2 ms·
> Ha, looks like my opinions hurt someone's feelings and got downvoted. Meh. Yeah, stupid, have an upvote! > Haha, I'm glad we can civilly hate each other's p
by wvenable 12y ago
> Ha, looks like my opinions hurt someone's feelings and got downvoted. Meh.
Yeah, stupid, have an upvote!
> Haha, I'm glad we can civilly hate each other's preferences. To me, repeating the menu strip for each window is a waste of real-estate, but i'm a huge desktop space whore. I don't need "File, Edit, etc" on every program window.
Well a lot of programs are ditching having a menu bar at all. This Firefox window I'm typing this into is really minimal -- no menu at all. If you're a desktop space whore than this is better than both options. I feel like the Mac way makes sense when desktop space is at a premium (like with the original Mac) but I have more desktop space than I know what to do with!
> Actually, I find myself getting confused the other way around. In Windows, if I step away from my desk, and come back, it's not clear to me which program is currently active
That's a valid point. After getting distracted, I've typed into the wrong window in my multi-monitor desktop because the wrong app has focus. But I don't think I'd be any more likely to look in the very top left corner of one monitor to see which one is active either. In a single monitor situation, this is almost a non-issue.
> I feel like the root of our different workflows has as lot to do with the fact that I prefer to autohide my taskbars
Yeah, I don't autohide but I do make them smaller than the current Windows default.
> As long as those two remain intertwined concepts in Windows, it's going to feel less logical to me (in my opinion of course).
This is a totally valid point and I don't have a good argument against it. But I think it comes with the baggage of having that single top menu bar which I think is much less logical. But I'm not sure if it's possible to reconcile these things. I will say that Office has probably the worst window management of any application on Windows but thankfully I usually only have one document open at a time. Ironically, NextStep has menus in each app and this was removed when it became OS X to make the transition easier for users.
> So far, I feel pretty keyboard-warrior-y just as much as I was on Windows.
I'm actually more of a mouse person or perhaps more accurately a combo mouse/keyboard. But strangely enough, my file management workflow is weirdly hampered on OS X. I found a few apps that just wouldn't let me CTRL-C CTRL-V a file into them, for example. I'm willing to concede if I used nothing but the keyboard, the Finder might be better but in my usage I just find it frustrating.