3 ms·
Average global standards may have gone up. The question is this: who really reaped the vast majority of the benefits from productivity improvements? Was it the
by enraged_camel 12y ago
Average global standards may have gone up. The question is this: who really reaped the vast majority of the benefits from productivity improvements? Was it the worker who is doing the work, but doing it much more productively, or was it the few "entrepreneurs" who figured out a way to "monetize" the skyrocketed productivity of those workers?
We have the exact same argument with regards to software developers today, who are quite underpaid relative to the actual value they are adding to their employers. Yes, they may be living quite comfortably, but is that all that matters?
- zaroth 12y agoAverage global standards have gone up, and not just a little. Orders of magnitude in just the last couple hundred years. Standards will continue to climb increasingly rapidly based on $1.6 trillion of annual R&D, and worth noting that private R&D investment is up to 75% of that (varies by country). I think you're focusing on the wrong thing. The question is not, are there a few (0.01%) people who have gotten supremely rich. As long as there is any notion of private property, there are, and always will be, a 1 percent. And a 0.001%. Generally the same people who provide the capital to fund the R&D leading to these advances are the ones who most directly reap the benefit of that R&D. What we suspect is that providing these profit motives is the reason why people are willing to take the risk and make these wonderful things happen in the first place. To paraphrase, capitalism is the worst form of economic system, except for all the rest. It's what we have, and clearly it has worked wonders in just a few hundred years of human history. To your point about developers, what other industry is more open to individual contributors quitting their day job and going to work for themselves? If you're complaining that working for someone else means that you are working for someone else, I don't know what to tell you. You can choose the security of someone else signing your paychecks, or you can go it alone and reap the benefits. What other choice could you possibly hope for? If an employee (or group of employees) captured the entire value that they added, then by definition they would not be worth hiring! Obviously in order to take the risk of hiring an employee and committing to pay them a (substantial) fee a couple times a month for the foreseeable future, you would expect to earn a significant return on that capital when things work out! Besides the fact that the company is fully supporting and directing them in their efforts, and to the extent that is not true you would expect equity. Don't forget, in the vast majority of cases where these things don't work out spectacularly, while the stockholders lose their shirts, we don't ask the employees for a refund!