4 ms·
Solar is only a piece of the puzzle. The main issue is that in the US, we use up twice the amount of electricity in the day than we do at night. Spinning up an
by dragontamer 12y ago
Solar is only a piece of the puzzle.
The main issue is that in the US, we use up twice the amount of electricity in the day than we do at night. Spinning up and spinning down the turbines / generators causes enormous amounts of waste.
Green energy can't "spin up" and "spin down" like coal, oil, or nuclear.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2013/10/07/what-is-the-holding-capacity-of-the-us-power-grid/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2013/10/07/what-is-the-hol...
Some large percentage of our grid (in particular, the "dynamic" portion) will have to be Coal, Oil, Gas, or Nuclear. The Gigawatts of energy differential between day-usage and night-usage foregoes any hope of storing that energy.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoCombined cycle natural gas turbines are extremely easy to throttle compared to baseload like coal or nuclear. Even most diesel/bunker fuel facilities that were used for peaking have been shuttered or switched to natural gas, because of cost as well. Natural gas turbines are just fine as a peaking stop gap until we have the renewables dispatchability problem solved.
- jgamman 12y agohere in NZ (no subsidies in our electricity market) we are about 70% renewable via hydro and geothermal. we run a parallel 'reserves' market (everyone does, it's there to take up the slack of a plant tripping out). typically a hydro plant will run 'tail depressed' which means it's not as efficient as it could be but can scale up within 7 seconds (there's another 7 minute reserve market). prices adjust, people get paid to conserve fuel (water) but it's availalbe when needed. fast start gas turbines are also common but these tend to be at the 10-15 min mark (which is still blistering!). tl;dr 'green' energy _systems_ spin up and spin down just like the regular kind...
- dragontamer 12y agoHydro is one of the best "green" energy sources, and we definitely need more of it. The downside is that rivers of the size that can power a Hydro-dam are relatively rare, and ecological issues (flood zones, and whatnot) need to be taken into account. So I'll amend my original post with Coal, Oil, Nuclear or Hydro. Solar and Wind are absolutely terrible at "spin up" and "spin down". So other sources are needed to cover the differential.
- seanflyon 12y agoMy understanding is that it is not practical to turn nuclear on and off to meet demand. Am I just wrong on that? Do you know of a good resource to learn more about this?
- krschultz 12y agoIt's not practical to turn on and off any steam based power plant. Coal and nuclear fuel are simply used to boil water. The steam created in both plants is then passed through a steam turbine, which turns a generator. The turbine is finely tuned to a specific set of steam characteristics. These are generally related to temperature and pressure. The process of getting the steam loop up to the right temperature and pressure takes a significant amount of time and energy. Once it is at steady state, it is very efficient. Natural gas turbines work differently. There is no steam. The natural gas is burnt directly in the turbine, much like a jet engine. Thus you can throttle it just like an airplane. There is some lag, but it is relatively responsive.