beginning would not be wedged so solidly in the pockets of the military-industrial complex. The sort of intelligence that enables military action has been really poorly executed by the CIA, and we'd be better off without it.