3 ms·
It’s very telling that there have been very few proposals from feminists or kinesiologists or sports marketers to come up with a way that men and women can comp
by jessaustin 12y ago
It’s very telling that there have been very few proposals from feminists or kinesiologists or sports marketers to come up with a way that men and women can compete together, or men and women can compete on a different kind of a playing field.
This has puzzled me for decades. There are some sports in which men and women compete together at the highest levels (e.g. horse racing), and there are some efforts at other mixed competition at lower levels. However, these seem to be minimized by everyone, and not even referenced as a benefit of which we'd like to see more. I can't think of any arena besides sports of which that could be said, although perhaps it might almost be said of the military. Even the military is criticized to an extent for the opportunities it denies women. Yet, sports get a complete pass.
It is true that many sports would have to change in fundamental ways to allow women and men to compete together at the highest level. That isn't really an excuse, though, is it?
- rglullis 12y agoSeriously asking, what opportunities are denied to women in sports?
- bdcravens 12y agoMost high schools and colleges dedicate a very small portion of the sports budget to women's sport as opposed to men's.
- iamthebest 12y agoNo this is completely wrong. Look up Title IX. It's the reason the university I went to e.g. had a women's swim team but not a men's team.
- EpicEng 12y agoActually, they don't, but the male sports, particularly football, do pay for the female sports.
- fhars 12y agoBeing noticed at all at the top level? What is the difference between the price payed for an ad at the men's superbowl, versus an ad at the women's superbowl?
- jessaustin 12y agoIs there a single woman on any of the teams in any of the leagues listed at the following? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_professional_sports_leagues_by_revenue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_professional_sports_lea...
- EpicEng 12y agoIt's a list sorted by revenue. Female sports don't make a fraction of what male sports do. Female's in general are not as interested in sports as makes are. Whether cultural or not is debatable, though I imagine at least a large part of it is. However, a list like this is not proof that women are not allowed the opportunity, only that, when given the opportunity, they have failed to capitalize on it. Look at the WNBA. I of course admit that the argument can get circular. Current culture -> unsuccessful female sports -> reinforcement of current culture. EDIT: Care to comment? What about this is factually incorrect?
- DanBC 12y agoThey get paid less; they don't get to set their pay; but it's somehow their fault that they get paid less?
- rglullis 12y agoIt's the same for men in fashion. It is just a matter of market value. We are talking about opportunities here, not how valued they are.
- jessaustin 12y agoYou can talk about whatever you want. When I kicked off the thread, it was to point out how the structure of sports in our society puts women in a ghetto, in ways that e.g. the admittedly imperfect tech industry doesn't even approach, and yet sports get a complete pass on this. Even many outspoken feminists settle for Title-IX-style resource-grubbing rather than challenging the basic structure of the ghetto. Any argument you might make defending the sports status quo would have applied to any sexist cultural institution ever. Case in point: every single sentence in the comment to which this is a response.
- wj 12y agoA better solution might be to create new sports that allow men and women to compete together rather than to change existing sports. Fans of existing sports are often very opposed to change for many reasons not least of which is that changes hamper the ability to compare athletes and teams over history. Many an hour has been spent having those arguments...err...discussions.
- jordanpg 12y ago> few proposals from feminists This is ludicrous. Womens' rights activists have talked about this since the beginning and often. Women have been explicitly banned from almost all sports that are associated with men only for most of their existence. There have always been women who wanted to play. This is slowly, slowly changing, as activists continue to fight for it, tooth and nail. Their gains are quickly assimilated and forgotten. It is not the case that sports would need to change. This is an old canard. Remember, all normal distributions have tails and pro-athletes, whatever their sex, are in those tails. Up until recently, women couldn't ski in the Olympic long jump because it was believe it would damage their reproductive systems. Wonder who was writing the rules? http://thesocietypages.org/sexuality/2010/01/09/reproductive-rights-and-athletics-the-curious-tale-of-female-ski-jumpers/ http://thesocietypages.org/sexuality/2010/01/09/reproductive...
- jessaustin 12y agoWomens' rights activists have talked about this since the beginning and often. Really? Who has said that our society would be better off if the NFL or NBA were replaced by some other league that offered any opportunity whatsoever for women to compete at the highest level? There have always been women who wanted to play. Of course! I certainly didn't intend to imply otherwise. In fact I've spent much of my time playing and watching stuff like the horse sports and kendo, which in all important respects women play just as well as men. I've also heard this about distance swimming. Perhaps ski jumping is another such sport? I don't know it well enough to say, but if it is, or if it can be made so, I'd say that it will be better for our culture to have more of it.
- protomyth 12y agoMotorsports are about the most even, but consistent winning is probably another generation out since car time is so important.
- hackuser 12y ago> It is true that many sports would have to change in fundamental ways to allow women and men to compete together at the highest level. That isn't really an excuse, though, is it? A very good point. But on the other hand, entrenched fields of endeavor are hard to change regardless of the social issues involved. Business, politics, and software development are fields where women always have had the physical ability to compete equally, but change is very, very slow.