5 ms·
How is it possible in 2015 that major kernels are vulnerable to arbitrary code execution via null pointer dereference? Leave aside memory safety, input validat
by geofft 12y ago
How is it possible in 2015 that major kernels are vulnerable to arbitrary code execution via null pointer dereference?
Leave aside memory safety, input validation, actually caring about the quality of your work, whatever. mmap_min_addr stopped a ton of attacks back in like 2007-10 when Linux had a local privilege escalation-of-the-month (and RHEL, which hadn't enabled it yet for backwards-compatibility concerns, got hit more frequently). It's not a particularly aesthetically-pleasing solution, but it's an effective one.
Are there legacy apps on OS X that require mapping the zero page? Executable? That Apple cares about supporting?
I've run into two things on Linux that need to map the zero page: versions of MIT Scheme from before 2009 (because the compiler was doing something super weird), and Wine, when running certain DOS / Windows 3.1 apps. Anything of that era probably stopped working on OS X when they killed Classic. Even Carbon has been dead for three years.
https://wiki.debian.org/mmap_min_addr https://wiki.debian.org/mmap_min_addr
https://access.redhat.com/articles/20484 https://access.redhat.com/articles/20484
- mmarks 12y ago>> Even Carbon has been dead for three years. <<< With regard to only this point, probably half if not more of the the top 15 grossing games on the Mac AppStore Games page today are either Carbon Apps or at minimum require the Carbon framework.
- daniel02216 12y agoAnd a bunch of those are using Wine, which requires mapping code at the zero page, so they're compiled with a special load command that allows them to map the zero page. On Yosemite, 64-bit binaries aren't allowed to do this.
- geofft 12y agoWhoa, seriously? I didn't realize Wine for OS X was real enough to be usable for anything, let alone be admitted to the app store and make it to the top. That's pretty awesome. Although every time I go "I didn't realize X on Y worked", it seems like games are the rationale, and not very surprisingly, since they exercise a relatively small part of the API surface apart from OpenGL. (Mono, some HTML 5 things as mobile apps, and Humble Bundle's asm.js collection all come to mind.) Can OS X take a cue from iOS and require a special Apple-signed entitlement to do this (unless root overrides it in a config file), or is it not worth the trouble? Also, does Wine actually require this in general? My understanding was that Wine needed this for legacy Windows apps that themselves map the zero page, but recent-ish apps designed for XP or later shouldn't do that, right?
- sitharus 12y agoWine on OS X has been stable enough for gaming for years! Sims 3 used it, as does EVE Online, and quite a few other major titles, mostly those from EA. They all use TransGaming's Cider fork though, I'm not sure if TransGaming every contribute back to the Wine community these days. CodeWeaver's Crossover is quite good as well. It can play Skyrim on my 2012 MPB with decent quality. I mostly use it for older games though - rollercoaster tycoon and the like.
- mzs 12y agohttps://code.google.com/p/google-security-research/issues/detail?id=135&q=label%3AVendor-Apple https://code.google.com/p/google-security-research/issues/de... That was a kernel null dereference, it really has nothing to do with creating a mach-o that puts code in the first page and there are valid reasons to do it, SheepShaver and BasilliskII come to mind.
- geofft 12y agoRight, the null pointer gets dereferenced in the kernel, but (assuming I'm understanding the report right) the means of exploitation is to create a userspace memory mapping with something mapped at address zero, and cause the kernel to read from that address / run code at that address instead of faulting when it tries to dereference NULL. The PoC code is userspace and does this: //map NULL page vm_deallocate(mach_task_self(), 0x0, 0x1000); addr = 0; vm_allocate(mach_task_self(), &addr, 0x1000, 0); char* np = 0; for (int i = 0; i < 0x1000; i++){ np[i] = 'A'; } Am I misinterpreting this? Re SheepShaver and Basilisk II, those are non-Mac apps, and at least on Linux, there's no requirement for an emulator (like qemu) to map address zero in the host to offer a usable zero page in the guest; it's a convenience depending on how you write the emulator, but it's by no means needed. I don't think this is true of other host platforms either, but I'm less familiar with those.
- Animats 12y agoHow is it possible in 2015 that major kernels are vulnerable to arbitrary code execution via null pointer dereference? Because they're monolithic, bloated, and written in C. (Rust guys, please don't screw up. We need a win there.)
- danieldk 12y ago> (Rust guys, please don't screw up. We need a win there.) While it's true that Rust would help here, it is very unlikely that a Rust kernel project would get as far as e.g. Linux and let alone replace it. Of course, rewriting and existing kernel stepwise would be interesting, if possible.
- runeks 12y ago> Of course, rewriting and existing kernel stepwise would be interesting, if possible. Perhaps it's possible to write a new kernel in Rust, and have it be backwards compatible with Linux, by "wrapping" the Linux kernel and drivers in sandboxes? So a Rust kernel with some kind of built-in environment isolation, in which it can run the real Linux kernel. The running Linux kernel would then access physical hardware through a wrapper in the Rust kernel, while the Rust kernel would access hardware directly. That's really the only way I see this project gaining widespread adoption: by leveraging Linux. Linux simply has too much momentum to be replaced with something non-compatible. Of course, a Rust kernel could be useful for all kinds of things other than replacing Linux. Like a Mirage OS-type kernel that uses Rust to write drivers in Rust (instead of OCaml).
- pjmlp 12y agoI don't see that happening with Linux, though. Linux as a UNIX clone, will never use anything else other than C. Replacing C in MirageOS sounds more likely.
- icebraining 12y agoWouldn't that essentially be an hypervisor written in Rust?
- josephpmay 12y agoCould this be solved by writing an operating system in Rust?
- geofft 12y agoYes, mostly, although that's a fairly big undertaking, and any code you have that uses unsafe blocks, or legacy C code (think proprietary drivers), or the like is going to be a weakness. mmap_min_addr is a mitigation measure, by saying, OK maybe we'll dereference NULL sometimes, but we're going to make totally sure that there's nothing mapped there, and certainly nothing that userspace put there. So if we do dereference null, it's just a crash, not execution of userspace-provided code in kernelspace. And it's the sort of thing that you can turn on in an existing kernel. Rewriting the whole kernel in Rust is a major (but worthwhile) project; adding this restriction is, in its simplest form, just adding `if (addr < 4096) return -EFAULT` to the page-allocation routine. As another commenter pointed out, OS X does have this restriction for 64-bit binaries now.