4 ms·
Welcome to Africa - one step forward two steps back.
by Havoc 12y ago
Welcome to Africa - one step forward two steps back.
- perlgeek 12y agoWelcome to the wealthy nation's interactions with Africa. To think "we" can tell people what problem they should solve (Malaria) when not even their food supply is secured, that's just hubris. Knowing Maslow's hierarchy of needs, it's Physiological needs (food) vs Safety needs (Malaria protection). And the former are more basic, so expecting anything else shows little foresight (easy to say in hindsight, I know).
- frozenport 12y agoWe solved other diseases without solving the food problem.
- erroneousfunk 12y agoYes, but you couldn't eat the vaccinations. This particular problem is caused by the safety solution also, accidentally, doubling as a means to procure food.
- lumpypua 12y agoWe need to work on both simultaneously, if only for our own safety. The eradication of smallpox was a major success in the 20th century and treating it in Africa was instrumental. It does no good to try and eliminate dangerous diseases if we leave reservoirs, just because those populations are not food secure. Obviously malaria has its own transmission dynamic that doesn't directly apply here, but for infectious disease generally (eg. ebola) African safety needs are an important part of our own safety.
- evanpw 12y agoFrom the article: "experts say that the vast majority of mosquito nets are used exactly the way they were intended". There's also good evidence that they work: http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/insecticide-treated-nets http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/ins.... If you don't buy that, then GiveWell's #2 charity just hands out cash to poor people in Africa. Those guys know what they're doing.
- Havoc 12y ago>To think "we" can tell people what problem As per my comment on another post I do not fall into your idea of "we". I've spent all of my life in Africa. Much of it under mosquito nets. Much like other posters here you're approaching this from an academic point of view (maslow etc). The truth is very different. Eg did you know that DDT is still (officially) being used to combat malaria? As in they spray that stuff on houses (it's compulsory for some areas). Enjoy the birthdefects. Another poster here reckoned my pessimism is unwarranted. What does it take for it to be warranted? Africa... One step forward two steps back.
- rukittenme 12y agoI want to throw in that people are too quick to group 'Africa' together. It's like getting mad at Europe for Russia's incursions into Ukraine.
- hristov 12y agoThis is not true and this type of fatalism is just not warranted. Malaria deaths have actually been decreasing the last 20 years or so. And that is impressive because population has been increasing. http://www.who.int/gho/malaria/epidemic/deaths/en/ http://www.who.int/gho/malaria/epidemic/deaths/en/ The ecology of a country is a very complex system and becomes even more complex if you throw humans into it. So any significant aid is bound to have unintended side effects. Thus, any aid must be accompanied by close monitoring and modified when necessary. This particular problem, for example, can be easily solved by making nets weaker so they break during fishing. But one should not take any side effect as an excuse to stop aid. Unless of course one is looking for any excuse to stop aid.
- Havoc 12y ago>This is not true and this type of fatalism is just not warranted. No? I bet I've spent more years in Africa than you have (my entire life). Also spent thousands of nights under mosquito nets. Ever seen someone fish with a mosquito net? I have. "ecology of a country"? Spare me the armchair commander BS. "Western" people mostly miss the plot. Eg vaccination. Massive freaking supply chain operation to get the stuff to Africa (great success) ... Mobile LPG powered refrigeration etc. High Five. Local witchdoctor says these things are evil - entire shipping of mission critical vaccines expire on site. (true story) One step forward two steps back. ..
- sangnoir 12y ago>No? I bet I've spent more years in Africa than you have This sound like an appeal to non-authority. How does seeing someone fishing with a mosquito net discount the fact that malaria deaths have been decreasing for 20 years? (a point you chose to ignore, by the way). Africa is not a monolith: it's 54-countries strong with a multitude of cultures (I'd bet you'd be hard-pressed to find a "local witch doctor" in Tunis). You are entitled to your opinion, just because you live there doesn't automatically make you an expert. I too have spent my entire life in (southern) Africa.