5 ms·
The risk psychology of the anti-vaccine movement
- kevindication 17y agoPeople who don't vaccinate their children do so as a luxury provided by the vast majority who do vaccinate.
- hcayless 17y agoHerd immunity helps, but the problem is that no vaccine is 100% effective and there are those who can't get vaccinated for health reasons (such as allergies, compromised immune systems, etc.). So, if you like, we're all relying on herd immunity to some extent, and people (hard not to type "morons") who don't vaccinate themselves or their kids are reducing the level of herd immunity. They're putting other people at risk--not just their own kids.
- scott_s 17y agoAnd, sadly, from the article: "“I used to say that the tide would turn when children started to die. Well, children have started to die,” Offit says, frowning as he ticks off recent fatal cases of meningitis in unvaccinated children in Pennsylvania and Minnesota. “So now I’ve changed it to ‘when enough children start to die.’ Because obviously, we’re not there yet.”"
- tomjen2 17y agoWell, no they have to catch it from somebody that _do_ have it in the first place, so the real culprit is those who have the decease currently. But yeah, statistically you are most likely to get to sick if you aren't vaccinated but at a certain point vaccination doesn't make sense at all.
- 83457 17y agoSo the non-vaccinated aren't the real culprits because they have to get it from someone who has the disease because they are not vaccinated?
- Alex3917 17y agoHow are you supposed to make an educated decision about the safety of these vaccines, when there's a good chance that the CDC is lying to you about the data? Just read RFK's article on the vaccine autism link: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/story/7395411/deadly_immunity/ http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/story/7395411/deadly_im... I've seen a ton of evidence since this article saying that the vaccine-autism link is false. However I've seen zero evidence that the alleged CDC cover up of the safety information didn't actually occur. How are you supposed to make an educated decision about the safety of these products when the head of the CDC vaccine division goes on record saying they are hiding information about their safety.
- gthank 17y agoYou mean the article that the submitted article explicitly calls out as unbelievably shoddy, and for which Rolling Stone has issued multiple corrections?
- Alex3917 17y agoI know the science in the article is wrong. But if you actually read the article, it isn't really about the science, it's about the CDC hiding data from the public. And this has not been challenged, in fact the CDC admits it. So I ask again, how are you supposed to make an educated decision based on facts, when the CDC admits that they have no qualms about hiding the facts from you.
- gcheong 17y agoI think you said it yourself. You've seen a ton of evidence that the vaccines are safe (and presumably very little evidence otherwise). If you believe they are credible sources then you should make your decision based on the available evidence, not some worry that the CDC has other evidence that they are hiding from you.
- nollidge 17y agoDo you have evidence that the CDC is hiding data from the public in this case?
- _ck_ 17y agoSome key quotes in there to think about: RotaTeq costs a little under $4 a dose to make. Merck has sold a total of more than 24 million doses in the US, most for $69.59 a pop (a 17-fold markup) In 19th-century England, Jenner’s smallpox vaccine was known to be effective. But despite the Compulsory Vaccination Act of 1853, many people still refused to take it, and thousands died unnecessarily. All you have to do to get the measles is to inhabit the airspace of a contagious person within two hours of them being there. There are going to be parts of this country in several years that are going to be darn dangerous to travel to as herd-immunity will be gone for several major diseases. I personally think the anti-vaccine people are way overboard.
- rimantas 17y agoDoes that take into account R&D?
- gthank 17y agoDoubtful, since the number would change with every single dose produced if it did.
- dschobel 17y agoIt's really frustrating that we can't get honest numbers on how much it takes to bring a drug to market. In the anti-pharma camp you see people quote the manufacturing price, and then you get the pharma companies quoting their entire operating budgets.
- protomyth 17y agoI used to work in clinical trials, and while I cannot comment on exact figures, the drug companies pay a lot of money over a very long period to release a drug. The big problem is that they only have 3 to 5 years to make all the money back and get enough of a profit to develop more drugs. Not every clinical trial actually works out, and the courts will be a constant problem for every drug. Do some research on the financial documents of the companies that do the clinical trials.
- protomyth 17y agoThe other problem with all this foolishness is that the resistance provided by these groups changes the research direction of the big drug companies. It is unwise to walk into a never-ending set of lawsuits. So, they make stuff that is less essential, but still makes them money (e.g. 'enhancers'). Even if you spent all the money and the FDA approves the drug for a specific use, the company will still get sued and it could be devastating. Look at the actual stats for asbestos and how many companies are out of business and how many NEW ones are being sued. Hysteria and foolish courts are going to wrack up a heck of a death toll.
- blueben 17y agoThis is exactly why Congress has given the flu vaccine manufacturers a pass on lawsuits. Without such immunity, who would take on the risk of manufacturing a low profit item like swine flu vaccine? But to the conspiracy theorists, this is just "proof" that the vaccines are dangerous and that "big pharma" and the government are conspiring together.
- blakeGideon 17y agoI hadn't had a flu shot in years. But with the added risk swine flu has brought, I plan on getting on this season.
- ars 17y agoWhat added risk? The swine flu is not worse than regular flu, it's simply that more people than usual will get it. That's troubling to governments, but should not matter to you.
- sketerpot 17y agoThe added risk of getting the flu. It well and truly sucks to get the flu, even if it's not much worse than usual.
- blueben 17y agoNot worse now. But the probability of the virus mutating goes up with the size of the population it has to play around in. We all have a vested interest in making sure that doesn't happen.
- fnid 17y agoI've only had the flu one time in my entire life and it was the same as the only year I got vaccinated. I haven't had a flu vaccine since and I haven't gotten the flu since. Edit: Not saying I don't believe in vaccines in general. But I'm not sure I believe in the flu vaccine. I can't explain my flu infection, nor can others who experienced the same circumstance: getting the flu the only year they were vaccinated. I have been vaccinated against other diseases since then though.
