3 ms·
Object permanence for children is interesting but not the best example. Far more interesting is the fact that children fundamentally don't understand geography
by jgrahamc 12y ago
Object permanence for children is interesting but not the best example. Far more interesting is the fact that children fundamentally don't understand geography at a young age because they can't see it and have to imagine it, and geography breaks something down into types (city, village, country etc.) and there's a hierarchy. Understanding geography is close to the sorts of abstract thinking required of programming.
Small children have a great deal of problems with "Paris is in France. We are in Paris." They also have almost no concept of distance as related to geography because they have no internal map of the world. So when you drive out of Paris you are still in France, but if you drive over the border into Belgium you are in another country.
So, teach kids geography.
I experienced this while teaching LOGO to small children (yes, this was years ago). Given a LOGO turtle and a set of instructions it's fascinating to watch them work out how to draw a square.
PS You might think showing small children a map or satellite view would help, but it doesn't help (much) because they have no internal way of breaking down the data presented into what they experience.
- ibdknox 12y ago> So, teach kids geography. Haha exactly! That's a really interesting example I hadn't heard before. There are lots of other fun ones: number permanence, volume conservation, etc.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> geography breaks something down into types (city, village, country etc.) and there's a hierarchy. Understanding geography is close to the sorts of abstract thinking required of programming It's one of the tools, but - probably because being heavily promoted by books and articles on Object Oriented Programming - it seems to be abused to the point of making some programmers dumber than they were before. What one really needs to grok here is that categories are arbitrary and rated only by their utility. With your example - yes, we divide countries into cities and villages, etc. but not only there are tons of exceptions breaking the perfect tree-like structure - the whole hierarchy exists only on the map, not in the territory. So yes, I'm all for teaching people hiearchies - followed by explaining that they're totally arbitrary, that real world is fuzzy, and that best ways to categorize do not always yield tree-like structures. (and maybe then people will stop listening to stories like "European Commision believes snails are fish" and then assigning stupidity to the authorities instead of themselves)
- jgrahamc 12y agoI never mentioned OOP and never would.
- glenjamin 12y agoIt strikes me that zooming around on Google Earth might be a good way to show the relationship between what we can see around us and the fully zoomed out globe.