3 ms·
I see stuff like this and I wonder about two things: 1) there is another open source (BSD) database - postgresql 2) why should it matter, since the whole purpos
by protomyth 17y ago
I see stuff like this and I wonder about two things:
1) there is another open source (BSD) database - postgresql
2) why should it matter, since the whole purpose of the GPL is to keep Oracle from "destroying" MySQL. Didn't the GPL protect the users in this case?
- nwatson 17y agoI'm sure if Oracle abandons MySQL then after some initial confusion developers and users will settle on 1 or 2 forks and continue from there. Some are already forking MySQL to scratch their own itch.
- protomyth 17y agoI guess the main people it hurts is commercial software developers that paid a license fee to not have to open source their code. None of the forks would be able to do the licenses.
- keyist 17y agoHere's the letter to the EC written by Stallman et al the OP is referring to: http://keionline.org/ec-mysql http://keionline.org/ec-mysql . Shocking of eWeek to leave out the link. The key paragraphs imo are: "As only the original rights holder can sell commercial licenses, no new forked version of the code will have the ability to practice the parallel licensing approach, and will not easily generate the resources to support continued development of the MySQL platform. The acquisition of MySQL by Oracle will be a major setback to the development of a FLOSS database platform, potentially alienating and dispersing MySQL's core community of developers [...]" No license can fully protect users from developer inactivity or not knowing where to go when they have problems. In this case the problem is particularly acute because MySQL AB has been known as the go-to place for a long time, and this may no longer be viable in the event of Oracle's acquisition. EDIT: Simon Phipps (Sun) wrote an eloquent piece about the dual licensing aspect: http://www.webmink.net/2009/10/remarkable-reversal.htm http://www.webmink.net/2009/10/remarkable-reversal.htm
- protomyth 17y agoI am in awe of the thinking that a commercial option is needed for MySQL and that Stallman agrees with that. It just seems so counter to all the comments on the GPL. I don't really see the support argument, a lot of software gets orphaned. Companies need to have plans for this kind of stuff. They are better off here because they might be able to hire people to fix compatibility issues until they can migrate to another platform. I think "major setback to the development of a FLOSS database platform" is kinda bs given the existence of postgresql.
- tensor 17y agoI completely agree with your first paragraph. It is amazing to see Stallman, the very founder and long time advocate of "Free" software and the GPL, admitting that a closed and open approach to software is needed. That seems very different than what he has always preached. Then again, perhaps I have not listened to his speech in enough depth.
- mscarborough 17y agoRegardless of whether there is a 'commercial' option for the source code itself, there is plenty going on with GPL-based development and an alternative for InnoDB led by Monty Widenius (Monty AB's development of the Maria Engine should lessen the concern due to Oracle's purchase of InnoBase and their patent ownership / 'original author' status). It's already been discussed at length, so I'll just say I'm not convinced it's in Oracle's best interest to try to kill off InnoDB in order to decrease consumer options for MySQL. I guess we'll see what they do if the EC approves. But the market for 'commercial services' around MySQL is doing just fine -- Percona and MontyDB being the most obvious (more here: http://lwn.net/Articles/329626/ http://lwn.net/Articles/329626/). Not an endorsement, but our team decided to start using Percona and it's been OK; over the last couple years we didn't end up using MySQL AB's support that much anyway.
- rbanffy 17y agoWhere is Richard Stallman and what did they do to him? Now, on a more serious tone, a program dies when nobody uses or is interested on it. MySQL will inevitably die someday, replaced by something better, much like MySQL itself replaced mSQL. The GPL will make its source available forever, protecting users who may be interested in continuing it. As for PostgreSQL, it saddens me to say its BSD licensing provides no such protection. If people lose interest in it, it will probably evolve some more in the form of EnterpriseDB and the source may be lost or locked up forever. Isn't Drizzle a worthy successor to MySQL?