4 ms·
Oi. I wish the nice designers of Silicon Valley could give some "pull requests" easily to the KDE team. The design is such a mix of things that don't go togethe
by azinman2 12y ago
Oi. I wish the nice designers of Silicon Valley could give some "pull requests" easily to the KDE team. The design is such a mix of things that don't go together -- some places of translucency, others don't, the pop ups are mostly flat yet the calculator has shadows, the search results and bookmarks have borders on every row yet the launch menu doesn't, the spacing between items in the left side of dolphin is off (too close), the icons are seemingly all over the place (the life preserver is more photo realistic while the hard drive is more cartoony), etc.
I know there are mailing lists and whatnot for this but if the process of helping was easier for normal (and good) designers to help out a little I think we all would benefit. Or at least if you're going to copy Apple pay attention to their ratios.
- andmarios 12y agoKDE has a great Visual Design Team. Also they rely on user feedback for their UX design. https://vdesign.kde.org/ https://vdesign.kde.org/
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "I wish the nice designers of Silicon Valley could give some "pull requests" easily to the KDE team. The design is such a mix of things that don't go together" Is this maybe due to the nature of open source? If you look at the big design teams in SV they are typically run by a dictator (e.g. Jony Ive or Duartes at Google). Maybe for good design that's necessary or you end up with a large mix of conflicting ideas.
- hysan 12y agoIt's actually very easy to contribute to the design process. Especially for this entire redesign. It was announced right from the start on the website / blog, the mentioned Visual Design Group website was put up, they created a subforum for design discussion and input (very active and so easy that even I, a non-designer, was able to participate), and they regularly posted detailed updates on the design process asking for feedback (sometimes in the form of polls). So I'm not quite sure how much easier you are expecting the process to be.
- donniezazen 12y agoI am looking forward to your constructive criticism here [1] [1] https://forum.kde.org/viewforum.php?f=285 https://forum.kde.org/viewforum.php?f=285
- anonbanker 12y agoman, it sounds like you're describing OS X Yosemite.