3 ms·
Your case is fair, and your advice is solid, but no one is sure it's appropriate. At IBM there is a distinct chain of command and people who have to interact wi
by rektide 12y ago
Your case is fair, and your advice is solid, but no one is sure it's appropriate. At IBM there is a distinct chain of command and people who have to interact with each other and a corporate body every day. A technical mailing list can certainly suffer from domineering people monopolizing the conversation as well, but most evidence we have of this- Systemd debates in Debian, Gentoo- show a much more overt structural deficiency going on in a far more pervasive fashion than what is found on LKML.
Look at the outcome in problem cases- whereas in a contained social environment- a business- the containment ends in creative control ending up in the lands of the domineering group, in mailing lists we tend to rampant infighting and shifting lines of battle amongst larger parties. The 1:1 1:few defined hierarchies and political power-games of a business have few clear places we can draw parity to on a highly-trafficed mailing list: dissent resisting the domineering force is highly visible and contested, and conflict spreads as people weigh in and the conversation threads-out and threads are linked into one another.
- mcguire 12y agoYou make a very good point, but I think you may be over-weighting the "chain of command" aspect of the corporate body and under-weighting the "flame-fests are fun, but somebody has to make a decision" aspect of a mailing list discussion. My personal favorite result of the latter are trigraphs in the C standard. Nobody liked them, but nobody argued strongly against them because they were introduced so late.