4 ms·
The hallmark of real intelligence / creativity will always be that they are eventually unforeseeable and uncontrollable. Imagine three different computers. Eac
by onion2k 12y ago
The hallmark of real intelligence / creativity will always be that they are eventually unforeseeable and uncontrollable.
Imagine three different computers. Each one is an identical black box that connected to a printer, and every 5 minutes it prints out an entirely new work of art that, subjectively speaking, is quite nice to look at. You are told the following;
1. One computer is genuinely intelligent in exactly the same way as a human is. The clever engineers have replicated human creativity perfectly and given it the personality of a competent artist. It 'thinks up' just one print and prints it each time.
2. The next computer generates 100 different pieces and then pushes each of them to Amazon Turk for evaluation by 100 different people. It prints the one with the highest score.
3. The last computer has a set of reasonable rules based on a set of the sum of knowledge from Harvard University's Art Society. It uses those rules to pick the best picture out of 100,000,000,000 different pieces it generates completely at random for each print.
How can you tell the difference between which is which?
The point being until you see the result there is no way to know. You have no control over the 3 boxes and you can't see what's happening inside. As far as you're concerned each computer could be any of the different types. They would all be creating a new work of art each time but only one would be "creative" in the human sense, but they're all being creative in the sense they're creating, appraising, and choosing a new solution.
- tempodox 12y agoYou're imposing a set of rules and just assume an intelligent entity would heed them. My point is, if you're dealing with true intelligence / creativity, you can't be sure a priori which rules it would play by. After all, creativity is the antithesis to predictability.