7 ms·
Um, it's pretty clear what she needs to do. Let Google block and take her fans to a different service. And encourage other artists to do the same. And then s
by bsder 12y ago
Um, it's pretty clear what she needs to do. Let Google block and take her fans to a different service. And encourage other artists to do the same. And then sue Google for infringement when Google doesn't actually manage to keep their music off of YouTube. That's the only way that Google will ever pay attention.
If she doesn't help overturn this, Google will just keep doing it.
Yes, this is the standard problem. She, individually, has to take the hit so that the musicians, collectively, benefit. It sucks.
The independent artists really need to get together and build their own service with the terms they need so they don't have to keep fighting Google, Spotify, etc.
- smacktoward 12y agoI bet independent artists would love to live in a world where they, even collectively, have the kind of money it would take to win a legal fight with Google, or to build a viable competitor.
- icebraining 12y agoViacom has plenty of money, and even they lost. Twice, in fact.
- bsder 12y agoViacom weren't exactly the most sympathetic of defendants.
- icebraining 12y agoOr maybe they simply didn't have a case. Like it or not, the safe harbor clause exists.
- metaphorm 12y agoplaintiff. they were the plaintiff in that case.
- vitd 12y agoDidn't they lose partly because it was discovered that they were the ones uploading the "infringing videos"?
- icebraining 12y agoAs far as I know, that wasn't part of the rulings, no.
- DrJosiah 12y agoThey did some of the uploading, yes. But I don't recall if that was part of the reason why Viacom lost.
- Animats 12y agoWikipedia: "Viacom did not seek damages for any actions after Google put its Content ID filtering system in place in early 2008." Google and Viacom ultimately settled. So the issue of whether Google can tie Content ID to giving them rights to content hasn't been litigated yet. Meanwhile, Facebook is getting serious about taking on YouTube. Maybe they'll offer a better deal.
- rhino369 12y agoFor 1/3rd of the cut, you'd find plenty of lawyers. The issue is DMCA is very pro web-host, they'd never win.
- newaccountfool 12y agoDMCA is in no way pro web-host. You can send out mass takedown requests and some hosts will choose to remove the content without even contacting the host of said infringing content.
- metaphorm 12y agoits pro-webhost with respect to generally not holding hosts liable for damages as long as they comply with DMCA requests.
- rhino369 12y agoThe alternative was holding them liable for anything they put on their servers.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThat alternative isn't even plausible. Hosts have no practical way to determine whether the users own or have licensed the content they post so it makes no sense to impose liability on them. The realistic alternative is the CDA safe harbor which has no takedown procedure. If you have e.g. a libel claim you have to go after the actual poster. It also isn't clear whether they would even have any liability without the safe harbor, because it was put into place early enough that we don't really know what happens without it. But you don't generally expect the Post Office to be liable for what people send in the mail.
- sp332 12y agoThat's worse than the current system. In the current system, the host can just take down the infringing content (until the uploader challenges the takedown), and pass along a warning to the uploader. The person complaining about the infringement never gets personal info about who the uploader is. In your scenario, the webhost would leave the content up but they would have to identify the uploader.
- jawns 12y agoIt would be cool to see a worker-owned cooperative, 100% owned by its member artists, become established in this space. It's not as infeasible as you might think; artists' cooperatives, as a business structure, have a long history, and creating a digital space is, in many respects, more cost-effective than a brick-and-mortar location.
- vertex-four 12y agoI've had thoughts in this area before. Such a co-op could build a platform on which they can share media, crowdfund, sell whatever, and whatever else the artists want to do to get themselves out there. Even if they didn't build and run the platform themselves directly (due to the fact that a bunch of artists have better things to do) - if they contracted out the development and maintenance to a third-party company - they'd have ownership over the platform, be able to switch maintenance company, and therefore take their fanbases with them if things start going wrong.
- settsu 12y agoWhat about a Bandcamp+Vimeo partnership?
- SwellJoe 12y agoIt is challenging, if not impossible, for a cooperative to obtain funding for that push into "really big" that nearly every major tech company has had to raise. There is no exit strategy for a cooperative, no cash out option for investors. Cooperatives historically raise money from their members, or use traditional loans, neither of which is feasible for the kind of independent artists that would benefit from this type of entity. It would need a benevolent, and very wealthy, collection of artists or sympathetic patrons to fund growth, or it would simply be out-gunned by the rest of the industry that actively works against artist independence. One of my businesses is a worker-owned cooperative. It has challenges that are completely novel to me (having started two small traditional corporations before that), and they're very difficult to overcome. Herding cats is hard, operating under the cooperative principles is hard(er than doing it all for profit), and raising money is effectively impossible for many types of cooperative, as far as I can tell. Building a competing music or video service to YouTube and Spotify would require tremendous resources, and without the big cash-out promised by those ventures, I don't know how one would make it work.
- magicalist 12y ago> And then sue Google for infringement when Google doesn't actually manage to keep their music off of YouTube You almost definitely couldn't successfully sue (Safe Harbour). You could file a DMCA takedown, though.
- bsder 12y agoThey're not going to get safe harbor if they've got the ability to block and monetize--that's not common carrier and they are exerting control. The first problem is that YouTube is effectively a monopoly. The app is default installed on 2/3 of all smartphones, and the server bandwidth is subsidized by Google so that competitors really can't get traction. If we had a viable YouTube competitor, these terms would get smashed. The second problem is that DMCA takedown is an unfair burden on the artist. After you have to file some number of the things over time, it should be considered a willful infringement by the service if it is collecting money. Instead, Google gets to have it both ways: it gets to extract money while sitting behind the DMCA as a shield.
