3 ms·
Great of the ACLU to post the actual court orders and opinions that would otherwise locked behind a rent-seeking government contractors "portal". Here is why w
by revelation 12y ago
Great of the ACLU to post the actual court orders and opinions that would otherwise locked behind a rent-seeking government contractors "portal".
Here is why we can't have nice things:
We caution, however, that the detention at the hands of
these TSA Officials is at the outer boundary of the Fourth
Amendment. Once TSA Officials were satisfied that George
was not armed or carrying explosives, much of the concern
that justified his detention dissipated. However, it did not
totally vanish or suggest that further inquiry was not
warranted. Suspicion remained, and that suspicion was
objectively reasonable given the realities and perils of air
passenger safety. The TSA Officials still were confronted
with an individual who was carrying Arabic-English
flashcards bearing such words as: “bomb,” “terrorist,” “to
kill,” etc. In a world where air passenger safety must contend
with such nuanced threats as attempts to convert underwear
into bombs and shoes into incendiary devices, we think that
the brief detention that followed the initial administrative
search of George was reasonable.
(https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/assets/george-v-rehiel_3rd_cir_qi_ruling.pdf https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/assets/george-v-reh...)
It's basically pages upon pages of personal opinions and value judgements. At the end of the day, the law does nothing to protect you when the judge dealing with the government appeal is a right-wing nutjob that attaches no significance to constitutional freedoms.