9 ms·
Lords Sneak UK Internet Snooping Law into Bill
- disputin 12y agoFor every action, there is an equal an opposite reaction.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI hope if something like this gets passed, there will be a massive protest, not just in the streets, but everyone starting to use Tor, TextSecure and other such apps they are most worried about.
- kbart 12y agoI doubt that very much. Masses don't care about privacy, the dominating view is still that of "I have nothing to hide" and "let police do their job -- think of a children/terrorism" or any other mantra that's popular at the time. Look at Snowden story, only tech sector and human right activists care, there were no widespread protest, no political action, and since then surveillance only broadens. Especially in UK, which is has CCTVs on every corner (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/10172298/One-surveillance-camera-for-every-11-people-in-Britain-says-CCTV-survey.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/10172298/One-surveilla...).
- ComputerGuru 12y agoMod: s/sneek/sneak/ please.
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoThe Lords are actually more often known for stopping the passing of bills that sail through Parliament and really, really shouldn't have. Is this a deliberate attempt by the Lords to sabotage the passing of the main bill, by putting in something they know the coalition partners the Lib Dems already voted down? Seeing who tabled it, maybe not, but we need to be alert that the latest fight for our liberties won't just start at the next election. Better make sure the Lib Dems know. Ugh.
- pjc50 12y agoOne of the lords responsible is Ian Blair, the former Met Police commissioner. The one in charge at the time of the De Menezes shooting. The one who was a close friend of the News of the World at the time all the hacking was going on. This guy: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2008/aug/20/ian.blair.profile http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2008/aug/20/ian.blair.pr... http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/aug/26/lord-blair-laws-principled-leaking http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/aug/26/lord-blair-la...
- tomtoise 12y agoYour obtrusive and underhanded domestic spying law gets shot down by a democratic procedure? No problem! Just tack it onto a bill already being considered by the House of Lords and sidestep the whole pesky review process.
- themartorana 12y agoHappens in the US all the time, too. It's the very thing that makes the line-item veto so controversial. I want someone to be able to knock down pork (or worse, like this) added to non-related bills, at the last minute, in the middle of the night, with no debate. But do I want that power to always exist? Edit: happened like 5 times just last month and could have shut down the government. Now Dodd-Frank is all but dead, campaign donation limits are up from $92k to $777k, the EPA is further defunded, and more - all last minute riders with almost zero debate. http://www.newsweek.com/what-did-congress-sneak-last-minute-spending-deal-291090 http://www.newsweek.com/what-did-congress-sneak-last-minute-...
- iopq 12y agoI would say veto the entire bill until people stop doing this. Make it a matter of policy.
- tormeh 12y agoYou're proposing holding good governance hostage. You assume those people care about good governance.
- ck2 12y agoActually an even worse thing in our "democracy" is how a single person in congress can put a hold on a bill and bury it - while remaining completely anonymous. How the hell is that even possible Line item veto would be incredibly dangerous. We'd end up with 100% corporate welfare while the entire foodstamp program would be canceled.
- themartorana 12y ago
- jblok 12y agoBills like this worry me greatly as an advocate for internet freedoms and because of a desire to a right to privacy. When I discuss government plans for the internet with non-technical people it worries me even more that they aren't at all concerned about it. I hear arguments like 'I have nothing to hide' and 'If it stops terrorism, why not'. I try to tell people that they should demand a right to privacy from the state, but I find it hard to not come across as a tin foil hat wearing goverment-skeptic. What arguments do you use with people that don't understand the web all that well to get them to care about this stuff?
- pjc50 12y agoIt's tricky because people find it hard to see the big systematic picture, and "respectable" people like to assume that the police are the good guys and anyone they oppose must be a bad guy. Your best bet is to find something where they disagree with the government or officialdom and build out from there. The "council uses RIPA surveillance to catch woman sending child to school in different catchment area" story is a good one here; almost everyone thinks that councils are officious busybodies. Health records privacy is another good one. "Do you think the government should track all your alcohol purchases?" (I wrote in a previous comment with a US context: - legal. It's against the law; there are strong 1st and 4th arguments against surveillance, and 5th and 6th amendment arguments as well. Some people have even tried to argue that if encryption is a munition the 2nd amendment applies. The "we could stop bad people" argument applies especially to the 4th. Similar legal protections exist in Europe, although not generally as strong (article 8). - practical: either a system is secure or it isn't. Handing it over to anyone increases the risk of compromise. Bans on effective encryption are self-defeating. - collateral damage: US intelligence agencies have a track record of killing innocent people themselves (e.g. drone strikes), supporting murderous governments (CIA in south america), funding terrorism and failing to prosecute the guilty (Iran-contra), use of intelligence for domestic immoral politics (Watergate, FBI vs MLK). Handing over data about your e.g. Chilean users to the CIA may result in them being murdered. - international hypocrisy: saying that mass surveillance is OK says it's OK for other governments too. Do you support Chinese interception against their adversaries? Are you happy to turn over your entire email history on entering a country? - finally, I'm going to question how much it does help. The Paris terrorists were known to the police, as was the killer of Lee Rigby. Intercept evidence is generally not used in trials. Nobody is presenting a cache of encrypted emails found on a computer used by the Parisian terrorists and saying "if we'd decrypted this we could have prevented it". Edit: see also on HN today https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/british-spy-agency-considers-journalists-threat-vacuums-their-emails https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/british-spy-agency-con...
