4 ms·
It's interesting that these articles always bring up weird Japanese subcultures. The fertility rates of Singapore and Republic of Korea are lower than Japan's,
by lern_too_spel 12y ago
It's interesting that these articles always bring up weird Japanese subcultures. The fertility rates of Singapore and Republic of Korea are lower than Japan's, and they have fallen far more precipitously (by more than 75% since 1960). The mainstream pop-demographics articles about those countries' fertility rates tend to focus more on the realistic explanations.
- frozenport 12y agoPerhaps because because those two groups display caution when choosing when to have children, rather than an outright rejection of human interaction in favor of a simulacra?
- obstinate 12y agoYou are making the same error that the lern_too_spel was pointing out. Japan is not anime and otaku -- that is just the part of the culture that has been exported successfully. The typical Japanese person hasn't exchanged normal human interaction in favor of simulacra.
- frozenport 12y ago>>The typical Japanese person hasn't exchanged normal human interaction in favor of simulacra. I don't know, but we have statistics to answer this question, which is precisely what we are talking about. Did you know that 50% of Japanese couples have not had sex in the past month? [1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8945585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8945585
- obstinate 12y agoThis may be a case of Poe's law. If it is, pardon my funny bone. But if you aren't joking, may I humbly submit to your consideration that, "did not have sex," and "did give up normal human interaction in favor of simulacra" are two different things. Statistics about solely about one of these things cannot be used to derive meaningful conclusions about the other.
- pyre 12y agoSo... you've created speculation based on a statistic, and used said statistic to "prove" your speculation is correct.
- ramblerman 12y agoActually if you bother to read the article instead of playing circular logic games in the thread you'd notice: "To examine Japanese attitudes toward sex, the Japan Family Planning Association interviewed 3,000 subjects, both male and female, about their sex lives." There is no mention of couples. It interviewed 3000 subjects who may or may not be in a relationship. The title is inaccurate.
- kalleboo 12y agoOr maybe more relatable to westerners: Germany also has a lower fertility rate than Japan. Nobody's writing these articles about why Germans won't have kids. I'd be more interested in articles exploring how we can create an economy and society that doesn't rely on neverending expansion (and ever-increasing energy usage), seeing as this is the trend in all western countries, and the immigration band-aid will only be possible for so long.
- lern_too_spel 12y agoEven Italy and Spain, having anticipated Pope Francis's sentiment three decades in advance, have lower fertility rates than Japan. Two solutions to your demographics problem are to reduce the cost of elder care (http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2013/05/automation-elderly http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2013/05/automation-el...) or to raise the retirement age (http://business.asiaone.com/news/raise-retirement-age-70-lim-boon-heng http://business.asiaone.com/news/raise-retirement-age-70-lim...).
- raverbashing 12y agoGermany can "import" any EU national as well as the immigrants (not all of them EU nationals) having a higher fertility rate.
- kalleboo 12y agoThat's not a solution though, that's a band-aid. I guess I understand that's why it's not in the news today, but personally I'm more interested in the long-term than short-term. As countries develop the fertility rate drops. This is happening across the planet. Eventually there won't be anywhere to get new immigrants. (there will also be problems before that if you look at places like France, the UK and Scandinavia where resistance against immigration is rising in the form of anti-immigration parties)
- raverbashing 12y agoI agree, in the long term countries will have to learn how to deal with low fertility rates.