- icebraining 12y agoThey're not going to get safe harbor if they've got the ability to block and monetize--that's not common carrier and they are exerting control. "Common carrier" is an ISP term, it doesn't apply here anyway. Google won't be liable as long as they (1) aren't aware of the infringing videos and (2) take them down after receiving a DMCA complaint. I don't see how their ability to block them changes this - it's pretty established that these services are not required to proactively monitor their content. After you have to file some number of the things over time, it should be considered a willful infringement by the service if it is collecting money. That would kill any user content service that has ads, not only Youtube. How exactly do you propose they'd do such a thing? ContentID is far from infallible, and many sites can't even afford to build such a technology - in fact, if you required automated takedown based on content recognition, you'd only be strengthening Youtube's position. Instead, Google gets to have it both ways: it gets to extract money while sitting behind the DMCA as a shield. And the phone service gets to charge money when criminals place calls to conspire to commit crimes. So what? By the way, I agree that this move is pretty shitty by Google. No argument there.
- jkyle 12y agoI'm not sure that strategy would work. Her only recourse would be to file DMCA take down notices on unauthorized content uploads. As long as Google complied with the take down process, they could not be sued. If she doesn't file a DMCA, they could not be sued. Google isn't held accountable for the uploads of their as long as they follow those rules. Remember, if they _could_ be sued solely for content appearing on their site and even if no take down was filed Youtube (or any other content site) would likely not exist as they would have been sued out of business long ago.
- mdasen 12y agoContent ID brings up an interesting twist on the DMCA. If a provider has "actual knowledge" of infringement, safe harbor doesn't apply. When Viacom sued Google/YouTube, they claimed that Google/YouTube had "general knowledge" of infringement. That isn't enough. Google is paying this person for use of their work. They have knowledge and it could be argued that they obtained a license. They want to renegotiate the terms of that license. The DMCA isn't a tool to be used to force artists to license their content on terms that favor YouTube. The actual safe harbor text (17 U.S.C. § 512(c)(1)(A)): i. does not have actual knowledge that the material or an activity using the material on the system or network is infringing; ii. in the absence of such actual knowledge, is not aware of facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent; or iii. upon obtaining such knowledge or awareness, acts expeditiously to remove, or disable access to, the material. It's certainly questionable whether Content ID gives Google "actual knowledge" of infringement happening. But the rule isn't that content only has to be taken down when given a DMCA notice. Once Google has "actual knowledge", they need to take action. And I think that's the alternative that Google would do. Videos that match the Content ID would be removed. I think the issue is that the artist doesn't want to be so punitive to fans who are caught in the middle. Google knows that artists don't want to hurt their fans and is leveraging that against them. I don't think this would become a DMCA issue at all. It's more an issue of Google having the market power to be a price/terms setter. Google seems more than willing to use Content ID to block infringement, but also has the positioning to reply to the user, "this artist has decided you, the uploader who worked hard on that video, that you're not allowed to use their music. Maybe you should hate that artist and like one of these other artists. . ." A bit of hyperbole, but you can see how an artist wouldn't want to position themselves that way.
- Kalium 12y ago> And then sue Google for infringement when Google doesn't actually manage to keep their music off of YouTube. This is an egregious abuse of copyright. It is not ethical to encourage this.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoIt's not ethical for a distributor to strong-arm the hands that feed it on a 5 year basis, no matter how small a slice of the pie it may be. Google has DMCA takedown capabilities. I'd suggest simply hiring a third party to monitor Google and send appropriate take-down notices. Then, on an annual basis, submit the invoice to Google. It's dirty pool, but then again, when has the music industry ever been a transparent and constructive and profitable enterprise for anybody outside of the top 1% of performers/acts/songwriters?
- icebraining 12y agoThen, on an annual basis, submit the invoice to Google. I doubt Google would be liable for such expenses.
- Kalium 12y ago> It's not ethical for a distributor to strong-arm the hands that feed it on a 5 year basis, no matter how small a slice of the pie it may be. In the business world, this is known as negotiation. It's normal and ethical. Here, it's like being in a big store. You can buy the thing on the shelf or not, but you don't get to haggle over the price. Zoe wants to haggle over the price until it's something convenient for her. > I'd suggest simply hiring a third party to monitor Google and send appropriate take-down notices. This is abuse. This will have a chilling effect on free expression.
- 6stringmerc 12y agoReally? It's abuse? Then what has RIAA been doing to actively patrol Google, YouTube and other services all these years? I'll tell you what: https://www.dmcaforce.com/ https://www.dmcaforce.com/
- zokier 12y ago> The independent artists really need to get together and build their own service with the terms they need so they don't have to keep fighting Google, Spotify, etc. Isn't that what Bandcamp is? And SoundCloud, and probably gazillion other similar services?
- andrelayer 12y agoArtists go where the fans are, and they're all on Youtube.
- vermontdevil 12y agoThat's how United Artists was founded. By a group of actors/directors to break up the commercial studio monopoly. Now it's a subsidiary of another studio. Go figure.
- MaysonL 12y agoUnited Artists for music. I wonder what would happen if Taylor Swift took this on as a project?