- iopq 12y agoWhy does the UK still have the house of the Lords? The elites don't control enough of the government?
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> Why does the UK still have the house of the Lords Why would the House of Lords stop existing? Not changing things is a tradition.
- iopq 12y agoBecause it's appointed elites deciding how the government should be run?
- inclemnet 12y agoThe standard argument is that it turns out appointed elites doing this works fairly well (they quite often block bad legislation), in principle partly because they don't have to pander directly to the electorate. I don't think it's an optimal system, but I can't deny it does have some advantages of this sort. The concern with changing it is that you could simply make things worse, even if on the surface more meritocratic. For instance, if it just ended up filled with the same career politicians as the commons and just agreed with everything they said. Of course it could end up better as well, in principle, but I'm not sure the government could be trusted to implement things that way.
- calgoo 12y agoWell, at least they could rename them!!!! House of Lords really sounds like they are supposed to be above everyone else. And while you are at it, remove commons as well, as it sounds really degrading. Suggestions for new names anyone?
- coherentpony 12y agoThere's already a term, and we (the UK) uses it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upper_house https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upper_house Edit: And the Commons is called the Lower House<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lower_house> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lower_house>. In a parliamentary system, the lower house actually has more power.
- contingencies 12y agoThe west has pursued an industrialisation path that allows for the privatisation of wealth from the commons, along with the criminalisation of commons rights of the public, as well as the externalisation of all true costs. [...] Our entire commercial, diplomatic, and informational systems are now cancerous. - Robert David Steele, The Guardian, 2014-06-19
- andy_ppp 12y agoDemocracy at work here - an unelected group of bureaucrats, mostly party donors (i.e. people who have bribed government for the privilege of being made a Lord) definitely seem like the right people to be making these calls on liberty and having the ability to change the law.
- goombastic 12y agoLooks like we need version control for bills.
- declan 12y agoThis could happen in the U.S. as well. Our esteemed politicians and federal police have proposed a new law with exactly the same approach. I disclosed some of these efforts in this 2012 article: "The FBI general counsel's office has drafted a proposed law...requiring that social-networking Web sites and providers of VoIP, instant messaging, and Web e-mail alter their code to ensure their products are wiretap-friendly. 'If you create a service, product, or app that allows a user to communicate, you get the privilege of adding that extra coding'" http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-we-need-wiretap-ready-web-sites-now/ http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-we-need-wiretap-ready-web-sites... Here's another article from 2006 talking about Rep. Diana DeGette (D-Colorado). She had originally proposed legislation imposing data retention requirements on ISPs, but then wanted to extend it to Facebook, Xanga, MySpace, etc. (to be fair, Rs have made similar proposals): http://news.cnet.com/Congress-targets-social-networking-sites/2100-1028_3-6089574.html http://news.cnet.com/Congress-targets-social-networking-site... I can't easily find the link to another piece I wrote, but DOJ/FBI reps have also talked about including photo-sharing sites. This is in addition to the FBI wanting to force ISPs to keep track of every web site that customers visit (not just IPs assigned): http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-wants-records-kept-of-web-sites-visited/ http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-wants-records-kept-of-web-sites... So far these proposals have not become law, meaning that the types of companies well-represented here on HN don't have to keep records of their users' activities for future police access. I've been critical of AT&T/VZ/Comcast/etc. over surveillance here before, but I'll give them credit for this: Those of us working on social/email/etc. startups aren't targeted by all these regulations today because of ISPs' defensive DC efforts over many years. They're doing it because of self-interest, true, but the spillover effect is real.