8 ms·
Will we ever get there? At the moment, political and regulatory barriers dwarf technological ones, per Yglesias in The Rent is too Damn High: http://www.amazon
by jseliger 12y ago
Will we ever get there?
At the moment, political and regulatory barriers dwarf technological ones, per Yglesias in The Rent is too Damn High: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO.
In many areas, building with century-old technologies like steel frames and elevators is effectively illegal. Where it isn't illegal, the approval process is often so cumbrous that it substantially raise the price of building: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2007/11/a-tale-of-two-town-houses/306334 http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2007/11/a-tale-o....
We as a society have chosen to make a lot of housing very expensive.
- iopq 12y agoNo, the people who own houses have chosen to make them expensive. Because it is expensive, those people are quite rich. This gives them political power to make it more expensive. See: San Francisco regulations on construction.
- hueving 12y agoIt's a terrible feedback loop. Nobody who owns a house in SF in their right mind would vote for anything that could substantially decrease the value of their home.
- JulianMorrison 12y agoThe fix: (1) government re-regulates building to be easier and land to be more available, causing a housing boom. (2) government guarantees every house's value as it was before the reforms. If the value falls, government pays the difference. (3) Government raises a tax to pay this all off.
- iopq 12y agoThis is why we can't have nice things. Raise a tax to guarantee that the richest people keep being rich? Do not want.
- swatow 12y agoBut are the majority of SF residents owners? Is it really about voting, or about savvy political lobbying by property owners?
- pimlottc 12y agoIt does seem at least that homeowners tend to vote more often than renters: http://journalistsresource.org/studies/politics/citizen-action/homeowners-better-citizens-homeownership-community-participation-united-states http://journalistsresource.org/studies/politics/citizen-acti...
- stolio 12y agoIt's a bit juvenile to blame building codes without also admitting why we have them: they save lives. Look at the death tolls of earthquakes that happen in countries with and without enforced building codes. On the other side of the coin, thanks to deregulation houses are commodities that people buy, sell and trade for profit, which raises their prices and causes volatility in the market. Is that Atlantic article really comparing the building codes of Dallas and L.A. without admitting one of those cities has to plan for earthquakes and the other doesn't? And that one of those cities is already too big while the other is looking to grow? Where's L.A. going to get the water for these cheap new housing developments? TL;DR building codes and growth restrictions are a lot more complicated than some rich people wringing their hands and using regulations to make themselves money.
- baddox 12y agoHow does turning something into a commodity that people buy, sell, and trade for profit raise prices?
- stolio 12y agoSupply and demand? Increase demand, supply is largely fixed* , prices go up. * a house in the boonies isn't really a substitute for a house in the city. Every house has demand from people who want to buy it as a home plus the demand of people who want to buy it to rent/flip/scrape it.
- spikels 12y agoYou are confusing land and housing - they are not the same. Land area is fixed but habitable space is not. In built up areas the constraint on building new housing is largely regulatory (mostly planning regulations).
- stolio 12y agoI lump land and housing together because that's how reality does it. Aside from trailer-houses they all stay on one piece of land for the duration. If an analysis depends on houses being able to fluidly change land positions I don't think it would be very useful.
- justincormack 12y agoLand is the main cost of buildings in most of the developed world, not building.
- querulous 12y agoin vancouver it costs about a million dollars for a house on a standard lot in the city. it's about a million two for a lot without a house
- patcheudor 12y agoNot quite. Land is the main cost of buildings in the most desirable places in the developed world. In the US Pacific Northwest as an example, outside of major metro areas people will spend about 1.5-4x the cost of land on the actual structure. If you buy a $150K lot in Boise Idaho as an example it's pretty standard to then spend between $200K-$400K on the structure and landscaping.
- baddox 12y agoI agree with everything except that "we as a society have chosen" this. A very very tiny portion of people (far smaller than "the 1%") have chosen this.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 12y agoAs soon as people get a mortgage, they're invested in house prices rising.
- zaroth 12y agoMostly they are just invested in inflation, the same way anyone with high debt of any kind is. From 1970-date inflation alone is responsible for a $120k house becoming a $700k house.
- gburt 12y agoThe fall in adjusted incomes is the real issue that everyone is overlooking.
- zaroth 12y agoAn overall positive slope but the last decade has not been kind to the bottom 60%: http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/charts/census/household-income.html?household-incomes-growth-real-annotated.gif http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/charts/census/hous...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sliverstorm 12y agoNah. Unless you take out equity in your house, rising house prices mostly mean higher property taxes. Now, inflation on the other hand, they now have a vested interest in, as it makes the loan easier to repay. This all goes out the window if you're buying a new house every 3 years, of course.
- Retric 12y agoThe actual cost of constructing a house is almost meaningless in most areas people want to live. What your paying for is the infrastructure around houses. So, if we really want cheap housing find out how to make cheap roads, bridges, water and sewer systems, electrical systems, schools, hospitals, ... etc. That said, people are also living in much larger houses with more amenity's like AC, and dishwashers. PS: There is a completely reasonable argument that building a new house or apartment complex should pay their fair share of existing infrastructure ~10k-50+k/person in most areas. That this does not happen is simply a form of corruption as zoning becomes a quick way to massively change the value of land after purchase.
- zaroth 12y ago> That this does not happen is simply a form of corruption... That's what property taxes are, to the tune of ~$500 billion per year in the US! The market price of a dwelling is inversely proportional to the tax rate, so it IS priced into the sale.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- reality_czech 12y agoA house in SF might cost around a million dollars. The same house in Columbus, Ohio, might cost 100k. Are you really going to argue that "roads, bridges, water, and sewer systems" are 10x as expensive in one place as in the other? No, "what you are paying for" is the artificial scarcity created by restrictive zoning codes and NIMBYs. If the city council let me build on one of the many open fields around I-280 tomorrow, I could get it constructed for a pittance-- and then turn around and sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars. PS: There is a completely reasonable argument that building a new house or apartment complex should pay their fair share of existing infrastructure ~10k-50+k/person in most areas. That this does not happen is simply a form of corruption as zoning becomes a quick way to massively change the value of land after purchase. Do you understand how "the existing infrastructure" is funded? It's funded by taxes. And developers pay taxes like anyone else. What they do isn't cheap.
- brudgers 12y agoIn most of the US it's pretty easy to entitle the construction of a new dwelling. The difficulty tends to be proportional to demand - i.e. regulatory requirements reflect market forces as the result of political action by the citizens of a representative democracy. In practice building with steel and elevators is more expensive than using traditional American methods involving stick framing and low rise construction. The more expensive methods only make sense when demand is high enough to justify the additional costs. A primary constraint on development density in the US is parking. By the time resources are committed to accommodating residents' vehicles, only higher housing prices associated with 'luxury' class housing make development of a site with dense housing feasible. Again, it's a market dealing with the parking regulations. Parking regulations reflect the body politic's interest in protecting the commons that is our roadways. There's cheap housing in Detroit. There isn't in Mountain View. That's just the nature of markets.