3 ms·
What is the probability your vote will make a difference? [pdf]
- gjm11 17y agoThis paper focuses specifically on US presidential elections, though the broad principles are applicable to other elections. One of the authors is Nate Silver (of fivethirtyeight.com), who has probably spent as much time doing statistics on US presidential election results as just about anyone else in the world. Another is Andrew Gelman, who's no slouch either. Academically he's got way more depth than Nate Silver, but he isn't as focused on elections. Authors Gelman and Edlin wrote a paper about why it might be rational (in utility-maximizing terms) to vote that's famous enough that I've read it (which isn't necessarily very famous). One-sentence summary (though the whole thing is only 9 pages long and not terribly scary): in a US election, your chance of deciding the election if you vote ranges from about 1 in 10^7 in swing states to about 1 in 10^10 or less in very one-sided states. The average vote, in some sense, has about one chance in 60 million of being decisive.
- diN0bot 17y agothe next statistic i want to see is the number of people effected by political advertisements...or say this paper.
- mattmaroon 17y agoThis fails to take into account margins of error. An election won by one vote would result in suits over the count being within the margin of error. In some states any result within a certain margin is decided by other means, including runoffs or even coin flips (though I'm not sure how this would apply in the case of a federal election). The hubbub over Coleman vs. Franken showed its not as simple as guy wins by 1 vote, gets elected.
- MarkPNeyer 17y agoThe assumption they make is that the payoff for voting on a decision is linearly proportional to the number of people the decision affects. In my case, that's not true - i don't get utility from telling other people what to do. Quite frankly, the assumption that people enjoy telling others what to do scares me. I'd like to think it isn't true, but something tells me that's just idealism.
- diN0bot 17y agoone's impact is not necessarily "telling others what to do," though i see your point when the consequence of this action is deciding legislatures or executives. nonetheless, i think the psychology behind caring about voting and, say, programming, is still similar: do i have an impact or am i just a rat in the maze?
- camccann 17y agoIt's not about you telling other people what to do, it's about picking someone else who will be telling people what to do. Nothing you do will change the fact that somebody will be selected; all you can do is influence the choice. Unless all candidates are (by your evaluation) of equal merit, voting for the one you prefer is (disregarding any costs of participation) pretty much by definition going to influence how much utility you get. And, unless you assign nonlinear utility (or none at all) to the experiences of other people, the number of people impacted is obviously going to be, in the limit, linearly proportional to the utility payoff. Gratuitous example: Political Candidate X runs on a platform that he will indefinitely imprison and torture 0.1% of the population, but only people that you personally have never (and will never meet). His opponent, Candidate Y, runs on a platform of doing absolutely nothing in office. How does the utility of voting for Candidate Y differ depending on whether the relevant population is a thousand people, or ten million?
- lifeisstillgood 17y agoVoting is like innoculation. I do not merely vote for a 'mainstream' candidate to ensure that my choice gets in. I also vote so that 'extreme' candidates are excluded. A vote for a mainstream candidate is an innoculation for society against extremist diseases. It is vanishingly unlikely that my vote will be at the exact tipping point, ie a hanging chad county in Florida. It is also unlikely that my innoculation against killer flu will be the one innocluation that stops the spread of the virus. But from society's point of view it does not matter - the more who are innoculated, the safer society is. Similarly, the more people who vote the more candidates need to pander to the mainstream opinion, not the extremist. In general we become safer. This all breaks down if mainstream opinion is actually 'wrong'. But thats a different issue. PS Here in the UK the fascist BNP have got two MEPs and will be controversially appearing on a wellknown politics talk show. Innoculations need to be kept up.