4 ms·
Interviews and letters of application might seem like a good idea, but on closer inspection it isn't. As you could expect, an industry of "consultants" has emer
by alkonaut 12y ago
Interviews and letters of application might seem like a good idea, but on closer inspection it isn't. As you could expect, an industry of "consultants" has emerged, helping rich kids get into Ivy League schools, by interview training and "helping them" write letters of application (i.e. writing it for them). So the grass doesn't seem much greener.
Perhaps the best system would be a combination of anonymized grades/scores combined with anonymized interviews?
- mantas 12y agoThere're always people who want to game the system :( I still think that interviews/applications are better on theoretical level though. Maybe it's because I didn't do very well in high school :) Anonymization definitely helps. It's strictly enforced on national exams there and it seems to work pretty well. I'd focus on ensuring that applicants themselves do the job though. For example, application letters could be written in a controlled environment, without any help from 3rd party. Some people would memorise prepared letters, but it would make it a wee bit more fair. P.S. Anonymous interviews would look great. Live Robot voice converter, full face (body?) mask... I'd watch this movie.
- alkonaut 12y agoI think the catholics have all but perfected the anonymous dialogue...
- rjaco31 12y agoSo basically, some kind of big national exam with both a written and an oral part.