3 ms·
Begs the question: is it possible to write a Lisp-based escape from the Lisp VM to the Virtualbox VM, then an escape from the Virtualbox VM to the host OS? Perh
by contingencies 12y ago
Begs the question: is it possible to write a Lisp-based escape from the Lisp VM to the Virtualbox VM, then an escape from the Virtualbox VM to the host OS? Perhaps, but not something a casual attacker is likely to have resources for ;)
- cpach 12y agoWouldn’t this possibility depend on security holes in Virtualbox rather than in the guest OS?
- thecatspaw 12y agoIt would depend on both.
- cpach 12y agoBut if there are security holes in Virtualbox, wouldn’t they be exploitable by any OS, regardless of what language it was written in?
- tedunangst 12y agoYes. The relevance depends on how likely you are to run a virtualbox image you found on the Internet because somebody told you "run this image".
- cbd1984 12y agoThe idea of a VM is that it provides an iron box which nothing can break out of, because it's completely invisible. There's nothing a guest can do which could possibly distinguish a VM session from running on the bare hardware. Partly this is for compatibility, partly for ease of development (develop the next VM as a guest in the current VM!), and partly for simple security: You can't escape a prison if you are utterly convinced you're already out. Maybe that part of the theory never made it into practice.
- tedunangst 12y agoYeah. Welcome to practice: I type "ifconfig | grep vio" and if it comes back nonblank, I know I'm running in virtualbox.
- cbd1984 12y agoThe idea of a VM is that it provides an iron box which nothing can break out of, because it's completely invisible. There's nothing a guest can do which could possibly distinguish a VM session from running on the bare hardware. Partly this is for compatibility, partly for ease of development (develop the next VM as a guest in the current VM!), and partly for simple security: You can't escape a prison if you are utterly convinced you're already out. Maybe that part of the theory never made it into practice.
- avodonosov 12y agoI doubt he was working several years to create this OS in Common Lisp to attack these 50 people who tries it :)