3 ms·
I don't think this rumor is true. The US market is not well suited to selling phones retail. I don't see how Google can sell a smartphone that is considered "c
by eli 17y ago
I don't think this rumor is true.
The US market is not well suited to selling phones retail. I don't see how Google can sell a smartphone that is considered "cheap" without being able to recoup anything in carrier subsidies. HTC smartphones retail for $400 and up without a subsidy. (For example, Google charges $400 for the developer version of the G1, but T-Mobile can sell it for $50 with a new contract)
Secondly, how is one phone going to work on Verizon and AT&T? Even if Google limits itself to GSM networks, AT&T and T-Mobile use different frequencies for 3G. Will they make an edition for each carrier?
I think Google is just creating one or more netbooks or "mobile internet devices" and this analyst (the only source in the story) got confused and thought it was a phone.
- zach 17y agoThis may be true but I don't think this is in the US. That detail was perhaps assumed but not announced in the article, and this is sourced from "design partners" who wouldn't know. It would make a lot of sense for Google to sell their own phone in many territories besides the US, though, so I wouldn't discount it as a possibility worldwide. But it's a lot less interesting than what people would assume from the title.
- Andys 17y agoMost phones sold in other parts of the world are available unlocked and supporting multiple 3G frequency bands without much trouble.
- eli 17y agoSure, but it also means that people routinely shell out 5x more for a fancy new phone than we do. And it's not just competing frequency bands, it's competing technologies. AT&T has WCDMA, but Sprint and Verizon do CDMA2000. T-Mobile has HSDPA. These things don't work together. Compare that to Europe and Asia where WCDMA will get you quite far. It's entirely the FCC's fault for letting the "market decide" what 3G standard we should use instead of just mandating one like every other country. But I digress.
- notauser 17y agoWe generally pay less for phones than the US, we just pay it up front instead of over time. It's cheaper because we avoid paying interest and carrier mark up on what is essentially a loan for the hardware. You wouldn't think it was a good deal buying a computer on punitive finance terms, why is it such a good deal for phones?
- mbrubeck 17y agoBelieve me, many of us in the US do understand that. But its not like the major US carriers will offer us a discounted service if we bring our own unlocked phones. So if you pay for your own phone and then buy a standard US service plan, you still end up subsidizing everyone else's handsets... This is why it's notable when Wal-Mart gets into the no-contract service plan game.
- known 17y agoInstead of squeezing netbook features into a cellphone, I think it is prudent to integrate cellphone in netbook.
- nimbix 17y agoI envision a cellphone that can be docked inside some kind of a netbook shell. The phone holds all the essential hardware, but the netbook shell provides a bigger battery, a keyboard and a larger screen. Take both or only the phone with you, depending on your needs that day. And you'd never need to sync files and contacts between your phone and netbook, because they'd be the same device. Something like this can't bee too far off.
- notauser 17y agoI'm afraid you are wrong about GSM network support. Integrated chipsets commonly have support for 4/5 bands and EDGE+HSPDA on board no matter what features the manufacturer turns on. In fact there are a couple of really cheap phones out there that have chipset support for WiFi and Bluetooth because it's cheaper than getting a custom chip set! Obviously the antennas (and drivers) supplied change which frequencies/networks you can actually use, but even the iPhone has support for multiple GSM bands - you can jail break it and drop pretty much any GSM sim in it. GSM vs CDMA is a different matter, although there are a few handsets with enough hardware to do it including some from RIM. Those do tend to be expensive but I imagine that has more to do with licenses than hardware costs these days. (By the way $400 phone with no contract is cheaper than $50 phone with a typical 2 year $50/month plan. To use the UK as a suitable example a reasonable plan would cost about $50/month with a phone or $25/month without. That's a saving of $600 to put towards the cost of the handset.)
- mbrubeck 17y agoThis might just be the next version of the Android Dev Phone. It makes sense for Google to provide a reference for both of its new operating systems, but it that doesn't necessarily mean they want to compete in the retail market.