3 ms·
> They have set the terms under which she can have them publish her data. She doesn't like them. She has the choice to walk away. That is not an accurate descr
by tzs 12y ago
> They have set the terms under which she can have them publish her data. She doesn't like them. She has the choice to walk away.
That is not an accurate description of the situation. Her music will still be published on YouTube if she doesn't accept their terms and walks away. She will have to take action (endless DMCA requests) if she wants to try to have her data not published on YouTube.
The terms they are offering are not the terms to have her data published on YouTube. They are the terms to get a cut of the money Google makes from her data on YouTube.
What you are describing is how Apple or Amazon work--if an artist walks away from their deals, their content is not on that service.
- asuffield 12y agoI don't think that's precisely right either. If I've understood the article correctly, she has three options here: sign up to the new agreement and continue receiving revenue from third party uploads that ContentID matches to her content, stop receiving third-party revenue and leave all third party videos up, or stop receiving the revenue and take all third party videos down. I'm not sure this would even stop her from getting ad revenue from videos that she uploads herself (the article doesn't discuss this). ContentID accounts are about getting revenue from things other people upload that include your content.