3 ms·
I've raised the same concerns before, but PG's opinion on the topic is that the downvote arrow is there to indicate disagreement and if people want to kneejerk
by Someone1234 12y ago
I've raised the same concerns before, but PG's opinion on the topic is that the downvote arrow is there to indicate disagreement and if people want to kneejerk downvote something, they're right to do so.
This is the opposite of Reddit where, in theory, the downvote is not meant to be used to indicate disagreement but rather low quality comments (not that that works at all).
The problem is that both HN and Reddit hide comments that get too downvoted (dead/hidden respectively). And also re-ordered to the bottom (further hidden). That means that getting downvoted has a real consequence, so unpopular opinions are pushed out of HN's dialog and the site becomes a uniculture (just like Reddit).
Then HN has flag kills which are like "super downvotes." I've seen a lot of perfectly reasonable comments flag killed for no real reason (just turn on dead in your settings). In particular when they're flying in the face of the site's culture/popular opinion.
In an ideal world people who run these sites need to sit down and make up their minds, for real, if downvotes are for disagreement OR to flag "bad" comments. If they're just for disagreement then stop hiding/killing low rated comments, that makes no sense...
Also the karma score on your profile (and unlocking functionality) is a massive hornets nest that has many of the same issues described above.
Ultimately the point of the downvote and the punishment/rewards on the site are completely at odds with one another. People just haven't thought it through at all, unless their ultimate goal is to wind up with some kind of uniculture.
- minimaxir 12y ago> Then HN has flag kills which are like "super downvotes." I've seen a lot of perfectly reasonable comments flag killed for no real reason (just turn on dead in your settings). In particular when they're flying in the face of the site's culture/popular opinion. [dead] comments are different from [flagkilled] comments. [dead] comments are usually from accounts that have been hellbanned. I've very, very rarely seen a comment get flagkilled.
- brudgers 12y agoFlagkilled comments are probably rare because flagging a comment is not an obvious option and the down vote overlaps the reasons a comment might be flagged.
- brudgers 12y agoThis is the opposite of Reddit where, in theory, the downvote is not meant to be used to indicate disagreement but rather low quality comments I'm not sure HN has changed for the worse, but this is the first time I recall someone suggesting that the cause of HN's decline is that HN is not enough like Reddit.
- Someone1234 12y ago> someone suggesting that the cause of HN's decline is that HN is not enough like Reddit. I claimed no such thing. I said the management of both places have stated opposites in terms of how they expect the downvote to be utilised. However, in reality they're both used in exactly the same way (for disagreement) so what management wants and what actually occurs are quite at odds on Reddit, and quite inline on HN. Would HN be better if PG pretended people weren't using downvotes for disagreement? I don't think so. It wouldn't change a darn thing. However the site might be better if PG took that usage to its logical conclusion and stopped penalising downvoted comments. Popular and "bad" aren't the same thing.
- brudgers 12y agoIn my opinion, this "Ask HN:" creates a context in which consent to its premises implies a belief that HN is in decline. I probably would have better understood your comment had it been prefaced with something like "I do not believe HN is in decline, however..." Looking at the recent net negative comments by the person creating the "Ask HN", one achieved that status quite reasonably due to tone. The other began with "I would argue..", and consisted of a single sentence of disagreement without support of facts, examples, or rationales. It added nothing to HN and the best one could say is that it was undeserving of upvotes. That it wound up net negative is just a result of it being on a topic - the nature of vinyl - that is not subject to definitive conclusions and likely to elicit strong opinions from those interested in it. In this it is akin to religion or politics. There are objectively bad comments. There are objectively good comments. In general the votes by HN's community correlate with each.
- kazinator 12y agoOne little problem is that "I lack the background to understand this comment" serves as a sufficient facsimile for "I disagree".
- DanBC 12y ago> Then HN has flag kills which are like "super downvotes." I've seen a lot of perfectly reasonable comments flag killed for no real reason (just turn on dead in your settings). In particular when they're flying in the face of the site's culture/popular opinion. Do you have any example flagkilled comments that shouldn't have been flagkilled?