2 ms·
The Wrists of Birds Reveal Evolution Undoing Itself
- gumby 12y agoI don't really see why this should be especially remarkable or subject to some "law" (especially one framed back when evolution was still being characterized). It's not like evolution has a "direction" -- humans are not "more evolved" than chimps. It's simply that each generation the genes that provide the most "fitness" for the environment that an individual finds itself increase the probability that said individual will reproduce. The same individual in different environment (say a bird in a flood) may be less fit than another. Given that, even if a gene stops expressing itself most of the time, that doesn't mean it vanishes (it may, as their may be no selection to keep it); it may stochastically express from time to time and give some advantage in a new environment. Hell, most macro phenomena are the result of several gene expressions; a gene isn't just a single use subroutine. What a dumb article about an interesting aspect of birds.
- colin_mccabe 12y agoDarwin remarked on the tendency of organisms to re-express ancestral forms. Sorry, I don't have a citation, but I do remember some commentary about this by Stephen Jay Gould. It should be pretty clear to anyone following embryology that a lot of really ancient genes are still present in modern animals, waiting to be re-awakened when the time is right. It is possible that some evolutionary paths are unlikely to be trod more than once by the same organism, but it hardly seems worthy of being called a "law." Around the turn of the 20th century there was a lot of confusion and people still proposing non-Darwinian explanations of biology, so I'd be suspicious that this was just another example of that.