4 ms·
How is a piece of paper any more valuable than a hash though? They're all just place holders.
by donatj 12y ago
How is a piece of paper any more valuable than a hash though? They're all just place holders.
- discodave 12y agoThe piece of paper is more valuable than the hash because more people will accept it as legal tender.
- laichzeit0 12y agoAre you implying that this should happen overnight? over the course of 2-5 years? over the course of 20-50 years? Because I bought a pair of Sennheiser headphones from a local audio equipment selling website and this in bumfuck South Africa we're talking about. I doubt the merchant is even aware they accept Bitcoin as "legal tender" since it happened through PayFast and was completely transparent to them. The point is _I_ could use it as legal tender. So from my point of view it has incredibly amount of value.
- lil_cain 12y agoUsing it to buy things in a shop is not the same as using it as 'legal tender'. Bitcoin is not legal tender anywhere in the world.
- laichzeit0 12y agoThe OP commented: "because more people will accept it as legal tender." the word "more" implying that at least one or more people already accept it as "legal tender" as per whatever definition he uses of "legal tender".
- jafaku 12y agoActually, Bitcoin is already accepted by more people than many fiat currencies.
- jafaku 12y agoDownvoted for stating facts. Way to go, HN!
- MarkMc 12y agoThe US dollar is backed by a promise by the US government to (a) keep the value fairly stable, relative to a common basket of consumer goods; and (b) accept them for payment of US taxes. The long and stable history of the US government gives weight to these promises.
- Ologn 12y agoEspecially since the dollar was exchangeable for the 10,000 tons of gold stored in Fort Knox etc. prior to 1971. Those 10,000 tons of gold are still there - obviously as a means to back the dollar (what alternative explanation is there?) An announcement on the news by the president that a gram of gold could be gotten for X dollars would be enough to put a floor under the dollar. Bitcoin does not have 10000 tons of gold in reserve backing it. We don't even know the identity of the person who invented this scam. The truth is this scam really ended in November 2013 when Bitcoins were worth $1100 and they cashed in to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars. That these worthless hashes still have people paying $226 a pop for them is a sign of all those things stated here on HN of all that loose money sloshing around due to monetary easing. It reminds me of all those subprime loan billboards I saw in the ghetto in 2007, or the pets.com Super Bowl commercials, and other such bubbles. The kids who did Dogecoin created a $14 million market cap with some goofy 4chan pictures and memes. The $3 billion market cap for worthless Bitcoin hashes are equally ludicrous. Why are Bitcoins collectively worth $3 billion? It is an unanswerable question. The same reason the subprime real estate market, or Pets.com-type dot bomb stocks, or Dutch tulip bulbs for that matter attained crazy prices. Bubbles happen. This is the first time I can recall that something completely worthless became worth $3 billion though ($13 billion before the scam started unwinding).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Ologn 12y agoIt's instructive of all the commodities out there in the world, you point to the only other one of questionable value as an example, "unbacked" paper currency. But obviously just because people use dollars (or euros) does not mean Bitcoin has any value. The answer to the question of why fiat money has lasted for 44 years is too much to go into in an HN comment. It can be answered in a questions like you did though. Why, with 10000 years of civilization, if it is possible for a state to create non-precious currency of a lasting like gold out of nothing, why if this can be done, did states only start doing it in the past 44 years? The US allowed dollar to gold conversion prior to 1971, if the dollar really is priced on its own accord, why does the US still maintain over 10,000 tons of gold in Fort Knox and other facilities? In 1971, an ounce of gold was worth $40, today it is worth about $1290. Conversely, a dollar in 1971 would be worth about seventeen cents today. Why did gold retain its value but not the dollar?
- hnnewguy 12y ago>How is a piece of paper any more valuable than a hash though? You can pay your taxes with it. It's really just that simple; that's what gives fiat its value. Your government accepts it, thus it's backed by the productive capacity of the country.
- shillster 12y agoUtterly ridiculous; shills be shilling all up in this tread.