- eru 17y agoI tried to re-upmod your post back to 1 point. You state an observation. And while that anecdote flys in the face of what many here (including myself) believe about vaccination, there's nothing wrong with your comment. For what its worth, I had have lots of flus, but was never vaccinated against influenza (as far as I can remember).
- sketerpot 17y agoThe observation isn't inconsistent with the facts about vaccination. Flu vaccines can't protect against every strain you might encounter, and it's a simple matter of probability that there are going to be a lot of people who get vaccinated for the first time, get a flu that year, and stop getting vaccinated from then on. This is why anecdotal evidence on this issue is worthless. Worse than worthless, actually, since it distracts from the proper statistical approach to thinking about vaccines.
- eru 17y agoPerhaps. And a proper comment like this is a good reply. Downvoting doesn't seem right to me in this case.
- nollidge 17y agoCorrelation is not causation. Correlation is not causation. Correlation is not causation. Edit: "I can't explain my flu infection" I can. You got the flu strain which wasn't covered by the shot.
- 17y ago
- dschobel 17y agoand the very first post in response to the NYT blog: I will never get another vaccine, just another way for the goverment to poison us off. Vaccines are the biggest scam ever created. sigh.
- pcestrada 17y agoIt's a self-correcting problem. Those who don't vaccinate will eventually dwindle in numbers and their offspring won't reach reproductive maturity.
- mynameishere 17y agoWhich is to say, those who don't get the vaccine will die in proportion to their natural weakness to a particular disease. The survivors will have the strongest resistance out of the entire population.
- anigbrowl 17y agoI wish. Aside from the ethical problem that adults are compromising the survivability of their children, who are not in a position to make the decision for themselves, this view depends on the idea that illogical thinking and paranoia are heritable traits. To be sure, growing up in an ignorant family may well offset the benefits of education, but many otherwise intelligent people can fall into error. Consider deniers of evolution or moon landings, who often know enough science to put up superficially persuasive arguments for their conspiracy theories (a favorite being 'van Allen belt radiation would have killed the astronauts') but seem unable to deal with questions of probability. These beliefs are more common in the US than in Europe; I wonder if this is due to some basic weakness in the design of US school curriculum. Maybe if basic programming were included as part of the math curriculum people would b better equipped to deal with these issues.
- dschobel 17y agoPrecisely. This is an education issue which we should try to address, not just say "well, they'll all be dead soon enough anyway"
- xexers 17y agoWhile I do think it's important to get the tried, tested, and true vaccines, I am not sure about some of the newer ones. There have been many stories in the past of people getting worse off from brand new vaccines. For new vaccines I use at my own discretion.
- ars 17y agoI have the same policy - I will not use a vaccine until it's been in (at least moderate) use for at least 10-15 years. A good policy is never use a vaccine that is still under patent (although that's 21 years, which is probably too much).
- nollidge 17y agoLots of people are dying of vaccine-preventable disease. They are quite obviously not dying, or even getting sick, from vaccines, except in extremely rare cases. So, that's a terrible policy. Edit: removed inflammatory language. Sorry.
- ars 17y ago> Lots of people are dying of vaccine-preventable disease. And all of those have vaccines that are much older than 10 years. And I use them - all of them. The recent vaccines are for things that don't kill, or kill in such small numbers (in the US) that the risk is almost unmeasurable. Varicella, rotavirus, HPV, flu. Rotavirus for example, should simply not be used in the US. In Africa? Sure. But not in the US. Does rotavirus kill in the US? Yes, sometimes (about 37 cases per year). But the added risk of 100 million people in the US driving on the road to get the vaccination kills more people than the illness itself does. (Ok, not quite, but it's close.) I'm very pro-vaccine, I just won't use new ones. And just to confirm my policy of waiting, remember the fatal cases of intussusception that happened with the first rotavirus vaccine.
- nollidge 17y ago> And all of those have vaccines that are much older than 10 years. Swine flu has killed 4,735 people [1] so far, and the vaccine is brand new. Seasonal flu kills about 36,000 people [2] a year in the U.S. alone, and the vaccine is different every year. [1] http://www.who.int/csr/don/2009_10_16/en/index.html http://www.who.int/csr/don/2009_10_16/en/index.html [2] http://www.reuters.com/article/healthNews/idUSN2932292920080329 http://www.reuters.com/article/healthNews/idUSN2932292920080...
- johnohara 17y agoAs a teacher, I've been fortunate over the years not to get most of the stuff students 'graciously' share. I don't know why, lucky I guess. I've taken every precaution in the computer lab to slow the spread -- sanitizers, keyboard/screen cleanings, constant reminders how to cough, etc. Some years, we've gone through 2 large pump bottles of sanitizer. One year I decided to get a flu shot just 'to be sure." Within 45 days I came down with one of the worst bouts of flu I had ever experienced and got into serious dehydration problems (almost hospitalized) before turning the corner. The strain I had actually induced 'projectile vomit.' I remember thinking "wow, I didn't know my body could do that." It was horrible, scary, and impressive all at the same time. I'm keeping a very close eye on this H1N1 business and like the other posters here, will read all I can to know more. But there's no way I'm marching down to get a flu shot just because the CDC says so. I've done that already. I'm not a conspiracy guy, nor am I herd-stupid. I'm just cautious by direct experience.
- sketerpot 17y agoYou got a flu shot, got another strain of flu a whole 45 days later, and you think that there's a connection? I'm sorry, but this isn't evidence; it's the exact same cognitive failure mode that convinced people that dances and sacrifices could control the weather. You were in a high-risk environment, with lots of flu strains circulating around, and you probably just got unlucky that year.